Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE SCREAM MURDER: A TRUE TEEN HORROR STORY on Hulu & Disney+. Joining them is Grace Leeder @goforgrace.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this docu-series? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 40.06

The panel discusses the Oscar nominated documentary features and shorts, beginning at about 42.53

Features: 

Shorts: 

Other properties mentioned in the podcast:

tv series: ADOLESCENCE

documentary: 13TH (Ava DuVernay, 2016)

documentary: ORIGIN (Ava DuVernay, 2023)

podcast: THE HANDSOME PODCAST

film: THE VOICE OF HIND RAJAB (Kaouther Ben Hania, 2025)

Next time on Crime Seen: A double feature of GIRL ON THE RUN on Hulu and Disney+,  and WILD BOYS: STRANGERS IN TOWN on Paramount+, with Alvin Williams from Affirmative Murder podcast @affirmativemurder on Instagram. Watch either or both, and send us your comments and questions

Find Grace at:

Find Mari at: 

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-2-recap/ 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-4-recap/ 

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE INVESTIGATION OF LUCY LETBY on Netflix. Joining them is Jason Reed @jr33d.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 55.53

Mini review of THE CURIOUS CASE OF … THE SKINCARE QUEEN AND THE HITMAN on Hulu begins at about 1.02.19

Recommendations:

tv special: THE MUPPET SHOW (Disney+)

documentary: COME SEE ME IN THE GOOD LIGHT (Apple tv+)

tv series: WONDER MAN (Disney+)

You can jump to the recommendations at about 1.04.46

Next time on Crime Seen: THE SCREAM MURDER: TRUE TEEN HORROR STORY with Grace Leeder @goforgrace.bsky.social. Watch it on Hulu, and send us your comments and questions

Find Jason at:

https://robhasawebsite.com/shows/reality-tv-rhapups/married-at-first-sight/

https://recapkickback.com/episode/wonder-man-recap-episodes-1-4

https://www.youtube.com/@THEGOODPODTV

Find Mari at: 

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-2-recap/ 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-4-recap/ 

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine KIDNAPPED: ELIZABETH SMART on Netflix

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 18.35

Mini review of HANDSOME DEVIL: CHARMING KILLER on Paramount+ begins at about 22.52

Recommendations:

anime: JUJUTSU KAISEN

tv series: AMERICAN GANGSTER: TRAP QUEENS

adult animation: SPLINTER CELL: DEATHWATCH

adult animation: HA HA YOU CLOWNS

film: SPINAL TAP II: THE END CONTINUES

tv series: AGATHA CHRISTIE’S SEVEN DIALS 

tv series: WILL TRENT Season 4

tv series: ANIMAL CONTROL season 4

You can jump to the recommendations at about 42.26

Next time on Crime Seen: THE HILLSIDE STRANGLER on MGM+ with Toby Ball @tobyballnh.bsky.social from Crime Writers On. Watch it, and send us your comments and questions

Find Mari at: 

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-2-recap/ 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-4-recap/ 

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE CULT BEHIND THE KILLER: THE ANDREA YATES STORY on HBO Max. Joining them is Katie from A Date With Dateline @datedateline.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 59.23

Further properties on Andrea Yates:

tv episode: AMERICAN JUSTICE season 12 episode 2 "The Andrea Yates Story"

youtube: BEHIND CRIMINAL MINDS "Andrea Yates: The Crime That Changed Mental Health Care Forever"

book: BREAKING POINT by Suzy Spencer

Recommendations:

book: FANTASTICLAND (Mike Bockoven, 2016)

book: COME KNOCKING (Mike Bockoven, 2025)

book: SHRINES OF GAIETY (Kate Atkinson, 2022)

book: DEAD DEAD GIRL (Nekesa Afia, 2021)

You can jump to the recommendations at about 1.04.51

Next time on Crime Seen: KIDNAPPED: ELIZABETH SMART on Netflix, with a mini review of HANDSOME DEVIL: CHARMING KILLER on Paramount+. Watch either or both, and send us your comments and questions

Find Katie at:

A Date With Dateline: https://www.adatewithdateline.com/ 

Find Mari at: 

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-2-recap/ 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Drag Race Rucap: https://robhasawebsite.com/rupauls-drag-race-season-18-ep-4-recap/ 

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine CRITICAL INCIDENT: DEATH AT THE BORDER on HBO Max. Joining them is Brandon R. Reynolds @brandorey.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about  30.57

Mini review of COVER-UP on Netflix begins at about 35.49

Link to previous episode:

THE PEZ OUTLAW https://crimeseenpod.com/episode/crime-seen-episode-42-the-pez-outlaw-xo07 

