Evelyn Hartley was taken from a babysitting job in her town in La Crosse in 1953. Her case is still unsolved despite media speculation. What happened to Evelyn? 

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube
Our website (support/case suggestions)

Theme Music

In April 2022, 10-year-old Lily Peters was riding her bike home from her aunt's house in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, when she suddenly disappeared. The next morning, her body was found in a wooded area near a popular trail. In this episode, we talk about the heartbreaking details of the case and the arrest.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube
Our website (support/case suggestions)

Theme Music

On October 11, 1993, nine-year-old Stephanie Crane left a bowling alley in Challis, Idaho, for a short walk home and was never seen again. In this episode, we talk about the day she vanished, the mystery. the Custer County Sheriff’s Office is still out there looking for her today. 

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube
Our website (support/case suggestions)

Theme Music

On March 18, 1991, two-year-old Thomas Gibson disappeared from his front yard in rural Oregon — a case that shocked a community and left more questions than answers. His father’s story, contradictions in witness statements, and conflicting investigations make this one of the most haunting unsolved disappearances of the 1990s. Decades later, Thomas’s fate remains unknown.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube
Our website (support/case suggestions)

Theme Music

Back in 2015, 19-year-old Katelin Akens was supposed to fly back to Arizona. She texted her mom saying she was at the airport… but she never got on that plane. Later, her suitcase was found tossed in a ditch. So what really happened to Katelin that day? And who knows more than they’re actually saying?
Also, Trace sometimes goes off the deep end with theories. You never know! (Her possible theories are not fact whatsoever! just thoughts tossed out into the universe.)


To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok

Ashley Young vanished after a night out in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Days later, her dismembered remains were found in her friend Jared Chance’s home. In this episode, we dive into the chilling details, the investigation, and the disturbing role his parents played in the cover-up.

To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok

Ashley Young vanished after a night out in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Days later, her dismembered remains were found in her friend Jared Chance’s home. In this episode, we dive into the chilling details, the investigation, and the disturbing role his parents played in the cover-up.

To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok

Sierra Newbold was just six years old when her life was stolen, kidnapped from her own bed in her home. What happened that night is every parent’s worst nightmare. In this episode, we’re telling Sierra’s story, what we know about that night, and the monster who did it. This one is heavy.

To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok

Sara Porter was murdered by her husband...then he picked up the phone, calmly confessed to 911, and disappeared. Just like that. In this episode, we’re digging into who Sara really was, the disturbing control Butch Knight had over her, and how he’s managed to stay off the radar all these years.
This one’s about power, manipulation, and a woman who deserved way more than the ending she got. Sara deserves justice. 

To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Show notes info (Pics, Sources, Tipline)

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok

Jennifer Morey did everything she was supposed to do. Locked doors. Gated complex. Safe, right? Nope. One night, she woke up to a man with a knife... and what she went through is the stuff of nightmares. But Jennifer fought like hell to survive, and this is her story. We’re breaking down exactly what happened that night, the terrifying details, and how Jennifer refused to become just another statistic. but instead a badass survivor.

To support our show, please consider subscribing to our Patreon! You get early access & ad-free episodes.

Cause of Crime socials: 
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

Theme Music

Trace's socials:
Twitter
Instagram
Tiktok