Counterfactual Canuck

This is the first episode of Counterfactual Puck, a look at hockey and alternate history that I'm adding to the Counterfactual Canuck feed.

This episode looks at the early history of the NHL, the National Hockey League, by examining how it arose out of the NHA, the National Hockey Association, and how much of this was due to one man, Eddie Livingstone - but not in a good way.

And my apologies for the inability to pronounce "Tamiskaming" for the hockey league with that name.

 You can reach me at:
 
 Email: [email protected]
 
Stuff you can look up:

Eddie Livingstone
National Hockey Association (also pages for individual seasons)
Ambrose O'Brien
List of Stanley Cup challenge games
Morey Holzman & Joseph Nieforth - Deceptions and Doublecross
Sean McIndoe - The Down Goes Brown History of the NHL

The Wars of Kings and Queens: The Fox, An Alliance, Jenkins' Ear and George

I continue the Wars of Kings and Queens in this episode, covering a number of conflicts large and small including the Fox Wars, the War of Jenkins' Ear, the War of the Austrian Succession and King George's War, as well as a brief period of Franco-British friendship.
 
 Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
 
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
 
 You can reach me at:
 
 Email: [email protected]
  
 Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

War of the Austrian Succession

King George's War

Meskwaki

Fox Wars

Anglo-French Alliance (1716–1731)

War of Jenkins' Ear

Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle (1748)


University of Google:

The Imperial Wars

The Arrival of the Europeans: 17th Century Wars


Printed Material:

M.S. Anderson - The War of the Austrian Succession, 1740-1748

Slavery in Canada

Content warning: Discussion of slavery throughout the episode

I look at the history of slavery in Canada, both African and Indigenous, and then propose some counterfactuals around this history.

 
 Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
  
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
  
 You can reach me at:
  
 Email: [email protected]
  

 Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

Slavery in Canada

Slavery among the indigenous peoples of the Americas

Slavery in New France

University of Google:

Slavery | Virtual Museum of New France

Enslavement of Indigenous People in Canada | The Canadian Encyclopedia

Torture and Truth: Angélique and the Burning of Montreal

7.7 Slavery – Canadian History: Pre-Confederation

Printed Material:

Afua Cooper – The Hanging of Angelique

The Wars of Kings and Queens: Anne and Father Rale

I continue the Wars of Kings and Queens in this episode, recapping the War of the Spanish Succession and Queen Anne’s War before ending with Father Rale’s War afterwards.
 
 Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
  
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
  
 You can reach me at:
  
 Email: [email protected]
   
 Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

War of the Spanish Succession 

Dummer's War

Peace of Utrecht

Treaty of Portsmouth (1713)

Queen Anne's War

Sébastien Rale

University of Google:

Treaty of Utrecht | The Canadian Encyclopedia

The Imperial Wars - Canada.ca

Peace and Friendship Treaties | The Canadian Encyclopedia

Printed Material:

James Falkner – The War of the Spanish Succession

Charles Spencer - Blenheim

A Lack of Industry: Malthus was right

This episode has a big picture scenario in which the Industrial Revolution does not come about and the world, including Canada, enters into a Malthusian trap in the early 18th century.

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
 
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
 
 For now, you can reach me at:
 
 Email: [email protected]
 
 Wikipedia should not be used as a source: 

An Essay on the Principle of Population

Club of Rome

Malthusian catastrophe

The Population Bomb

Thomas Robert Malthus

Industrial Revolution

University of Google:

World Population by Year - Worldometer

Cornucopian vs. Malthusian debate - RationalWiki

Thomas Robert Malthus (1766-1834)

Printed Material:

Thomas Malthus - An Essay on the Principle of Population

Gregory Clark – A farewell to Alms

William K Hartmann – Out of the Cradle

***UPDATED AUDIO FILE - I've uploaded a better recording to replace the first one (although there was still a wind storm for the first bit of the episode)

In this episode, I begin the Second Hundred Years' War between France and England/Britain, beginning with the War of the League of Augsburg, King William's War and then ending with the Great Peace of Montreal in the aftermath.

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
 
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
 
 You can reach me at:
 
 Email: [email protected]
 
 Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

Nine Years' War
King William's War
Peace of Ryswick
Glorious Revolution
James II of England
Wabanaki Confederacy
Great Peace of Montreal
Battle of Quebec (1690)
Lachine massacre
Battle of Falmouth (1690)
Battle of Port Royal (1690)
Avalon Peninsula Campaign
Peace of Ryswick

University of Google:

The Abenaki People – Fighting the English – Legends of America
The Great Peace of Montréal Treaty | Canadian History Hall | Canadian Museum of History
Great Peace of Montreal, 1701 | The Canadian Encyclopedia
The Great Peace of Montreal
Canadian Military Heritage | Canadian Military History Gateway

Printed Materials:

John Lynn - The Wars of Louis XIV
Gilles Havard - The Great Peace of Montreal of 1701

The Dismal Science: The Early Fur Trade and Rupert’s Land

This episode turns the focus onto economics and early Canada, looking at the beginnings of the fur trade and the creation of Rupert's Land.

