This week Cassie and Marc are back at it again with another cult story and this cult may be the craziest of all the cults we've covered so far! The LeBaron family and their various churches have been in existence for almost 100 years and during that time, they managed to kill upwards of fifty people. So, strap in and prepare to be aghast and horrified. Did we mention this cult is STILL around today??

Submit questions and case suggestions HERE.

Email us at: [email protected]

Contact us by mail at:

P.O. Box 903

Solvang, CA 93464

Source Material:

Church of the Firstborn (LeBaron family)

A Family’s Legacy of Death

Rena Chynoweth

Polygamous murderer denied parole

Ervil LeBaron

The Colony: Faith and Blood in a Promise - Sally Denton

In March of 2012, Kathy Young was shocked when she awoke at 5 AM and her 21-year-old daughter Molly was nowhere to be found. Only 5 hours later, Molly's family would discover that Molly had driven to her ex-boyfriend's house in the middle of the night and taken her own life. However, it quickly became apparent that something wasn't adding up. Molly's ex-boyfriend claimed to have slept through the gunshot, although it occurred only inches from him. The gun belonged to Molly's ex-boyfriend and was found underneath her body. And her ex-boyfriend's DNA was found under her fingernails. Was Molly's death really self-inflicted? Or was it the work of something sinister? 

Submit questions and case suggestions HERE.

Email us at: [email protected]

Contact us by mail at:

P.O. Box 903

Solvang, CA 93464

Source Material:

10 years later: The Molly Young case remains open as family grieves, seeks justice

Justice For Molly: Family still searching for answers ten years after daughter's death

Crime Watch Daily investigates the controversial death of Molly Young

Still A Mystery - Season 1, Episode 2

This week Cassie and Marc finish up their coverage of the Ammons family and finally get down to the nitty gritty of what actually occurred during the four separate exorcisms Latoya received. Yes, you read that right, FOUR complete exorcisms. You seriously can't make this one up. 

Submit questions or case suggestions HERE.

Email us at: [email protected]

Send mail to: PO Box 903, Solvang, California, 93464

Source Materials:

Demon House

The Exorcisms of Latoya Ammons - IndyStar

This week Cassie and Marc cover possibly their craziest case yet! In 2011, Latoya Ammons and her family moved into a home in Gary, Indiana. They quickly discovered that the house was not all that it appeared. Supernatural happenings began occurring and before the family knew it, there was evidence that some sort of malevolent being was possessing them.

Submit questions or case suggestions HERE.

Email us at: [email protected]

Send mail to: PO Box 903, Solvang, California, 93464

Source Materials:

Demon House

The Exorcisms of Latoya Ammons - IndyStar

Marc could not record this week due to some family commitments, but Cassie's best friend Kimberly graciously stepped in to fill his shoes. Join them as they discuss the mysterious Bennington Triangle. An area of the Vermont wilderness with an unusual amount of supernatural activity, disappearances, and murders. Is it pure coincidence? Or the work of something far more sinister?

Submit questions and case suggestions HERE.

Shoot us an email at [email protected]

Write to us at: PO Box 903, Solvang, CA, 93464

Source Material:

Bennington Triangle

Exploration Mysteries: Bennington Disappearances

Paula Jean Welden

The Vanished Town of Glastenbury and The Bennington Triangle

The Bizarre Spontaneous Vanishing of James Tedford from a Moving Bus

Marc could not record this week due to some family commitments, but Cassie's best friend Kimberly graciously stepped in to fill his shoes. Join them as they discuss the mysterious Bennington Triangle. An area of the Vermont wilderness with an unusual amount of supernatural activity and unsolved murders and disappearances. Is it pure coincidence? Or the work of something more sinister?

Submit questions and case suggestions HERE.

Shoot us an email at [email protected]

Write to us at: PO Box 903, Solvang, California, 93464

Source Material:

Bennington Triangle

Exploration Mysteries: Bennington Disappearances

Paula Jean Welden

The Vanished Town of Glastenbury and The Bennington Triangle

The Bizarre Spontaneous Vanishing of James Tedford from a Moving Bus

Due to an intense amount of traveling and holiday feasting, we didn't get the opportunity to record a new episode this week. But fear not! We didn't want to leave you all empty-handed, so we remastered our first-ever episode, which is no longer available on any of our listening platforms. We have come a long way since then! Happy holidays to everyone and we hope you all get a good chuckle at a time when we had no idea what we were doing yet!

Please submit case suggestions and questions HERE.

Source Materials:

In 2016, the Tromp family fled their home and drove 800km north. We still don't know why.

Tromp family: The mystery of a tech-free road trip gone wrong

During a Thanksgiving gathering in 2011, Paul Michael Merhige inexplicably opened fire on 16 members of his family, killing five and injuring two. Join Cassie and Marc this Thanksgiving season as they discuss what lead up to this ghastly crime and what may or may not have been done in order to prevent it.

Submit questions and case suggestions HERE.

Source Materials:

Paul Michael MERHIGE

Slain Girl's Parents To Sue Thanksgiving Killer's Mom and Dad for Negligence

This week Cassie and Marc discuss the controversial case of Brittany Smith. Brittany was attacked and raped in her own home and shot and killed her attacker. However, some doubted the validity of her story and whether or not Brittany had actually killed Todd Smith in self-defense. Join Cassie and Marc as they dive into the events of this case and decide for yourselves whether or not you believe Brittany to be a victim or a perpetrator. 

Source Material:

Netflix's State of Alabama vs. Brittany Smith

The Shattering Truth: Methamphetamine isn't going anywhere

Brittany Smith Loses Her Stand Your Ground Hearing

This week Cassie and Marc discuss three cases which were solved due to the help of various animals! That's right, in recent years there have been an increase in our furry or feathery friends helping break criminal cases and we are paying homage to their service on our behalf!

Source Materials:

Pet Duck Leads Police to Murder Victim and Elusive Clues: 'If I Could Give That Duck a Medal, I Would'

Sheriff’s Office Says N.C. Couple Charged with Killing Grandmother Sent Deputies on a ‘Wild Goose Chase’ That Was Solved by a Pet Duck

How Animal DNA Puts Killers Behind Bars

Police Say Pet Helped Solve Murder

Murder of Shirley Duguay

Douglas Leo BEAMISH