In this devastating episode, Charity takes listeners back to 1983 Griffin, Georgia—where racism, silence, and unchecked hatred converged to steal the life of 23-year-old Timothy Coggins. A charismatic, funny, deeply loved young Black man, Timothy was brutally tortured and murdered in an act of racial violence so horrific that it stunned even seasoned investigators.
For decades, the truth was buried—covered up by fear, intimidation, missing evidence, and a system poisoned by white supremacy. But time did not erase Timothy’s story. His family refused to forget. And more than 30 years later, a new generation of investigators reopened the case, determined to finally confront the evil that had been allowed to fester in their own community.
This episode exposes the brutality of the crime, the deep failures of the initial investigation, the racial terrorism inflicted on the Coggins family, and the relentless work that finally brought Timothy’s killers to justice.
This is the story of a life stolen by hate—and a family who never stopped fighting for truth.
Content Warning: Racism, hate crimes, torture, and graphic violence.
Episode Highlights
Timothy’s life: a beloved, energetic 23-year-old from a tight-knit family known for kindness, loyalty, and communityThe discovery of his mutilated body in a field near the “Hanging Tree”Evidence showing Timothy had been chained to a truck and dragged, stabbed repeatedly, beaten, and left to dieHow even local authorities failed to recognize him due to the severity of the injuriesThe conversation earlier that night where Timothy mentioned he was dating a white woman—an act that enraged local racistsUnease at the club: white men waiting outside, warnings ignored, and the moment Timothy was last seenOfficer Jordan’s early investigation and how leads pointed to Frank Gebhardt and Bill MooreThe sudden shutdown of the case by superiors—later tied to deputies with KKK affiliationsDecades of terror directed at the Coggins family: threats, vandalism, intimidation, and violence33 years of silence… until the case was reopened in 2017Missing evidence from the original file, raising suspicions of deliberate obstructionWitnesses who finally came forward, sharing decades of confessions and racist bragging by GebhardtThe excavation of Gebhardt’s well using hydrovac technology—and the breakthrough discovery:Shoes matching what Timothy woreA bloodied, slashed shirtA broken knife believed to be the murder weaponGebhardt’s long history of violence, racism, and bragging about Timothy’s murderProsecutor Marie Broder’s powerful, emotion-driven approach to the caseTestimonies from inmates, former neighbors, white supremacists, and even Gebhardt’s own circleThe defense’s disturbing strategy of dismissing witnesses as “trash”The jury’s ultimate decision:Frank Gebhardt — Guilty on all counts. Life in prison.Billy Moore — Pleaded guilty. 20-year sentence.Charges brought against others who obstructed justice, including law enforcementThe emotional interaction between Moore’s daughter and the Coggins family after the verdictTelisa Coggins’ powerful reflection on forgiveness and generational resilienceThe lasting impact of Timothy’s case on investigators, the prosecutor, and the communityReflection
Timothy Coggins was murdered because of the color of his skin and the hateful lies that racism breeds. His case forces us to confront an ugly truth: justice delayed is not just justice denied—it’s trauma prolonged. But Timothy’s family held on to hope, and when a new generation of investigators finally listened, the truth could no longer be buried.
This story is a reminder that confronting racism isn’t optional. It’s necessary. And justice, even late, still matters.
How the Lynching of Timothy Coggins Was Finally Solved After 34 Years | GQ
How the racially-motivated cold case murder of young Black man was finally solved decades later - ABC News
The Hate Crime Solved After 34 Years | HISTORY
Here's How a Georgia Prosecutor Got Justice for a Man Murdered Before She Was Born - A&E True Crime
Man convicted, sentenced to life in 1983 racially motivated killing in Georgia
Gebhardt v. Georgia :: 2019 :: Supreme Court of Georgia Decisions :: Georgia Case Law :: Georgia Law :: US Law :: Justia
Suspects Bragged About Dragging Black Man Behind Truck, Prosecutor Says
Sign up to be a Patron today! Get access to the Patron-Only Facebook Group, Bonus Episodes, and more.
https://www.escapepod.live
Do you have a story that you want to share with EscapePod? Or do you just want to reach out to us with your comments and thoughts?
General mail: [email protected]
Submit listener stories: [email protected]
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/EscapePod.traumedy
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/escape_pod_podcast/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Escape_Pod_podcast/videos
Subscribe and listen now- https://linktr.ee/escapepod57701
