This conversation explores the gap between seminary formation and parish reality—and why that gap is not primarily about missing technical skills, but about human formation, self-knowledge, and shared leadership.
Father Shane Deman explains what seminarians are actually formed to do (preach, sanctify, govern) and why expecting priests to also function as MBAs, HR directors, and marketing experts is both unrealistic and unhealthy. The deeper issue isn’t competency—it’s overload, isolation, and a lack of shared responsibility between priests and the laity.
The episode ultimately argues that renewal stalls when ministry becomes program-driven instead of relationship-driven, and when both priests and parish leaders neglect the basics: prayer, self-awareness, healthy relationships, and trusting others with real responsibility.
—————
Key Takeaways
Priests are formed to shepherd souls, not run corporations. Seminary formation is already full; expecting priests to “just add” business mastery misunderstands the priesthood.
The biggest gap isn’t skills—it’s self-knowledge and security. Healthy leadership flows from knowing one’s limits and inviting others to fill the gaps without fear or defensiveness.
Burnout is usually a breakdown of basics. Sleep, prayer, friendships, accountability, and boundaries are not optional—they are foundational.
Lay leadership is not about taking control, but offering gifts well. The most effective collaboration happens when lay leaders approach priests with humility, clarity, and a desire to serve—not to fix or override.
Renewal grows through relationships, not programs. One-on-one investment, prayer together, and trusted disciple-makers multiply far more fruit than perfectly executed initiatives.