At 11:45 p.m. on August 28th, 2024, a call comes in to Suffolk County emergency dispatch. It’s from teenage girls, frantic about a friend. She has just texted them from a moving car, terrified. Her father ordered her to come outside and get in, and now her mother isn’t answering the phone. Nine minutes later, the friend calls in herself. Her 50-year-old father, Daniel Copala, is walking through his house with a gun in his hand. While officers rush to restrain him, a second team reaches a quiet, upscale street in St. James, Long Island.
The mansion’s front door has been shot open. Inside are two people, dead on the floor. There’s no robbery and nothing disturbed, only a targeted attack. The victims were Kenneth “Kenny” Pullman, 53, a widower who raised his children alone, and Kelly Copala, 50, Daniel’s ex-husband’s former wife and the mother of the girl in that car. Their new life together looked happy, and they posted it online. Investigators say Daniel, who blamed Kelly for his financial troubles, had been watching.
Detectives found a typed document, ammunition labeled with names, and body-camera footage of his confession. Yet in court he pleaded not guilty. In this episode, we trace the divorce, the warning signs, and the night itself, and ask why a man whose gun permit had been revoked was able to keep firearms at home.
If you or someone you know is affected by domestic violence, please contact a local support service or emergency number. Subscribe for a new true crime case every week.