Crime Connections

In 1995, 19-year-old Tabitha Guth vanished in Toledo, Ohio, only to be found murdered a month later. At the time, investigators struggled to find solid leads, and the case went cold. However, when authorities began to connect the dots with a string of similar unsolved murders from the 1980s, a disturbing pattern emerged. Many of the victims were young women whose bodies had been found just miles away from where James Worley, a man with a dark history of violence against women, lived. Worley’s eventual arrest in 2016 for the abduction and brutal murder of Sierah Joughin raised unsettling questions. In part one of our two-part series, we dive into James Worley's twisted life, exploring his potential involvement in multiple cold cases and how his capture for Joughin’s murder finally exposed his deadly past. Join us as we examine the grim possibility that Worley's trail of terror began long before he was ever brought to justice.

This week, we’re diving into updates on some of the cases we've covered. Get the latest developments on Katelyn Markham, Toyah Cordingley, the Delphi Murders, the Idaho University Killings, and Gabby Petito.

Tune in for the newest details and unexpected twists in these ongoing investigations.

In April 2021, 52-year-old Dee Warner vanished from her home in Tipton, Michigan, leaving behind her car, her phone, and countless questions. Her daughter Rikkel discovered her missing that Sunday morning, sparking a desperate search that would span over three years. What really happened on the night of April 24th? And why did her husband’s story raise suspicion?

Now, in a shocking turn of events, Dee's remains have been discovered on her husband's property. Join us as we dive into the mystery, the investigation, and the heartbreaking resolution.

In April 2021, 52-year-old Dee Warner vanished from her home in Tipton, Michigan, leaving behind her car, her phone, and countless questions. Her daughter Rikkel discovered her missing that Sunday morning, sparking a desperate search that would span over three years. What really happened on the night of April 24th? And why did her husband’s story raise suspicion?

Now, in a shocking turn of events, Dee's remains have been discovered on her husband's property. Join us as we dive into the mystery, the investigation, and the heartbreaking resolution.

Join us as we delve into the disturbing and unsolved case of Priscilla Johnson, a 32-year-old woman whose life was brutally cut short after a New Year’s Eve celebration in 2002. Priscilla spent the evening with friends and was dropped off at home in good spirits.

A week later, her family found her house in disarray, with bloodstains on the floor, walls, and mattress, but no sign of Priscilla. Months later, a man walking his dog discovered a human skull in a remote area. Forensic analysis confirmed it was Priscilla’s, but the rest of her remains were never found.

To this day, no one knows who took Priscilla’s life or why. Investigators and her family continue to search for the truth behind this chilling and heartbreaking crime.

In the summer of 2013, 25-year-old Zachary Porter sold his BMW for a motorcycle and cash via Craigslist. Weeks later, the buyer wanted to repurchase the bike. On July 23, Zach drove to meet the buyer, who was supposed to give him a ride back to McMinnville, Oregon. He texted his father that he arrived safely and later told a friend the sale was complete. Hours passed with no word from Zach, and his family reported him missing. To this day, Zachary Porter remains missing, and his case has gone cold.

In this episode, we delve into the harrowing decade that began on May 25th, 2013, in the tight-knit town of Bardstown, Kentucky. This peaceful community was shattered by the ambush and murder of officer Jason Ellis, a dedicated K-9 officer. A year later, the brutal slayings of Kathy and Samantha Netherland, a beloved teacher and her teenage daughter, deepened the town’s trauma. 

In 2015, the disappearance of young mother Crystal Rogers added to the fear and uncertainty, especially when her abandoned car was found with no trace of her. The tragedy worsened in 2016 when Crystal’s father, Tommy Ballard, was shot and killed while out hunting with his grandson, adding another layer of heartbreak. 

These interconnected tragedies have exposed corruption and instilled fear in Bardstown, but the community remains resilient. Residents hold onto hope, united in their quest for justice for Officer Ellis, Kathy Netherland, Samantha Netherland, Crystal Rogers, and Tommy Ballard. Join us as we uncover the details, explore the impact, and seek to understand the enduring mystery that has come to define Bardstown.

On July 4, 2010, Shonda Townsend spent a festive day with friends and family in Mineral Wells, Texas. After a cookout, swimming, and fireworks, she left to return to her home in Perrin, Texas, where she lived with her mother and 2-year-old son, Haiden. Shonda never made it home. Her 1997 Toyota Camry was found two days later, ransacked, in a rough part of Mineral Wells.

Despite extensive searches and interviews by police and private groups, Shonda remained missing. Over a year later, in October 2011, her remains were discovered. Dental records confirmed her identity, but the mystery of her disappearance and death remains unsolved.

This July marks 13 years since Shonda Townsend went missing. Join us as we delve into this tragic case and explore the unanswered questions surrounding her disappearance and death.

Today we delve into the tragic and perplexing case of Katelyn Markham. On August 14th, 2011, Katelyn vanished from her home in Fairfield, Ohio, leaving her family and friends in a state of anguish. Their relentless search for answers turned to heartbreak when, on April 7th, 2013, her remains were discovered in a dump yard in Indiana. For years, investigators combed through limited clues, struggling to piece together who could have committed such a heinous act and why. Despite extensive efforts by multiple police departments, the case remained unsolved until February 2023, when a major breakthrough led to the arrest of a suspect. Now, as the suspect faces trial this month, a jury will finally decide their fate. Join us as we explore the detailed twist and turns of this harrowing journey for justice in the case of Katelyn Markham.