Recommendations:

film: ALL THE PRESIDENT'S MEN (Alan J. Pakula, 1976)

documentary: WORMWOOD (Erol Morris, 2017)

tv drama: DOWN CEMETERY ROAD (2025)

film: NO OTHER CHOICE (Park Chan-wook, 2025)

tv drama: HIS & HERS (2026)

reality tv: UNLOCKED: A JAIL EXPERIMENT

reality tv: THE TRAITORS US season 4

tv drama: THE PITT season 2

tv drama: BLUE LIGHTS season 1-3

You can jump to the recommendations at about 50.53

Next time on Crime Seen: KIDNAPPED: ELIZABETH SMART Watch it on Netflix from January 21, and send us your comments and questions

Find Brandon at:

KCRW https://www.kcrw.com/ 

More Like Ancient FAIL-iens https://open.spotify.com/show/2EHjrzFjZk3QzUqKlxMkSX

Why is Amy in the Bath? https://open.spotify.com/show/6oHAoxfzbXmrEhVcxIvldP 

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE CULT OF THE REAL HOUSEWIFE on HBO Max. Joining them is Maggie Morgan @mlmorgan.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about  40.19

Recommendations;

tv drama: DOPESICK (Danny Strong, 2021)

film: DISTRICT 9 (Neill Blomkamp, 2009)

animated series: RICK & MORTY season 8

reality tv: THE TRAITORS UK series 4

reality tv: RUPAUL'S DRAG RACE season 18

tv drama: RUN AWAY (Nimer Rashed & Isher Sahota, 2026)

book: CURSED DAUGHTERS (Oyinkan Braithwaite, 2025)

docuseries: EVIL INFLUENCER: THE JODI HILDEBRANDT STORY (Skye Borgman, 2025)

book: THE HOUSE OF MY MOTHER: A DAUGHTER'S QUEST FOR FREEDOM (Shari Franke, 2025)

You can jump to the recommendations at about 45.52

Next time on Crime Seen: Journalist Brandon R Reynolds CRITICAL INCIDENT: DEATH AT THE BORDER. Watch it on HBO Max, and send us your comments and questions

Find Maggie at:

Instagram & TikTok @mlmorgan_

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE SECRETS WE BURY on iD. Going them is Emily Doogan from Critical True Crime

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 33.45

Link to previous episode:

THEY CALLED HIM MOSTLY HARMLESS https://crimeseenpod.com/episode/crime-seen-episode-92-they-called-him-mostly-harmless-k5o4 

Recommendations;

book: I'LL BE GONE IN THE DARK (Michelle McNamara, 2019)

docu-series: CAPTURING THEIR KILLER: THE GIRLS ON THE HIGH BRIDGE

film: THE PHOENICIAN SCHEME (Wes Anderson, 2025)

film: WAKE UP, DEAD MAN: A KNIVES OUT MYSTERY (Rian Johnson, 2025)

film: THE HISTORY OF SOUND (Oliver Hermanus, 2025)

tv series: THE BEAST IN ME

You can jump to the recommendations at about 36.58

Next time on Crime Seen: THE CULT OF THE REAL HOUSEWIFE. Watch it, and send us your comments and questions

Find Emily at:

https://www.youtube.com/@criticaltruecrime 

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine PREDATORS on Paramount+

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 27.03

Mini review of the 48 HOURS episode from December 14 JOE HUNTER'S MISSION begins at about 28.28

Mini review of MURDER IN MONACO on Netflix on begins at about 33.16

Mari & Sarah's Favourites of 2025

documentaries: THE FURRY DETECTIVES: UNMASKING A MONSTER (MF); SHINY HAPPY PEOPLE: TEENAGE HOLY WAR (SC)

podcasts: SISTAS WHO KILL (MF); WISECRACK (SC)

hidden gems: SURVIVING OHIO STATE (MF); GIRLS GONE WILD: THE UNTOLD STORY (SC)

dramatic adaptations: DEVIL IN DISGUISE (MF); APPLE CIDER VINEGAR (SC)

scripted tv: THE STUDIO (MF); DEPARTMENT Q (SC)

books: BEHIND THE MIRROR (Taran Armstrong, 2025) HEATED RIVALRY series (Rachel Reid), and THE DUSKWALKER BRIDE series (Opal Reyne) (MF); ALL THAT REMAINS: A LIFE IN DEATH (Sue Black, 2018), and AN UNEXPLAINED DEATH: THE TRUE STORY OF A BODY AT THE BELVEDERE (Mikita Brottman, 2018)

audio books: MY SISTER THE SERIAL KILLER (Oyinkan Braithwaite, 2018), and THE KIND WORTH KILLING (Peter Swanson, 2015) (MF)

reality shows: GOT TO GET OUT (MF); CRIME SCENE ZERO (SC)

episodes of Crime Seen: MONSTER: THE ED GEIN STORY (MF); THE FOX HOLLOW MURDERS (SC)

