Alicia and Rita debate the various theories surrounding the disappearance of Asha Degree, and determine Reddit is usually right about everything. 

Alica tells Rita the very sad story of Asha Degree, a nine-year-old girl who packed up and left her home one night, never to be seen again. 

Rita and Alicia ponder who could've stolen millions of art from a sleepy art museum in Boston, and learn of an intriguing update that might lead us to where the art is today. 

Alicia tells Rita about the most infamous and costly art heist of all time, a rather sloppy affair that somehow remains unsolved. 

Alicia and Rita dig into the evidence that looks both good and bad for Ian Bailey, and other suspects that slipped through the Garda's fingers. 

Rita tells Alicia about a shocking murder in rural Ireland. No one has ever been arrested for the crime, but locals are convinced their super annoying neighbor is behind it. 

Alicia and Rita discuss whether Greg's brother Zach should have been convicted in his murder and look at possible other suspects.

Rita tells Alicia the tragic case of a boy convicted of murdering his own brother. Despite almost 20 years in prison, he's always sworn his innocence. 

Did he or didn't he? That is the question Alicia and Rita debate on today's episode about Adnan Syed, convicted of murdering his high school girlfriend. 

Rita and Alicia dig into their favorite court cases, culminating in the court case that got Rita into podcasting, the murder of Hae Min Lee and her sort of convicted murderer, Adnan Syed.