A Mason's Work

Crafting a Life Series: The Mirror of Feedback


Listen Later

In this episode, we navigate the "place of great danger" that is soliciting feedback, teaching you how to distinguish between seeking approval and seeking actionable insight.

High-Value Quotables

[01:21] "Are you looking for feedback or approval? Those things are different."
[02:44] "What you're really looking for is nuanced feedback... by asking questions that are a little bit more engaging."
[04:01] "Every person that's giving you feedback... is acting to as a mirror on that process."
[05:42] "Be prepared that they will not be able to separate their opinion from their observation... be careful with other people's feedback, because if you take that and use it as a way to drive your own behavior, you may find that you are operating sort of at the whim of a thousand different perspectives." 

The Core Concept: Nuanced Questioning

Soliciting feedback is a risky step in development because we are often sensitive and prone to seeking simple approval. To get truly actionable insight, you must change the nature of your questions from binary ("Did you like it?") to specific and process-related ("What flavors did you taste?").


Key Takeaways:

  • Approval vs. Feedback: Approval is a binary like/dislike; feedback is a nuanced understanding of choices made in context.
  • The "Mirror" Effect: Respondents are mirrors reflecting your process back to you, but their reflection is always flavored by their own subjective preferences.
  • Specific Inquiries: Ask what someone would have done differently or what was most attractive about an experience to get actionable data.
  • The Feedback Nightmare: If you use subjective feedback as your sole behavioral driver, you risk going adrift by following a "thousand different perspectives".

Creators & Guests

  • Brian Mattocks - Host
  • ★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★
    Click here to view the episode transcript.
    Thanks to our monthly supporters
    • Tim Dedman
    • Jorge
    • ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store

      A Mason's WorkBy Brian Mattocks


      More shows like A Mason's Work

      View all
      Whence Came You? - Freemasonry discussed and Masonic research for today's Freemason by Robert Johnson

      Whence Came You? - Freemasonry discussed and Masonic research for today's Freemason

      321 Listeners

      The Masonic Roundtable - Freemasonry Today for Today's Freemasons by Jon Ruark, Jason Richards, Nick Johnson, Juan Sepulveda & Robert Johnson

      The Masonic Roundtable - Freemasonry Today for Today's Freemasons

      204 Listeners

      The Art of Manliness by The Art of Manliness

      The Art of Manliness

      14,295 Listeners

      Masonic Lite Podcast by Masonic Lite Podcast

      Masonic Lite Podcast

      47 Listeners

      Short Talk Bulletin by Short Talk Bulletin

      Short Talk Bulletin

      88 Listeners

      Scottish Rite Journal Podcast by The Tyler's Place Podcast

      Scottish Rite Journal Podcast

      34 Listeners

      The Working Tools Podcast by The Working Tools Podcast

      The Working Tools Podcast

      16 Listeners

      The Traveling Man Masonic Podcast by Jim Hall

      The Traveling Man Masonic Podcast

      35 Listeners

      Craftsmen Online Podcast by Craftsmen Online

      Craftsmen Online Podcast

      41 Listeners

      Masonic Muscle by Cesar Rubio

      Masonic Muscle

      27 Listeners

      Further Light Podcast by C Luedke

      Further Light Podcast

      14 Listeners

      Arcanvm Podcast by Ike Baker

      Arcanvm Podcast

      18 Listeners

      Craftcast: The Freemasons Podcast by United Grand Lodge of England

      Craftcast: The Freemasons Podcast

      21 Listeners

      The Third Degree Masonic Podcast by Brothers Samuel , Gabriel,  and Ryan

      The Third Degree Masonic Podcast

      8 Listeners