You can jump to the Favourites at about 37.44

Next time on Crime Seen: Emily Doogan from Critical True Crime youtube.com/@CriticalTrueCrime joins the Seen to discuss THE SECRETS WE BURY on ID. Watch it, and send us your comments and questions

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine THE MERCHANTS OF JOY on Prime. Joining them is Mary-Payne Gilbert @pinkshadepod

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 28.16

link to previous episode:

FRUITCAKE FRAUD: https://crimeseenpod.com/episode/crime-seen-episode-20-fruitcake-fraud-rob-cesternino-o9zg  

Mini review of ¡CASA BONITA, MI AMOR! on Paramount+ begins at about 29.14

Mini review of THE SECRET LIVES OF MORMON WIVES on begins at about 38.52

Recommendations:

tv series: THE BEAR (Hulu in the US, Disney in Australia)

tv series: TASK (HBO)

docu-series: SEAN COMBS: THE RECKONING (Netflix)

tv series: SLOW HORSES (AppleTV)

tv series: HEATED RIVALRY (HBO in the US and Crave on Canada)

documentary: WHAT HAPPENED AT FELL ACRES (ID)

You can jump to the recommendations at about 43.53

Next time on Crime Seen: Sarah D Bunting from Best Evidence @bestevidencefyi.bsky.social joins the Seen to discuss PREDATORS on PARAMOUNT+. Watch it, and send us your comments and questions

Find Mary-Payne at:

Prink Shade Podcast: https://pinkshadepodcast.com/ 

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Crime Seen is the true crime review podcast that gets to the heart of how true crime stories are told. Join Mari Forth @maritalks2much.bsky.social and Sarah Carradine @sarahcarradine.bsky.social as they put true crime properties under the magnifying glass. In this episode they examine ELOÁ THE HOSTAGE: LIVE ON TV on Netflix. Joining them is Matt Scott @mattscotgw.bsky.social

How many magnifying glasses out of 5 will they rate this documentary? Listen to find out. Or jump to the ratings at about 41.23

link to previous episode:

GLADBECK: THE HOSTAGE CRISIS https://crimeseenpod.com/episode/crime-seen-episode-19-gladbeck-the-hostage-crisis-8xkj 

Mini review of THE CARMAN FAMILY DEATHS on Netflix begins at about 44.49

Recommendations:

book: SOMETHING BIG: The True Story Of The Brown's Chicken Massacre (Patrick Wohl, 2025)

short documentary: ALL THE EMPTY ROOMS (Joshua Seftel, 2025)

podcast: THE REST IS HISTORY: Jack The Ripper (2025)

film: NOW YOU SEE ME (Louis Leterrier, 2013)

film: NOW YOU SEE ME 2 (Jon M Chu, 2016)

film: NOW YOU SEE ME, NOW YOU DON'T (Ruben Fleischer, 2025)

docu-series: 50 SECONDS: THE FERNANDO BÁEZ SOSA CASE (Martin Rocca, 2025)

tv series: MISSING: DEAD OR ALIVE Season 2 (Netflix)

documentary: THE MANY DEATHS OF NORA DALMASSO (Jamie Crawford, 2025)

You can jump to the recommendations at about 52.39

Next time on Crime Seen: Mary Payne Gilbert from Pink Shade Podcast @pinkshadepod.bsky.social joins the Seen to discuss THE MERCHANTS OF JOY on Prime. Watch it, and send us your comments and questions

Find Matt at:

Pod Friends https://robhasawebsite.com/shows/reality-tv-rhapups/pod-friends/ 

Find Mari at: 

Recap Kickback: https://recapkickback.com/

FInd Sarah at:

Silent Podcasts International:

https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/silent-podcasts/id1580483047

https://open.spotify.com/show/2L3VlGlusgx4Wpmb1QglWJ 

Support the creators at buymeacoffee.com/CrimeSeenPod 

Theme music by Will From America @willfromamerica.bsky.social

Logo by Tricky Rice @trickyrice.bsky.social 

You can follow the show @CrimeSeenPod on Bluesky, Instagram, Threads & Facebook, and @crime.seen on TikTok

Send us your feedback and recommendations for future episodes by email to [email protected] or by voice memo at speakpipe.com/CrimeSeenPod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices