
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Rachel and Krystal discuss the outcomes of the Sandra Birchmore, Sophie, and Stephanie Crone-Overholt in this episode of water cooler whispers.
Three cases, three courtroom dramas, and one very unusual plea deal! This week on Water Cooler Whispers, Krystal and Rachel break down the Sandra Birchmore case and Matthew Farwell’s federal trial, the Cooper Ouellette trial, and the Florida defendant who offered to plead guilty in exchange for a cheesesteak and a Pepsi.
Grab your coffee (or your cheesesteak) and join us as we catch up on the details making headlines.
Before the world knew her name, 37‑year‑old ranch hand Patricia Meehan walked away from a car crash on a quiet Montana highway and disappeared into the night. What followed is one of the most surreal missing‑person mysteries in modern history: more than 5,000 reported sightings across multiple states — some mistaken, some impossible, and some chillingly credible.
In this episode, we explore the crash, the search, the psychology behind mass sightings, and the haunting possibility that Patricia kept walking long after that night. This is a story about mental health, geography, and the human instinct to look for someone who’s lost.
In 1990, Barbara George was murdered inside her comic book store, Comics World, in Clinton Township, Michigan. What followed was a complicated investigation, courtroom battles, unanswered questions, and a case that would remain in the headlines for years.
In this special episode, we go beyond the headlines with a personal connection to Barbara. Through memories of the woman behind the counter, we explore the case, the investigation, the evidence, and the lasting impact her loss had on those who knew her.
Because behind every headline is a real person, a real story, and people who haven't forgotten.
Monsters, Myths & Panic. We dive into the stories that shaped our fears: Indigenous Sasquatch teachings, Cold War UFO secrecy, Point Pleasant’s winged omen, a frozen mystery in the Ural Mountains, and the Halloween broadcast that sent listeners running for their lives. Why do these legends stick? Why do we believe the unbelievable? And what does panic reveal about us?
A comic book store. A staged robbery. A timeline that never made sense.
The case went cold almost immediately - until a single witness and a determined community forced investigators to take a second look. This episode unravels the timeline, the marriage, the staged robbery, and the moment everything change
In this episode, we explore the tragic case of Colleen Slemmer, the young woman whose life was taken in a brutal 2005 murder in Tennessee. We discuss the case and the lasting impact on Colleen’s loved ones as questions of justice and accountability continue to draw attention.
We’re also sharing resources from other true crime voices covering the case and its ongoing developments.
🎧 Want to learn more?
At Coworkers & Crime, we believe the victim should never be forgotten. Colleen deserves to be remembered as more than the crime that took her life.
Krystal and Rachel are catching up on the cases making headlines and the ones we think you should be watching.
This episode:
Some cases are getting new developments. Others are just getting started.
In this episode, we explore the origins of the Innocence Project, the psychology behind false confessions, and the systemic failures that allow innocent people to be convicted. We break down interrogation tactics, forensic flaws, under‑reported cases, and the staggering statistics that reveal how widespread wrongful convictions truly are.
Primary Sources & Reputable References
(All sources are academic, legal, or institutional — no Reddit, no Wikipedia.)
Innocence Project – Official Resources
Equal Justice Initiative (EJI)
National Registry of Exonerations
Department of Justice (DOJ) Reports
National Academy of Sciences (NAS)
Academic Research
Case References (Under‑Reported)
Key Statistics Mentioned
Yosemite is breathtaking—but beyond the trails and waterfalls lies a vast wilderness where four people disappeared without a trace.
In this episode, we examine the cases of George Penca, Michael Ficery, Dikran Knadjian, and Peter Jackson—four disappearances spanning more than a decade, each with its own unanswered questions.
What happened after their last known sightings? And how can someone vanish in a place searched by teams, helicopters, dogs, and rangers?
Join us as we explore four of Yosemite’s unresolved missing-person cases.
In September 1978, two children walked home to a small cabin in Sterling, Alaska. By morning, they were gone. No struggle. No footprints. No witnesses. Just a pot of boiling macaroni left on the stove and a timeline that collapses into silence.
This episode takes you inside one of Alaska’s most haunting unsolved disappearances — the night at Good Time Charlie’s, the walk to the Luptons’, the stove that never got turned off, and the investigation that never found a single trace.
We explore the verified facts, the community that still carries the weight of this case, and the moment where everything changed. No sensationalism. No speculation. Just the story of Scott and Amy Fandel, told with care, clarity, and the hope that someone, somewhere, still remembers something.
Resources & Verified Sources:
If You Have Information:
Contact Alaska State Troopers or NCMEC.
From the publisher's feed
Welcome to Coworkers and Crime—the podcast where office chatter meets crime discussion. We’re your hosts, Rachel and Krystal. Yes, we really do work together... and yes, we’re totally obsessed with…
email us at: [email protected]
https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1G4UhP9odP/
https://www.youtube.com/@CoworkersCrimePodcast
https://www.instagram.com/coworkersandcrime/#