Both Things Are True Crime

Both Things Are True Crime

Download on the App Store

All Both Things Are True Crime episodes

  • Part 3 | Connick v. Thompson Explained: John Thompson and the $14 Million Verdict

    John Thompson spent 14 years on death row because a New Orleans prosecutor's office hid a lab report. A jury awarded him $14 million. The Supreme Court took it back.

    Ray Liuzza Jr. was shot outside his New Orleans home in December 1984. John Thompson was convicted and sent to death row, and he was acquitted in 35 minutes in 2003 once the hidden blood test came out. Then I explain what happened next: why you can't sue a prosecutor personally (Imbler v. Pachtman), how a lawsuit against the office works (section 1983 and Monell), and why the Supreme Court said the office owed him nothing in Connick v. Thompson, 5 to 4.

    This is the last of three in my Brady series. The family that was told in 1985 who killed Ray was told in 2003 that it was not him, and I keep that part of the story in the room.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #ConnickvThompson #JohnThompson #BothThingsAreTrueCrime

    24 min
  • Michael Morton Case: Christine Morton Murder and the Brady Violation Part 2

    Christine Morton was killed in her bed in Texas in 1986, and her husband Michael spent nearly 25 years in prison while the prosecutor held evidence that pointed away from him.

    The prosecutor had their young son's account, a green van and her credit card in his file. The jury never heard about any of it. I tell the Michael Morton case in order, explain how Brady works in real life, and cover the bandana that finally freed him, the prosecutor who went to jail, and the Michael Morton Act that changed Texas law.

    This is part two of three in my Brady series. Christine Morton is the center of this one, and I say her name first and last.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #MichaelMorton #WrongfulConviction #BothThingsAreTrueCrime

    22 min
  • Brady v. Maryland Explained: The Confession in the Drawer

    Brady v. Maryland explained through the case behind it: William Brooks, a new car in 1958, and a confession a prosecutor never handed over.

    In June 1958, William Brooks was killed in Maryland for his new car. One of the men convicted, John Brady, never saw the other man's confession before trial. That hidden statement became Brady v. Maryland, the Supreme Court rule that prosecutors have to hand over evidence that helps the defense.

    This is part one of three in my Brady series. I start with Mr. Brooks, walk through the case in order, and explain the rule in plain English so you can spot a Brady violation the next time you watch a trial. Part two is Michael Morton in Texas. Part three is John Thompson in New Orleans.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #BradyvMaryland #TrueCrimeLaw #BothThingsAreTrueCrime


    23 min
  • Fannie Lou Hamer Story: Sick and Tired of Being Sick and Tired

    A Mississippi sharecropper learned at 44 that she could vote. Then the state came for her body, her vote and her voice.

    Fannie Lou Hamer was sterilized without her consent, evicted for registering to vote, and beaten in the Winona jail, and the five men tried for it were acquitted. I tell her full story, from the cotton fields to the 1964 Democratic convention in Atlantic City, and what the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party was asking for.

    Black women carried the civil rights movement and are the least told in it. This one is hers.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #FannieLouHamer #CivilRights #BothThingsAreTrueCrime

    31 min
  • Diddy Trial Explained: The Mann Act and Any Other Immoral Purpose

    Sean Combs was acquitted of racketeering and sex trafficking and convicted under a law signed in 1910.

    I follow that law from Jack Johnson to a Manhattan jury, then through his sentence, his appeal, and the prison rules that reportedly cost him 41 days. I explain the Mann Act, RICO and acquitted conduct in plain English, and what the verdict does and does not say.

    Both things are true here: the jury did not convict on the biggest counts, and the conviction that stands rests on a very old law. I stay with what's in the record and say out loud when a part is my opinion.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #DiddyTrial #SeanCombs #BothThingsAreTrueCrime

    55 min
  • Gannon Stauch Case Part 2: The Juror Who Reversed the Verdict

    In 2023 a Colorado jury found Letecia Stauch sane and guilty of killing her stepson Gannon. In 2026 an appeals court reversed it over one juror.

    That juror's son-in-law worked for the DA. I explain implied bias, structural error, the insanity defense and competency to stand trial in plain English, and what the Colorado Court of Appeals decided and why it matters. Then I cover where the case stands now.

    This is part two of two. Start with part one if you haven't seen it.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #LeteciaStauch #GannonStauch #BothThingsAreTrueCrime


    44 min
  • Gannon Stauch Case Part 1: The Search (Came In Fighting)

    Gannon Stauch was eleven when he went missing from his Colorado home in January 2020. Seven weeks later he was found in Florida.

    His stepmother, Letecia Stauch, told version after version while his dad begged for answers. I walk through the search, the versions she told as they were told, and how it came together.

    Part two covers the trial, the 2026 appeal and the juror at the center of it. Gannon is the center of this one, and I say his name first and last.

