Two men. A remote hilltop. Matching suits. And homemade lead masks resting over their eyes.

In this episode of Clue Me In, Liv, Kay, and Grace dive into the strange and unsettling Lead Masks Case of 1966—a mystery that begins with a cryptic note and only gets stranger from there. No clear cause. No obvious answers. Just a trail of clues that somehow leads to even more questions.

What were they expecting to see? And what really happened on that hill?

A young woman arrives at the ER with a racing heart and a strange sheen on her skin. Within minutes, hospital staff begin collapsing one by one.
What happened inside that emergency room would leave doctors baffled, officials divided, and an entire nation searching for answers.

In this episode of Clue Me In, Liv, Kay, and Grace dive into the unsettling case of Gloria Ramirez—the so-called “Toxic Lady.” From unexplained medical reactions to conflicting investigations, we follow the clues through one of the most disturbing and controversial mysteries in modern medical history… and ask whether the truth was ever really uncovered.

Two little girls are tragically lost in a sudden accident. One year later, twin daughters are born into the same family… and they begin to remember things they were never told.

In this episode of Clue Me In, Liv, Kay, and Grace unravel the chilling story of the Pollock twins—a case filled with strange memories, familiar places, and questions that still have no clear answers. Follow the clues into one of the most unsettling family stories in modern history.

Step into one of history’s strangest and most mysterious events—the Dancing Plague of 1518. When hundreds of people in Strasbourg suddenly began dancing uncontrollably for days on end, no one could explain why. Was it mass hysteria, a curse, or something more sinister? Get ready for a story full of twists, strange symptoms, and eerie dances—this is one case you’ll want to be clued into!

It’s the most famous Christmas poem of all time—but who actually wrote ’Twas the Night Before Christmas? In this holiday special, we unwrap a literary mystery filled with rival claims, family feuds, historical clues, and just the right amount of festive chaos. Grab some cocoa, settle in, and let us clue you in as we try to solve one of Christmas’s coziest mysteries.

Voices in the night. Shadows that whisper your name. In the chilling finale of our Clue Me In Spooky Special series, Liv, Kay, and Grace dig into the legend of The Bell Witch—a spirit said to torment, taunt, and even kill. Join us as we step into the haunted hills of Tennessee and face one of America’s oldest ghost stories.

He’s tall, faceless, and born from the darkest corners of the internet. In this Clue Me In Spooky Special, Liv, Kay, and Grace dig into the eerie origins of The Slender Man—how a simple photo edit spiraled into fear, folklore, and a chilling real-life aftermath. Join us as we step into the forest and uncover the truth behind the legend.

Our October Spooky Special continues with one of Britain’s eeriest unsolved mysteries. In 1943, a group of boys discovered a skull hidden inside a hollow tree—and sparked decades of haunting questions. Who was the woman in the wych elm? And why was she placed there? Join us as we dig into the strange clues, chilling theories, and lingering whispers of the case of Bella in the Wych Elm.

Our October Spooky Specials kick off with a chilling modern mystery: The Watcher. 

A dream home. A quiet New Jersey street. And letters that turned it all into a nightmare. The messages revealed unsettling details about the family’s lives and raised terrifying questions. Was it a neighbor, a prankster, or something far more sinister?

In 1872, the Mary Celeste ship was discovered adrift in the Atlantic—its cargo untouched, its vessel in good condition, but the entire crew had vanished without a trace. Join us as we dig into the voyage, examine the strange clues left behind, and explore the many theories that have kept this maritime mystery alive for over a century.