In Episode 3 of Deadly Devotion, we explore the mysterious death of Susan Sills — a successful businesswoman, mother of twins, and co-founder of a Southern California fertility clinic whose death was initially believed to be a tragic accident.
When Susan was found at the bottom of a staircase inside her San Clemente home in 2016, her husband, fertility doctor Eric Scott Sills, told investigators she had fallen during the night while suffering from a migraine.
At first, the explanation seemed possible.
But as investigators looked closer, troubling questions began to emerge.
Blood evidence found throughout the home…
injuries that raised forensic concerns…
a marriage reportedly filled with growing tension behind closed doors…
and a scene prosecutors later argued had been carefully staged.
In this episode, we examine the investigation, the courtroom battle between accident and homicide, the emotional toll on Susan’s children and family, and the hidden dynamics that can exist inside relationships that appear successful from the outside.
We also discuss the realities of domestic violence, coercive control, and why leaving unhealthy relationships is often far more complicated than people realize.
Most importantly, we remember Susan Sills for who she was beyond the headlines — a mother, a woman with ambition and intelligence, and someone deeply loved by the people closest to her.
Because at the center of every case…
is a life that mattered.
Sources for Episode 3 — The Story of Susan Sills
- NBC News
www.nbcnews.com - Los Angeles Times — Coverage of the Susan Sills murder trial and conviction
www.latimes.com - CBS News / 48 Hours — Did the dogs play a role or was the scene staged to cover a murder?
www.cbsnews.com
www.paramountpressexpress.com/cbs-news-and-stations/shows/48-hours/releases/?view=109829-the-wife-of-a-fertility-doctor-is-found-dead-did-her-dogs-play-a-role-or-was-the-scene-staged-to-cover-a-murder - Fox News — Reporting on the conviction of fertility doctor Eric Scott Sills
www.foxnews.com - CrimeOnline — Coverage of the investigation, arrest, and sentencing
www.crimeonline.com - Court records and publicly available trial reporting related to the conviction of Eric Scott Sills in Orange County, California
Additional background reporting and timeline verification from:
- www.people.com
- www.oxygen.com
- www.abcnews.go.com
If you or someone you know may be experiencing domestic abuse, help is available. The National Domestic Violence Hotline provides free, confidential support 24/7.
Call: 1-800-799-SAFE (7233)
Text “START” to 88788
Website: The Hotline
You are not alone, and support is available whenever you’re ready.