Frances Fox Piven, the City University of New York sociologist best known for her work on the Poor People's Movements (which led to her being centre piece Glenn Beck the Right-wing attack dog), turned her attention last week to an oft-repeated question: "Can American labor recover?" Her short answer was might be: Maybe (I hope so), but not on its own, and not without a push from outside.
Piven's take on the labor movement is not peculiar to her alone, but rather is emblematic of a section of the left, academic and otherwise. Which I guess is not surprising, given the distance between the world of the university and the world of working people.
In any case, the left, including the academic left, should be knowledgeable about the labor movement. It should hail and join its initiatives.
This doesn't preclude criticism, but it should be done in a constructive, unifying, and partisan way. It should be always mindful not only of the very difficult circumstances in which labor fights, but also the necessary role that it will play in any progressive and socialist thrust in U.S. politics.Sam Webb People's World