In the final chapter of the Lisa Marie Kimmell series, Rocky Mountain Reckoning returns to the courtroom, the desert, and the decades-long legal maze that followed Dale Wayne Eaton’s conviction.

We break down:

This episode closes one of Wyoming’s most defining cases… and opens the door to the next.

Next on Rocky Mountain Reckoning:

📣 Calls to Action (Platform-Optimized)

If this episode moved you, follow the show, leave a rating, drop a review, and tap the thumbs-up wherever you listen. Your engagement keeps cold cases alive and supports independent investigative storytelling.

To support the show directly — including deep-dive research, record retrieval, and production — join us on:

For tips, case suggestions, or media inquiries, email: [email protected]

Sixteen years after an 18-year-old vanished from a Wyoming highway, the truth finally reached the courtroom.

From the emotionally charged jury selection to the forensic testimony that sealed his fate, this episode retraces each day of a landmark capital trial. Hear how science, law, and the unwavering resolve of a family collided inside Casper’s historic Natrona County Courthouse — where Lisa’s voice echoed once more after sixteen years of silence.

We examine the DNA breakthroughs, the psychological unraveling of Eaton’s defense, the rare death sentence handed down by a Wyoming jury, and the extraordinary civil judgment that gave Lisa’s family ownership of the very land where her car was buried. What they did with that land — and why — became one of the most powerful acts of reclamation in true-crime history.

This is justice, Wyoming-style: unflinching, human, and long overdue.

🔔 Calls to Action

If you believe in telling stories that give voice to the silenced—

Join the Dark Dialogue Collective, our boots-on-the-ground volunteer network that assists with searches, logistics, and family support.

Support our work directly on Patreon or Ko-fi, and subscribe on Substack for exclusive updates, case files, and behind-the-scenes analysis.

🌐 Visit www.darkdialogue.com for full case archives, updates, and ways to get involved.

In this haunting installment of Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning, host John McColl and co-host Angela return to the desolate plains of Wyoming, where justice finally clawed its way to the surface.

What investigators found beneath that earth rewrote a fifteen-year mystery. From the chilling excavation to the forensic science that proved Eaton’s guilt, to the strength of Sheila Kimmell’s unbreakable advocacy, this episode chronicles how truth can survive even when it’s buried in silence and dust.

You’ll walk the property, feel the tension of the dig, and stand in the quiet moment when the earth itself gave up its secret. Because sometimes justice doesn’t speak — it rises.

Follow and Review: Like, follow, and rate Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or YouTube. Tap the bell or leave a review to help others find these stories.

Support the Mission: Join the fight for truth through Patreon or Ko-fi — your support keeps independent investigations alive.

Get Involved: Visit darkdialogue.com to join the Dark Dialogue Collective, volunteer for boots-on-the-ground research, or explore the Adopt-a-Victim Program to help preserve cold-case legacies.

Stay Connected: Follow @DarkDialogue on social media for case updates and behind-the-scenes investigations.

Fifteen years after Lisa Marie Kimmell vanished on a lonely stretch of Wyoming highway, a single DNA sample whispered the name of her killer — Dale Wayne Eaton. DNA and the Man in the Desert follows the forensic trail that broke one of the state’s most haunting cold cases and revealed the predator who had stalked its plains for decades.

From the quiet hum of the crime lab to the empty desert where a family once fought for their lives, John and Angela retrace the chain of events that turned a forgotten rape kit into the voice that finally spoke for Lisa. This episode uncovers how Eaton’s violent past, his near-fatal 1997 kidnapping of a Michigan family, and his drifter existence all converged to expose a killer hiding in plain sight.

With cinematic storytelling and investigative precision, Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning brings you inside the case that proved justice can rise from silence — and that sometimes, survival itself is the key to solving a murder.

If this episode moved you, like, follow, and leave a review wherever you listen — it helps keep these cases in the light.

📂 Explore more: Visit darkdialogue.com for case files, victim tributes, photos, and updates from across the Mountain West.

🕯️ Join the mission: Become part of the Dark Dialogue Collective — our volunteer research network committed to advocacy, forensic analysis, and remembrance.

