It was supposed to be a normal night in La Crosse, Wisconsin. 

In 1953, 15-year-old Evelyn Hartley was babysitting for a local family—books in her bag, a routine check-in scheduled with her parents. But when she failed to call home, concern quickly turned to panic. 

Her father found the house locked, the baby sleeping soundly… but Evelyn was gone. Blood on the walls, broken glasses, and a trail of strange clues sparked one of the largest manhunts in Wisconsin history. Witnesses saw shadows. Footprints led nowhere. And decades later, the silence still screams. 

What happened to Evelyn Hartley? 

Join Sweet T as she pours up this haunting case filled with red flags, cold trails, and a faith that refuses to forget. Because some stories don’t fade—they just wait for truth. 

☕ Cold Tea with Sweet T—where the tea is cold… and the case is colder. 

In 1987, two teenage boys—Don Henry and Kevin Ives—went hunting in rural Arkansas and never came home. The next morning, their bodies were found laid across train tracks, mutilated by an oncoming locomotive. 

Authorities called it an accident.
 Their parents called it a cover-up.
And the truth? Still buried. 

Autopsies later revealed a skull fracture. A stab wound. A broken rifle.
 Witnesses began to die. Names were silenced. And whispers of drug trafficking, political corruption, and CIA-linked operations began to rise. 

In this episode, Sweet T unpacks a mystery soaked in injustice, grief, and long-suffering faith. 

In October 2009, Bobby and Sherilynn Jamison packed their truck, grabbed their daughter Madyson, and set off into the Oklahoma mountains in search of land. Days later, their truck was found—abandoned. Inside: $32,000 in cash, their IDs, cell phones, and a starving family dog. But the family? Gone. 

For four years, the Jamisons were missing—until their remains were discovered just three miles away. No cause of death. No signs of violence. No explanation. 

In this haunting episode, Sweet T unpacks the rumors of witchcraft, spiritual warfare, and eerie surveillance footage that made this case one of the most chilling family disappearances in America. 

The tea is cold. The case is colder.
 

🎙️ Now You See Him: The Vanishing of Brian Shaffer

Cold Tea with Sweet T | Episode [insert number]

How does a man walk into a crowded bar with surveillance cameras—and never walk out?

In this chilling episode, we dive into the 2006 disappearance of Brian Shaffer, a 27-year-old medical student from Columbus, Ohio, who vanished from inside The Ugly Tuna Saloona. Caught on camera entering the bar… but never seen leaving, Brian's case has left investigators, friends, and family baffled for nearly two decades.

From mysterious phone pings to eerie theories of staged vanishings and glitch-in-the-matrix speculation, this is a real-life locked room mystery with no clear answers.

Grab your headphones and your iced tea as Sweet T breaks down the timeline, unravels the theories, and reflects on what it means to disappear in plain sight.

In this chilling episode of Cold Tea with Sweet T, we unpack the mysterious deaths of 19-year-old twin brothers Qaadir Malik Lewis and Naazir Rahim Lewis, whose bodies were discovered on Georgia’s Bell Mountain in March 2025. Officially ruled a double suicide, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation cited forensic evidence, ammunition purchases, and search history. But the Lewis family isn’t convinced—and neither are we. 

Sweet T dives deep into the timeline, the inconsistencies, and the emotional testimony from the family who refuses to let this case fade away. Was this truly a suicide pact, or is there more to the story? 

Grab your mug and settle in—this tea is ice cold, but the truth might still be simmering. 

🧊 NEW EPISODE: WHAT HAPPENED TO KENDRICK JOHNSON?
A teenager walked into his high school gym…
But he never walked out.
The next day, he was found rolled up inside a gym mat.

No blood.
 No justice.
 Organs missing.
 And a silence too loud to ignore.

This ain’t just a story — it’s a warning.
 And the deeper you sip… the colder it gets.

Listen now on #Spotify, #ApplePodcasts, #Buzzsprout, and #AmazonMusic.
#ColdTeaWithSweetT #KendrickJohnson #TrueCrimePodcast #JusticeForKJ #UnsolvedMystery

🧊 NEW EPISODE: THE UNSOLVED DEATH OF ALONZO BROOKS
He went to a party.
He never came home.
Authorities searched the field and found nothing.
But his family did — a month later — just yards from the party house.

No answers. No arrests.
Until the FBI stepped in.

Was it a hate crime? A cover-up?
Or a cold case that got too quiet for too long?

🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Buzzsprout & Amazon Music
#ColdTeaWithSweetT #AlonzoBrooks #TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMystery #JusticeForAlonzoBrooks

In 1989, Patricia Meehan survived a head-on crash on a quiet Montana highway. Witnesses say she stepped out of her car… stared blankly at the wreckage… and walked into the night, never to be seen again — at least, not officially.

For years, people claimed to see her across the country. But no one ever got close. No answers. No closure.

Join Sweet T as she sips the cold tea on one of Montana’s strangest disappearances — a woman who didn’t just vanish… she might still be watching.

 “He was a respected Texas attorney... until he vanished Super Bowl weekend.

Days later, they found him... 1,600 miles away, dead on the side of the road.

No ID. Wrong clothes. No answers.

I’m Sweet T — and on this episode of Cold Tea with Sweet T, we’re sipping the strange, true story of David Glenn Lewis.

Because when the tea runs cold... the truth just might be hiding in plain sight.”