
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Case Files #385: Mary Day — Seaside, California. Mary Louise Day, 13, vanished from her Seaside home in July 1981 and was never reported missing. When her sisters finally brought police to the case in 2002, cadaver dogs alerted in the family backyard and detectives began building a homicide case against her mother and stepfather — until November 25, 2003, when a Phoenix traffic stop turned up a living woman carrying Mary Day's name and birth date. DNA proved she was Charlotte Houle's daughter, and in 2017 Seaside's acting chief Judy Veloz concluded she was Mary, closing the case. Where she spent the 22 years between, she never said. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #384: Arlis Perry — Stanford, California. Arlis Perry, 19, a newlywed from Bismarck, North Dakota, was found murdered inside Stanford Memorial Church on October 13, 1974, after walking there to pray the night before. The coroner recorded her cause of death as a penetrating stab wound to the cranium. The case stayed open for 44 years. In 2016, investigators discovered the jeans held in evidence as hers were actually her husband's — her own had never been tested. DNA from her jeans matched Stephen Crawford, the security guard who reported finding her body. On June 28, 2018, as deputies arrived at his San Jose home with warrants, Crawford died by his own hand; he was never charged or tried. Sheriff Laurie Smith announced the case closed. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #383: The Grissom Family — Shreveport, Louisiana. On November 4, 1989, Tom Grissom, 55, his daughter Julie, 24, and his grandson Sean, 8, were stabbed to death in Tom's home in Southern Hills as the family prepared dinner. Julie's former fiancé, attorney Hal Carter, became the prime suspect; he was never arrested, and police verified he was in Atlanta. Ten months later, five students were murdered in Gainesville, Florida, and detectives recognized the same signature. A Shreveport tip named Danny Rolling, and Louisiana held an arrest warrant for him in the Grissom case from 1994, but he was never tried for it. Convicted of the Gainesville murders, Rolling was executed on October 25, 2006. Hours before his execution, he handed his spiritual adviser a written confession to the Grissom murders, declaring Carter completely innocent and himself alone guilty. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #382: Terri Hollis — Torrance, California. Terri Lynn Hollis, 11, went out near her Torrance home on Thanksgiving Day, November 23, 1972, and never came home. Her body was found the next morning on the rocks below the Pacific Coast Highway near Point Mugu, some seventy miles away, and the medical examiner concluded she had been strangled. Torrance detectives ran some 2,000 interviews and preserved the DNA evidence; it drew no match in CODIS in 2004, but in 2018 genetic genealogy by Parabon NanoLabs pointed to Jake Edward Brown, who had died in Arizona in 2003. Police exhumed Brown from a Maricopa County cemetery, and DNA from a bone fragment matched the 1972 evidence — a one in twenty septillion match, announced by Torrance Police Chief Eve Irvine on September 11, 2019. Brown was never charged or tried; he is the man the DNA identified. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #381: Sofia Silva, Kristin Lisk & Kati Lisk — Spotsylvania County, Virginia. Sofia Silva, 16, vanished from her front porch on September 9, 1996, and was found five weeks later in a King George County creek. Sisters Kristin Lisk, 15, and Kati Lisk, 12, were taken from their home on May 1, 1997, and found in the South Anna River. A neighbor indicted for Sofia's murder was cleared when the fiber evidence behind his indictment collapsed. Five years later, Kara Robinson, 15, escaped Richard Marc Evonitz in South Carolina and led police to his apartment; FBI Laboratory examiners then matched his hairs and fibers to all three girls and raised Kristin's fingerprints from inside his trunk lid. On August 13, 2002, the task force announced all three murders solved. Evonitz died in Florida in June 2002, never charged and never tried. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #380: Vanessa Guillén — Fort Hood, Texas. Specialist Vanessa Guillén, 20, of Houston, vanished on April 22, 2020, after reporting to the Fort Hood arms room where she worked as a small arms and artillery repairer. Her remains were found near the Leon River on June 30, 2020; the autopsy findings summarized in a Texas Department of Public Safety report filed in federal court showed multiple blunt force injuries to her skull, and the death was a homicide. Army CID and federal prosecutors named fellow soldier Aaron David Robinson, who died by suicide on July 1, 2020, before he could be arrested or tried; he was never charged. Cecily Anne Aguilar pleaded guilty to accessory to murder after the fact and three false-statement counts and was sentenced on August 14, 2023, to the maximum thirty years. The Army later confirmed Vanessa had been sexually harassed by a different superior, and her name now stands on federal reforms to military justice. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #376: Grace Millane — Auckland, New Zealand. Grace Millane, 21, a British backpacker, was last seen on December 1, 2018, entering the CityLife Hotel in Auckland with Jesse Kempson, a man she had matched with on Tinder that day. Her body was found on December 9 in a suitcase buried in the Waitakere Ranges. The Crown pathologist gave the cause of death as pressure to the neck, and both pathologists agreed that fatal pressure takes five to ten minutes. A jury convicted Kempson of murder on November 22, 2019, and he was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum of seventeen years. His name was suppressed for two years while he faced further trials; he was also convicted of offenses against a former partner and of raping another woman he had met on Tinder, and his appeals have been dismissed. Grace's family founded the Love Grace charity for women fleeing abuse. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #367: Anthony Mims — Memphis, Tennessee. Anthony "Big Jook" Mims, 47, the older brother of rapper Yo Gotti and a behind-the-scenes figure at the Collective Music Group (CMG) label, was shot and killed on Saturday, January 13, 2024, outside Perignons Restaurant and Event Center on Winchester Road in Memphis, where he had attended a repast following the funeral of a relative earlier that day. Another man was wounded and survived. Mims was pronounced dead at the hospital. Memphis police said they believed the shooting was targeted and released surveillance images of a vehicle they believe was involved, a white Ford Explorer with black wheels and dark tinted windows. No one has ever been arrested or charged, and the case remains unsolved. At the 2024 trial of Justin Johnson for the murder of Young Dolph, prosecutors alleged — and a witness testified — that Mims had offered a $100,000 bounty on Dolph; Mims was never charged with anything in connection with Dolph's death, and police have never announced a motive for Mims's own killing. Tips: Memphis Crime Stoppers, 901-528-CASH (2274). Can you help solve this crime? The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #368: Madeline Soto — Kissimmee, Florida. Madeline Soto, 13, was reported missing on February 26, 2024, after she never arrived at Hunter's Creek Middle School. Her mother's boyfriend, Stephan Sterns, said he had dropped her off that morning. During the search, detectives searched his phone and arrested him on sex charges; prosecutors later filed a 60-count sex-crimes case against him. On March 1, 2024, investigators announced they believed Madeline had been killed in the family's Kissimmee home, and search teams found her body that day in a wooded area off Hickory Tree Road near St. Cloud. A grand jury indicted Sterns for first-degree murder, and the state sought the death penalty. On July 21, 2025, the day before his first trial, Sterns pleaded no contest to the murder and guilty to 20 counts of sex offenses. Judge Keith Carsten sentenced him to 21 concurrent life sentences without parole, and Sterns waived all rights to appeal. Madeline's mother, Jennifer Soto, has never been charged in the case. The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.
Case Files #365: Kortne Stouffer — Palmyra, Pennsylvania. Kortne Ciera Stouffer, 21, vanished from her apartment at 810 West Main Street in Palmyra in the early morning of Sunday, July 29, 2012. Police answered a disturbance call at her door at 3:12 a.m. and cleared the scene at 3:49; when officers knocked again at 4:31, no one answered. The friend who had stayed on her couch woke at about 7:30 a.m. and Kortne was gone — her car, keys, purse, phone and shoes left behind, and her dog Sheba still inside. There was no blood and no sign of a struggle. Her boyfriend was in custody all night on a probation violation; the friends who were with her that night were questioned repeatedly, and investigators have never named a suspect or charged anyone in her disappearance. Her case remains open and active, and her family offers a $100,000 reward. Tips: Lebanon County Detective Bureau, 717-228-4403; Western Lebanon County Regional Police Department, 717-838-8189. Can you help find Kortne? The truth is in the files. At Autopsyfiles.org.