💀 Support the work:

Patreon → patreon.com/DarkDialoguePod

Ko-fi → ko-fi.com/darkdialogue

📬 Stay connected:

🕯️ Join the Dark Dialogue Collective: Become part of our volunteer network for research and advocacy.

💀 Support the mission:

Patreon → patreon.com/DarkDialoguePod

Ko-fi → ko-fi.com/darkdialogue

📬 Stay connected:

Silence can be louder than any answer.

In this episode of Rocky Mountain Reckoning: Dark Dialogue, John and Angela revisit the long, painful years after the 1988 murder of Lisa Marie Kimmell—the bright 18-year-old whose life was stolen along a Wyoming highway. For more than a decade, her family lived with grief and questions while investigators faced false leads, dead ends, and mounting frustration.

You’ll hear about:

The dead-end years (1988–2002): false confessions, cult rumors, and missed opportunities that let Lisa’s killer walk free.

The Stringfellow Hawke letter: a cryptic note left on Lisa’s grave that haunted her family for years—later tied directly to the man who murdered her.

The emotional toll: how birthdays, holidays, and long nights of waiting wore on Lisa’s parents, sisters, and community.

The broader pattern: a chilling reminder that Lisa was not the only woman to vanish across the highways and plains of the American West.

This is the story of frustration, silence, and resilience—the fight of a family who refused to let Lisa be forgotten, even when the system faltered.

If Lisa’s story moves you, don’t let it fade into silence.

Every listen, every share, and every show of support helps us keep the dialogue alive—and ensures that stories like Lisa’s are never forgotten.

🕯️ What the River Gave Back dives into the chilling moment Lisa Marie Kimmell was found—eight days after her disappearance—in the frigid waters of the North Platte River. Naked. Weighted down. Brutally assaulted. And discarded like she didn’t matter.

But Lisa mattered.

We unpack:

The forensic evidence recovered in 1988—and what it couldn’t yet reveal

The iconic “LIL MISS” license plate that became a symbol of both heartbreak and hope

The media storm that swept through Wyoming and Montana, changing public fear forever

The critical investigative failures that let a killer walk free for 14 years

The family’s courage in demanding answers when no one else could deliver them

💔 Lisa’s story wasn’t just a headline. It was a reckoning. And in this episode, we begin to understand what the river gave back—and what it couldn’t wash away.

🎧 Listen now and make the guilty face the reckoning.

🧾 Get full transcripts, case files, and exclusive content: darkdialoguecrime.substack.com

☕ Fuel the investigation with a one-time gift: ko-fi.com/darkdialogue

💬 Join the discussion on Discord: discord.gg/MeghDycm

📬 Contact us: [email protected]

🔔 Subscribe. Follow. Share.

What happens when a bright, responsible 18-year-old vanishes on a road she’s traveled countless times?

In this gripping premiere of Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning, we begin the haunting case of Lisa Marie Kimmell—known to those who loved her as “Lil Miss.” In March 1988, Lisa left her job in Aurora, Colorado, and set off for a weekend road trip north. She never made it.

With no signs of a crash, no frantic calls, and only a fleeting last sighting by a Wyoming Highway Patrol officer, Lisa’s disappearance stunned investigators and devastated her family. This episode takes you deep into her early life in Montana, her move to Colorado with her mother, the final drive she planned—and the tragic silence that followed.

Hosts John and Angela peel back the layers of this real-life mystery, exposing how jurisdictional gaps, vast Western landscapes, and lost hours contributed to one of the most baffling disappearances of the 1980s.

🎧 Tune in as we retrace her final moments, explore what was known and what was missed, and pay tribute to a life interrupted far too soon.

💡 Want to go deeper?

Subscribe to our Substack for episode transcripts and bonus content: darkdialoguecrime.substack.com

Support the show and fuel future investigations: patreon.com/DarkDialoguePod | ko-fi.com/DarkDialogue

Join our investigative community on Discord

📩 Reach out: [email protected]

🔔 Don’t forget to like, follow, and subscribe. Your support keeps these stories alive—and helps make the guilty face the reckoning.

