Rita and Alicia discuss theories on the same day that we learn of a major break in the case. 

Rita tells Alicia about the murder mystery that has haunted her ever since she saw an odd thing on the Ocean Parkway.

Rita and Alicia debate what happened to Brandon. Did he drown? Was he trafficked? Or is farm equipment to blame?

Alicia tells Rita about Brandon Swanson, a college student who disappeared while on the phone with his dad. Rita learns where Michigan is.  

Alicia and Rita discuss the prevailing theories as to the identity and cause of death of Norway's Isdal Woman. 

Alicia tells Rita about the enduring mystery of the Isdal Woman, a Jane Doe and possible murder victim who smelled like garlic and had a shit ton of fake passports. 

In Episode 4, Rita and Alicia discuss who was harassing the Broaddus family via snail mail. Answer: basically anyone, since it turns out snail mail is quite hard to track. 

It's every suburbanite's nightmare, and yet another reason to avoid New Jersey—the story of The Watcher House. Rita and Alicia discuss the creepy tale and admire the pajamas Naomi Watts wore in the Netflix version. 

Listen as Rita and Alicia discuss all the theories as to what happened to the nine skiers who perished in the Dylatov Pass incident, from avalanches to Yetis and everything in between.

Rita tells Alicia about the frigid, grisly deaths of nine hikers during Cold War-era Russia. Alicia tells Rita how much she hates skiing.