The Sinister and Calculating Case of Catherine Foster — a true crime story of a teenage bride, poisoned dumplings, and the chilling calm that sent her to the gallows.
What if the most disturbing thing about a murder wasn't the act itself, but the complete absence of remorse in the face of it?
In this episode, we dive into the case of Catherine Foster, born Catherine Morley in 1829, a "simple-minded" servant girl from Acton, Suffolk, who married farm labourer John Foster on 28 October 1846. She was seventeen. He was twenty-four. They had known each other for years, and he was eager to marry mainly to escape his mother's crowded household. Just three weeks later, on 17 November 1846, Catherine made him suet dumplings laced with arsenic. He ate around six o'clock, fell violently ill almost immediately, and died before four the next afternoon. The arsenic was later found in his stomach, and the chickens that pecked at his vomit in the yard died too. The most damning testimony came from Catherine's eight-year-old brother Thomas, who told the court he saw her empty a small paper packet into the dumpling mixture and throw the paper into the fire. The jury took fifteen minutes to convict her. She was hanged at Bury St Edmunds on 23 April 1847, before a crowd of ten thousand. But what truly unsettled everyone—the newspapers, the chaplain, the crowd—was not the crime. It was her face. She betrayed no emotion. Not at the verdict, not at the sentence, not on the scaffold. The press called her cold and calculating. Some modern writers have wondered if she was simple-minded, or if she simply felt nothing at all. We explore the forensic evidence, the poisoned dumplings, the dead chickens, the brother's testimony, and the question that has never been answered: why did a seventeen-year-old girl with no apparent motive kill her husband of three weeks? Perfect for true crime fans, history enthusiasts, and anyone drawn to the darkest corners of the human mind. Turn off the lights, and whatever you do — don't eat the dumplings. Listen now… if you dare.