Good News of Great Joy
Culture of Gospel
Share this with someone in your life who doesn’t know Jesus
Christmas announces that God didn’t step into the world to shame us or control us, but to rescue us from what’s destroying us, heal what’s broken inside us, and give us the life we’ve been longing for. If that kind of hope exists, it’s worth taking a serious look at Jesus.
Sermon Summary
Introduction: The Eucatastrophe of Christmas
Coleton begins with the angelic announcement in Luke 2:8–11, where shepherds—ordinary, overlooked people—are met by the glory of God in the middle of the night.
“There were shepherds living out in the fields nearby… An angel of the Lord appeared to them… ‘Do not be afraid. I bring you good news that will cause great joy for all the people. Today in the town of David a Savior has been born to you; he is the Messiah, the Lord.’” (Luke 2:8–11)
Coleton introduces the idea of eucatastrophe, a term coined by J.R.R. Tolkien, meaning “an unexpected breaking in of goodness that changes everything.” A catastrophe is an unexpected disaster that alters life for the worse; a eucatastrophe is the opposite—unexpected goodness that permanently alters reality for the better.
That, Coleton says, is exactly what the angels are announcing. Christmas is not sentimental nostalgia—it is the declaration that something has happened that changes everything. And the angel insists this news is meant to produce great joy.
Coleton then asks the central question of the message:
Why should the birth of Jesus cause great joy?
1. Jesus Came to Rescue Us from Sin
“Today in the town of David a Savior has been born to you.” (Luke 2:11)
The first word the angel uses to describe Jesus is Savior. Coleton emphasizes that this is not accidental—this is the core announcement of Christmas: a rescuer has come to you.
Matthew clarifies what kind of rescue Jesus brings:
“He will save his people from their sins.” (Matthew 1:21)
Coleton explains that many in Israel expected a rescuer from Roman oppression, but God identified a deeper enemy. From God’s perspective, sin is a greater threat than any external circumstance. Sin is not just rule-breaking; it is a destructive power that poisons life from the inside out.
“The wages of sin is death.” (Romans 6:23)
Sin always pays out in destruction—relationally, emotionally, spiritually.
Coleton illustrates this with a personal story from a home renovation: exposed live wires in the wall when his son Teddy was three years old. He wanted Teddy to obey him—but not simply because “I said so.” The deeper reason was that touching the wire would cause serious harm or even death.
In the same way, God’s commands are not arbitrary. Sin is dangerous. God forbids it because it kills us.
The problem is not just that sin is harmful—it’s that we are drawn to it. Coleton traces this reality through Scripture:
Adam and Eve fixated on the one forbidden tree.
Genesis 6:5 describes humanity’s hearts as bent toward evil.
Romans 7 shows Paul describing sin like an addiction he wants to resist but can’t.
“Who will rescue me from this body that is subject to death?” (Romans 7:24)
Coleton names experiences we all recognize:
Wanting to stop being angry but feeling trapped
Wanting to forgive but being unable
Wanting to stop fearing, lusting, worrying, or discontentment
“Sin is the suicidal abandonment of joy.”
This is why Christmas is good news: Jesus has come to rescue us from the addictive desire to do what destroys us.
Paul answers his own question:
“Thanks be to God, who delivers me through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Romans 7:25)
Through the cross, sin’s power is broken.
“Our old self was crucified with him… that we should no longer be slaves to sin.” (Romans 6:6)
Coleton quotes Jackie Hill Perry:
“When Jesus died and rose, He gave you power to defeat sin… You are not a slave. You are free. You just have to believe that and walk in it.”
—
Jackie Hill Perry, Gay Girl, Good GodJesus doesn’t just forgive sin—He breaks its authority and reshapes our desires.
2. Jesus Came to Give Us an Abundant Kind of Life
The angel also calls Jesus the Messiah—His job reminder, not just His title.
Coleton walks through Isaiah 61, the Messiah’s job description:
“The Spirit of the Sovereign Lord is on me… to proclaim good news to the poor… bind up the brokenhearted… proclaim freedom for the captives… bestow on them a crown of beauty instead of ashes…” (Isaiah 61:1–3)
This describes a life transformed—not patched up, but renewed.
Jesus explicitly claims this mission in Luke 4, declaring that Isaiah’s prophecy is fulfilled in Him.
Coleton shows how Jesus lived this out:
The paralytic who believed nothing could change
Jairus’ daughter, declared hopeless and dead
The woman with the issue of blood
Lepers, demoniacs, the blind, the broken
Every encounter demonstrates the same truth: when people come to Jesus, His job description becomes their lived experience.
Coleton makes a bold claim:
If this kind of transformation has never begun in someone’s life, they may know
about Jesus without truly knowing Him.
He shares his own story—how his life changed dramatically after coming to faith. His friends loved the change but resisted the source. They wanted transformation without surrender.
“We treat Jesus the way Saul treated David. We want him to fight our battles for us… but we don’t want him to be our king.”
Coleton explains that who you believe your Messiah is will shape your life.
If the world is your messiah, the world will form you—and it is broken.
If Jesus is your Messiah, He will form you into His image—and He is full of life.
Jesus doesn’t offer occasional help; He offers fullness of life under His leadership.
3. Jesus Came to Remove Our Shame
The angel calls Jesus Lord—God Himself with us.
“Shame is not guilt. Guilt is ‘I did something wrong.’ Shame is ‘there is something wrong with me.’”
— Jon Tyson & Jeff Bethke,
Fighting ShadowsIn Genesis, Moses repeatedly says Adam and Eve were “naked and unashamed.” Their identity, value, and security came from God’s presence.
Coleton quotes Donald Miller:
“All of the glory, all of the security, all of the value that came from God was gone… and for the first time ever, they were pining for something to tell them they were okay.”
God’s question—“Who told you that you were naked?” (Genesis 3:11)—reveals the source: shame.
Coleton shows how humanity has been trying to silence shame ever since:
Relationships
Success
Approval
Humor
Anger
Perfectionism
Underperforming
Substances
Money, appearance, status
All of it is an attempt to quiet the whisper: something is wrong with me.
Christmas declares something different: Immanuel—God with us.
Through Jesus, we are welcomed back into God’s presence.
“Come to me… and I will give you rest for your souls.” (Matthew 11:28)
Coleton ends by pointing to the cross:
Jesus chose not to save Himself to save us
He was broken so we could be made whole
He was crucified naked and shamed to carry the shame of the garden—and remove ours
Jesus is the ultimate eucatastrophe—the unexpected goodness that changes everything.
Questions for Reflection
Which of the three reasons—rescue from sin, abundant life, or removal of shame—do you most need to experience right now, and why?
In what ways do you see sin acting more like an addiction than just bad behavior in your own life?
Where are you tempted to want the benefits of Jesus without surrendering to Him as King?
What are some ways you’ve tried to silence shame apart from God’s presence? How have those strategies fallen short?
What would it look like practically this week to trust Jesus to fulfill His “job description” in your life?