In 1983, Janelle Johnson was chasing her dreams. Just 23 years old, she traveled from Riverton, Wyoming to Denver for a modeling interview at Vannoy Talent Center. She called home to check in, planned her return—and vanished.

Two weeks later, her body was discovered on a desolate stretch of Muskrat Creek Road near Shoshoni. She had been brutally assaulted, strangled, and left in a shallow grave. The forensic evidence that could have identified her killer was collected—then destroyed in a failed police refrigerator. Forty years later, her case remains unsolved.

In this episode of Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning, John and Angela retrace Janelle’s final journey. From her ambitions as a small-town girl chasing big-city dreams to the dark realities of hitchhiking in the Great Basin during the 1980s, they explore the suspects who could have been responsible: Dale Wayne Eaton, Robert Ben Rhoades, Larry Hall, and the unknown predators who stalked Wyoming’s highways.

This is more than a murder story—it’s a story of systemic failure, lost justice, and a young woman who should never be forgotten.

👉 If you know anything about the murder of Janelle Johnson, contact the National Organization of Parents Of Murdered Children at (513) 721-5683 or darkdialogue.com | Join the Dark Dialogue Collective | Adopt-a-Victim Initiative

Because justice delayed is justice denied.

Naomi Kidder wasn’t a runaway. She wasn’t reckless. She was an 18-year-old mother trying to find her way in the rural sprawl of 1980s Wyoming. And in the summer of 1982, she disappeared—leaving behind a baby daughter, a devastated family, and a trail of silence that lasted over a decade.

In this episode of Dark Dialogue: Rocky Mountain Reckoning, we unravel the heartbreaking story of Naomi Kidder—who vanished after hitchhiking out of Rawlins and was later found strangled with barbed wire in a remote patch of Natrona County. For 12 years, she was a Jane Doe. Her name wasn't added to any national databases. Her dental records weren’t uploaded. Her killer was never found.

John and Angela trace the deeply personal and systemically failed case from Naomi’s final days to the discovery of her body, through the tangled web of suspects, including serial predators like Larry DeWayne Hall and Dale Wayne Eaton. We break down the evidence, the missed opportunities, and the haunting legacy left for Naomi’s daughter, Bobbi.

This is more than just another cold case.

This is Naomi’s story.

🎧 Support Our Work:

Subscribe, follow, and leave a review

Visit darkdialogue.com for full transcripts, bonus content, and case updates

Join the Dark Dialogue Collective and Adopt-a-Victim program

Support us on Patreon or Ko-fi

Submit tips or suggestions: [email protected]

📞 If you have information on Naomi Kidder’s murder, contact the National Organization of Parents of Murdered Children at (513) 721-5683 or email [email protected].

How many serial killers does it take before a region sounds the damn alarm? Apparently, more than a dozen.

In this blistering special episode of Rocky Mountain Reckoning, John and Angela put the regular format on pause and turn their full attention to the monsters who stalked the Great Basin from the 1960s to the early 2000s. With names like Bundy, Long, Rhoades, Hall, Baldwin, and the Gallegos, this episode peels back the brutal truth of just how many sadistic killers were prowling the very same highways, truck stops, and rural corridors — often at the same damn time.

From vanished hitchhikers to dumped bodies in Wyoming’s backcountry, from botched investigations to lost DNA evidence, this is the episode where John’s fury is unleashed. These weren’t just killers — they were roaming predators enabled by silence, incompetence, and indifference.

Why this region? Why so many? And how many are still out there, unaccounted for?

Featuring deep research, gallows humor, and seething disgust, this episode is for the victims — both named and nameless — and for anyone who refuses to let their stories be forgotten.

🎧 Listen if you dare — and prepare to be outraged.

🧩 Join the Dark Dialogue Collective to aid in cold case research: https://www.darkdialogue.com

☕ Fuel the show on Ko-fi: https://ko-fi.com/darkdialogue

📰 Subscribe on Substack for behind-the-scenes content: https://substack.com/@darkdialogue1

💸 Become a patron: https://www.patreon.com/darkdialoguepod

📩 Got a tip or want to get involved? Email: [email protected]

🖤 For the victims — we see you, we remember you, we will not let you be erased.