It was a Thursday morning in December. The kind of morning when St. Anthony, Newfoundland, a fishing village of 2500 people, clinging to the northern tip of the island, is still pitch black at a quarter to seven.
Inside the house at 8 Husky Drive, fifteen-year-old Deana Penney woke to a persistent noise. It was her mother's phone alarm, ringing from the kitchen. She banged on the bedroom door. No answer. She opened it. Nobody inside.
She walked through the house. Her mother's phone was on the counter. Her purse was on the table. Her keys were still in the ignition of her car, parked in the driveway. Her shoes were at the door.
Everything was set down, Deana would later tell a jury, as though her mother had just arrived home and left it all behind.
Deana called her grandmother. Ruby Penney came over within 20 minutes. Ruby called her son, Deana’s father, Dean Penney, who drove in from his hunting cabin right away.
But Jennifer Hillier-Penney was gone. She was thirty-eight years old. A mother of two. And she would never be seen again.
For seven years, nobody was charged. For seven years, her family fought to keep her face in the public eye, plastering posters across town while the RCMP conducted searches over land and sea, coming up with nothing.
And then, in December of 2023, Dean Penney was arrested at the Deer Lake airport. What the public didn't know, what almost nobody knew, was that the RCMP had spent the previous four years running one of the most elaborate undercover operations in Canadian history to get him to talk.
They built an entire criminal empire around him. They gave him a best friend. They took him on heists, diamond runs, and gun deals from Newfoundland to Alberta to British Columbia. They paid him $27,000. And in the end, on a yacht in Vancouver harbour, exactly seven years to the day his wife disappeared, Dean Penney sat across from a man he believed was a mob boss, and told him what happened that night.
Or did he?
That is the question a jury of twelve spent four days deliberating, after an eight-week trial that gripped the province.
Send us Fan Mail
www.canadiancrimecast.com