    I'm Jakayla Jewel. I cover true crime the way I think about it, which is that two things are usually true at once. I read the opinions, the transcripts and the filings and explain the law in plain English. The victims are the story. It always looks like a Thursday.

    I'm not a lawyer. This is education and commentary, not legal advice. Anything I call my opinion, I label as mine.

    #GannonStauch #LeteciaStauch #BothThingsAreTrueCrime

    25 min
  • The Last Military Execution Was 1961 | Fort Hood Firing Squad (Part 2 of 2)

    Thirteen people died at Fort Hood, among them Michael Grant Cahill. The method waiting at the end was approved in 1879.

    On October 2, 2026 the President approved the death sentence for the 2009 Fort Hood shooting, and the Army set it for Thursday, December 3, at Fort Hood: a chair, a hood, a paper target and three volunteers fifteen feet away. The last person the American military executed was Private John Bennett, hanged at Fort Leavenworth on April 13, 1961, for a crime in which the victim lived. From 1954 to 1961, eleven of the twelve service members executed were Black.

    Wilkerson v. Utah upheld the firing squad in 1879 because it was not drawing and quartering. Two months later the shooters missed Wallace Wilkerson's heart and he bled to death over twenty-seven minutes. No method has ever been held facially unconstitutional. Under Baze v. Rees, Glossip v. Gross and Bucklew v. Precythe, a prisoner who challenges a method has to name a better way to be killed, which is why prisoners started asking to be shot. Then Mikal Mahdi's 2025 autopsy showed two wounds and no hit to the heart, and Christa Pike survived a failed lethal injection in Tennessee.

    On the institutional question I am a hard no, and this episode is my two reasons. I can believe a person deserves to die and still believe no government should be given the switch.

    Both Things Are True Crime with Jakayla Jewel. Story first, the law where it bites, and the people who were lost at the center. Every fact in this episode is sourced. Subscribe for a new case almost every day.

    #TrueCrime #FortHood #FiringSquad

    48 min
  • Nidal Hasan Tried to Plead Guilty. The Law Said No | Fort Hood (Part 1 of 2)

    Michael Grant Cahill and twelve others died at Fort Hood on a Thursday. The Army set the execution for a Thursday too.

    November 5, 2009 was paperwork day at the Soldier Readiness Processing Center, the building where soldiers get their shots, sign their wills and talk about whether they are okay. An Army psychiatrist shot forty-five people there. Thirteen died, among them a psychologist, a psychiatric nurse and a PTSD specialist. On October 2, 2026 the President signed the death sentence, and the Army set the date: December 3, 2026, at Fort Hood.

    Military justice is its own country. Article 45(b) of the Uniform Code of Military Justice would not let him plead guilty, because in a capital case the government has to prove it out loud. He represented himself under Faretta v. California, nobody was allowed to argue for his life, and thirteen officers voted unanimously for death in under two hours. Article 57 makes it the only sentence in American law that needs the President's own signature. And habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. 2241 is why Ronald Gray, approved for execution in 2008, is still alive.

    I answer the moral question here and name the institutional one. The most carefully built death sentence in America did not move for sixty-five years, and then it moved in sixty-two days. Thirteen names at the end.

    Both Things Are True Crime with Jakayla Jewel. Story first, the law where it bites, and the people who were lost at the center. Every fact in this episode is sourced. Subscribe for a new case almost every day.

    #TrueCrime #FortHood #NidalHasan

    39 min
  • Bart and Krista Halderson: The Fake College Lie | Chandler Halderson Case

    Bart and Krista Halderson's son said they had gone to the cabin up north. Both of their cars were in the garage.

    On July 7, 2021, Chandler Halderson, 23, called the Dane County Sheriff's Office in Windsor, Wisconsin and reported his parents missing. For about a year he had kept his parents believing he was a full-time student, with fake Madison College counselors built out of Gmail accounts, a fake job and a story about SpaceX. On June 29 Bart called the college and found out. On July 1 he texted his son, "I'm ready when you are." On July 8 Bart's remains were found on a farm in Cottage Grove, and his son was arrested, not for murder, but for lying.

    The law: how Wisconsin proves first-degree intentional homicide with no confession, no eyewitness and, for Krista, no cause of death. Why lying to police about a missing person is its own crime in Wisconsin. Why his silence at trial, protected under Griffin v. California, made no difference. And the multiplicity rule that took two convictions off his sheet in 2023 and changed nothing. The jury convicted him on all eight counts in a little over two hours, and he was sentenced to life with no possibility of release.

    Where I land: his silence cost him nothing, and he had not been silent for three years. Bart and Krista are the center of this one.

    Both Things Are True Crime with Jakayla Jewel. Story first, the law where it bites, and the people who were lost at the center. Every fact in this episode is sourced. Subscribe for a new case almost every day.

    #TrueCrime #BartAndKristaHalderson #ChandlerHalderson

    38 min