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad
 
 Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans
 
 For now, you can reach me at:
 
 Email: [email protected]
 
 Wikipedia should not be used as a source: 

Beaver Wars

Rupert's Land

New Netherland

Fur trade 

Hudson's Bay Company

North American fur trade 

University of Google:

Fur Trade in Canada | The Canadian Encyclopedia

Beaver | The Canadian Encyclopedia

The Legacy of the Fur Trade | SeaOtters.com

HBC Heritage | Radisson and des Groseilliers

Fur Trade | Indigenous Peoples Atlas of Canada

The Beginnings of the Fur Trade

6.8 The Fur Trade in Global Perspective – Canadian History: Pre-Confederation

17th Century Potpourri, Indigenous Edition

This is another potpourri episode, about the 17th century, this time focusing on Indigenous nations. The bulk of the episode concerns the Beaver/Iroquois/Haudenosaunee wars, but there are a couple of broader-picture scenarios as well.

1. Fallout for Canada from Indigenous-British wars to the south (Pequot, King Philip);
2. New France and the Haudenosaunee reach peace early and avoid the Beaver Wars;
3. The Wyandot-Haudenosaunee War;
4. The Fall of New France (Haudenosaunee capture Quebec);
5. Greater European-Indigenous hostility (Content warning: genocide)

Links for Dale Cozort:

http://www.dalecozort.com/
https://www.amazon.ca/American-Indian-Victories-Dale-Cozort-ebook/dp/B009XCGWVM

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad

Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans

For now, you can reach me at:

Email: [email protected]

Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

Beaver Wars
Demographic history of Quebec
Wampanoag
First Abenaki War
King Philip's War
Pequot War
Narragansett people
First Abenaki War
Niantic people

University of Google:

The Arrival of the Europeans: 17th Century Wars - Canada.ca
The Abenaki People – Fighting the English – Legends of America
Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) | The Canadian Encyclopedia

Printed Material:

Philip Marchand - Ghost Empire

17th Century Potpourri, English & French Edition

This is another potpourri episode, this time looking at a number of scenarios involving England and France in the 17th Century. I look at some of the history that happened prior to the series of larger-scale conflicts that started in 1688.

1. England and France become allies;
2. England keeps Quebec and Acadia early in the century;
3. France intervenes on the Royalist side in the British and English Civil Wars;
4. Louis XIV dies soon after his regency ends.

This episode focuses more on Europe, with ramifications for North America. The next couple of episodes will focus more on North America and Canada.

Link to alternatehistory.com thread mentioned in the episode:

(2) AHC:French Intervention during the English Civil War | alternatehistory.com

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad

Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans

For now, you can reach me at:

Email: [email protected]

Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

Anglo-French War (1627–1629) - Wikipedia
Siege of La Rochelle - Wikipedia
Siege of Saint-Martin-de-Ré - Wikipedia
Bishops' Wars - Wikipedia
Sovereign Council of New France - Wikipedia
Huguenot rebellions - Wikipedia
Philippe I, Duke of Orléans - Wikipedia
Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor - Wikipedia

University of Google:

A Spanish Settlement in Carolina, 1526 — GaHQ 7:339‑345 (1923)
Biography – KIRKE, SIR DAVID – Volume I (1000-1700) – Dictionary of Canadian Biography
The first English Conquest of Canada : with some account of the earliest settlements in Nova Scotia and Newfoundland : Kirke, Henry, 1842-1925 : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

Canada and Big History: A Passage to Asia

For this episode, I step back from the counterfactual narrative of Canadian history to look at Big History and what could be called cosmic counterfactuals. After a brief overview of what Big History is, there are a couple of general, non-Canadian scenarios followed by a Canada-centered scenario around the idea of a Passage to Asia around or through North America.

I'd also like to post a correction here (that's also near the end of the episode). In Episode # 2 on Indigenous Nations & Civilizations, I mentioned the "Inuit people" a couple of times. This is repetitive as Inuit translates as "the people". I apologize for this mistake and will not make it again going forward.

Opening Theme: "Another Place" by Score Squad

Outro: From "Oh Canaduh" by Nomeansno, covering the Subhumans

For now, you can reach me at:

Email: [email protected]

Website for Neil F Comins (Books are listed below):
Neil F. Comins - Welcome to the website of Dr. Neil F. Comins

Wikipedia should not be used as a source:

Isthmus of Panama - Wikipedia
Southern Ocean - Wikipedia
Northwest Passage - Wikipedia
Antarctica - Wikipedia

University of Google:

Panama: Isthmus that Changed the World
Recent Connection Between North and South America Reaffirmed | Smithsonian Institution
Timeline On Formation Of Isthmus Of Panama - Texas A&M Galveston, TX
Big History Project
How the Antarctic Circumpolar Current helps keep Antarctica frozen
Southern Ocean Warming | Oceanography
NAQT | You Gotta Know These North American Rivers

Printed Material:

David Christian - Origin Story
Neil F Comins - What if the Moon Didn't Exist?
Neil F Comins - What if the Earth had Two Moons?
Cynthia Stokes Brown - Big History