In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we delve into the haunting story of Centralia, Pennsylvania—a once-thriving mining town now abandoned due to an underground coal fire that's been burning since 1962. Discover firsthand accounts from residents who lived through the disaster, explore eerie photographs of the desolate landscape, and uncover archival newspaper clippings that chronicle the town's tragic decline.

Click here for Survivor Stories

Click here for historical Newspaper Clippings

We're back after a summer full of traveling! A well-dressed man steps off a plane in Tokyo in 1960 carrying a passport from a country no one has ever heard of, speaking multiple languages, and claiming an urgent mission. The problem? His homeland does not exist.

In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we explore the strange case of John Allen Kuchar Zegrus, the man who insisted he was a diplomat from a place called Tamanrasset. Was he a Cold War spy, a master con artist, or something far stranger?

You’ll hear about the real Japanese court records, the gaps in his story, and how the tale evolved into one of the most famous urban legends on the internet: The Man from Taured, said to be a traveler from a parallel universe. Was it a government cover up, a mental break, or a glitch in reality itself?

In a quiet Ohio town, residents began receiving anonymous, threatening letters that revealed their darkest secrets. These weren’t just rumors—they were specific, chilling, and relentless. From affairs to attempted murder, the Circleville Letters saga escalated into one of the most baffling and eerie unsolved mysteries in American history.

For nearly two decades, the anonymous author tormented the people of Circleville with hundreds of letters. Even after a suspect was convicted, the letters didn’t stop. So who was behind them? A jealous neighbor? A shadowy conspiracy? Or something even darker?

FBI & Local Law Records (Declassified Documents):

Visit vault.fbi.gov and search “Circleville Letters” for redacted case files and correspondence.

On a remote, wind-lashed slope in Russia’s Ural Mountains, nine young hikers vanished into legend. In February 1959, what began as a routine expedition turned into one of the most haunting cold cases in modern history—the Dyatlov Pass Incident. Their tent was found slashed open from the inside. Their bodies scattered, mutilated, and frostbitten. Theories abound—from avalanches and secret military tests to stranger, more terrifying possibilities

This episode of Brewed and Bewildered honors the memory of the nine lives lost and the questions they left behind:

Igor Dyatlov, 23 – expedition leader, radio engineering student

Yuri (Georgiy) Krivonischenko, 23 – construction and hydraulics student

Lyudmila Dubinina, 20 – economics student

Zinaida Kolmogorova, 22 – radio engineering student

Rustem Slobodin, 23 – mechanical engineer

Nikolai Thibeaux-Brignolles, 23 – civil construction student

Alexander Kolevatov, 24 – nuclear physics student

Yuri Doroshenko, 21 – radio engineering student

Semyon Zolotaryov, 38 – WWII veteran, hiking instructor

The Dyatlov Group Memorial Foundation (official):

dyatlovpass.com — Features detailed case files, personal diaries, photographs, autopsy reports, maps, and interviews with investigators and family members.

#DyatlovPass #TrueCrimePodcast #ColdCase #RussianMysteries #BrewedAndBewildered #UnsolvedMystery #ParanormalPodcast #AvalancheTheory #DyatlovIncident #MysteryLovers #PodcastRecommendation

Step inside the infamous 284 Green Street and uncover the chilling story of The Enfield Poltergeist—a case that shook 1970s England and still sparks debate today. Was it a real haunting, a clever hoax, or a psychological breakdown captured on camera? In Episode 10 of Brewed and Bewildered, Jess delves into the eerie events, firsthand accounts, and hidden truths behind one of the most extensively documented paranormal investigations in history. Perfect for fans of The Conjuring 2, true crime, and supernatural mysteries.

On a quiet Minnesota night in May 2008, 19-year-old Brandon Swanson vanished after his car veered into a ditch, just moments after a chilling final phone call with his parents. Despite an extensive search, no trace of him was ever found.

In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we explore the baffling mystery that continues to haunt investigators, from eerie cell phone pings to theories of foul play, accidental death, and possible abduction. Was Brandon lost in the dark, or was something more sinister at play?

Let's unravel one of America’s most puzzling missing persons cases and its lasting impact on the law and those left behind.

On January 15, 1947, a young woman’s severed body was discovered in a Los Angeles vacant lot—drained of blood, surgically mutilated, and eerily posed. The victim? 22-year-old Elizabeth Short. The press named her The Black Dahlia, and the mystery surrounding her death would grip America for decades.

In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we explore the brutal crime that became one of the most infamous unsolved murders in U.S. history. Who was Elizabeth Short, and why did her death spark such public obsession? Was the killer a doctor, a serial murderer, or someone protected by the powerful?

We examine the most chilling theories—from Dr. George Hodel and LAPD cover-ups to links with the Cleveland Torso Murders. But beyond the headlines, we remember Elizabeth not as a spectacle—but as a real person whose story deserves dignity.

On Christmas Eve, 1945, a mysterious fire destroyed the Sodder family home in Fayetteville, West Virginia. Five of the ten Sodder children vanished without a trace. Despite no remains being found in the ashes, authorities declared them dead, but the truth may be far more disturbing.

In this episode, we unravel one of America’s most haunting mysteries. Were the Sodder children kidnapped? What about the cut phone lines, the silent fire truck, and the strange photograph sent decades later?

Join us as we investigate this chilling true crime case that still baffles experts and haunts listeners worldwide.

Want to learn more or see the evidence for yourself? Check out these in-depth resources:

• Smithsonian Magazine – The Children Who Went Up in Smoke
• FBI Vault: The Sodder Children Disappearance

Off the coast of Denmark, beneath the icy waters of the North Sea, lies a mysterious submerged site—possibly an ancient Viking city lost to time. In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we dive deep into the mystery as divers uncover Viking-age tools, pottery, and structures buried beneath the seabed. But the story doesn’t end there.

Some artifacts may date back to the Mesolithic era, suggesting this site could be far older than anyone imagined. Was it a Viking fishing village? A ritual site? Or the remnants of a forgotten prehistoric civilization swallowed by the sea?

Join us as we explore the evidence, the legends, and the science behind one of Europe’s most intriguing underwater mysteries.

In 1587, over 100 English settlers vanished from Roanoke Island—leaving behind no bodies, no signs of struggle, and only a single word carved into a post: CROATOAN. What happened to the Lost Colony? In this episode of Brewed and Bewildered, we unravel one of America’s most enduring historical mysteries. Explore the real story behind Roanoke through colonial records, recent archaeological discoveries, and the leading theories—from assimilation with Native tribes to hostile encounters and deadly relocation attempts.Perfect for fans of unsolved mysteries, American history, and true crime podcasts, this episode digs deep into the roots of early colonial America—and a disappearance that still haunts the timeline.