On November 9, 1971 John List murdered his entire family at their home in New Jersey, including his wife, three children and his mother. He then packs up and starts his life anew under an assumed identity where he even manages to remarry! John List is hiding in plain sight under his fake persona for 18 years before America's Most Wanted features him in an episode in 1989. With the expertise of Frank Bender and his remarkably accurate age progressed bust of John List, the episode is seen by 22 million people, resulting in the one phone call they were hoping to get... The one which led to the arrest of John List.