Deadly Truths

Deadly Truths

By onlydeadlytruthsTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Deadly Truths episodes

  • The Rowan County War: Kentucky’s Bloodiest Feud - The Frontier is Dead

    Kentucky has seen violence, but nothing like what hit Rowan County in the 1880s.
    This wasn’t a feud — it was a war.

    In this episode, we uncover the brutal story of The Rowan County War, a three-year bloodbath that turned the quiet town of Morehead into a battlefield. What began as a political dispute exploded into public executions, ambushes, burned homes, and open-street shootouts, all led by the ruthless Craig Tolliver and his armed clan.

    You’ll hear how a single Election Day killing lit the fuse… how Sheriff James Hogg’s daylight murder pushed the governor to deploy the Kentucky State Guard… and how the final, violent siege at the American Hotel ended one of the deadliest family conflicts in Kentucky history.

    This is a story of power, revenge, and a town held hostage by fear.

    This is Kentucky’s bloodiest feud.
    This is Deadly Truths.

    Follow, Rate & Share

    If this episode pulled you in, do one quick thing to support the show:

    Follow, rate, and share Deadly Truths on:

    • Spotify

    • Apple Podcasts

    • YouTube

    • Amazon Music

    Your support keeps these forgotten American stories alive — and helps new listeners find the show.

    Resources & References

    Primary Historical Sources

    • The Kentucky State Guard Reports, 1885–1888

    • Rowan County Courthouse Documents & Inquest Records

    • Official Correspondence of Governor J. Proctor Knott

    • Contemporary newspaper coverage:

      • The Louisville Courier-Journal

      • The Lexington Herald

      • The Cincinnati Enquirer

    • Eyewitness accounts preserved in the Kentucky Historical Society Archives

    Secondary Sources / Research

    • Collins, Lewis. History of Kentucky, Vol. II.

    • Caudill, Harry. Night Comes to the Cumberlands.

    • Brown, H.C. The Rowan County War.

    • Kentucky Humanities: “The Tolliver-Martin Feud”

    • Morehead State University Special Collections on the Rowan County Feud


      Disclaimer

      This episode of Deadly Truths is for educational, historical, and documentary purposes only.
      All events are presented based on recorded history, archival research, and publicly available documents.
      Descriptions of violence and historical events are not intended to sensationalize but to accurately portray the brutality of the era.
      All opinions expressed are my own.

    20 min
  • The Murder of Pearl Bryan: The Headless Mystery of 1896 - Dead State

    In 1896, the body of 22-year-old Pearl Bryan was found in a frozen Kentucky field—
    pregnant, murdered, and beheaded.
    Her killers, Scott Jackson and Alonzo Walling, were educated, well-dressed medical students.
    Her missing head was never found.

    This episode uncovers Pearl’s final days, the lies that lured her into danger, the forensic trail that exposed her killers, and the explosive double execution that shocked America. We examine the rumors of satanic rituals, the courtroom chaos, and the haunting legends that still cling to the Ohio River valley.

    More than a murder, this is a case about control, cruelty, and the one question history still can’t answer:
    Where is Pearl Bryan’s head?

    This is Deadly Truths: Kentucky Bloodlines.

    If this episode gripped you, take a moment to follow, rate, and share Deadly Truths on:

    • Spotify

    • Apple Podcasts

    • YouTube

    • Amazon Music

    Your support keeps these forgotten stories alive and helps new listeners discover the show.

    Deadly Truths is created for educational, historical, and documentary purposes.
    The violence described in this episode reflects the documented brutality of the real case.
    Nothing is dramatized for entertainment beyond the historical record.
    Listener discretion is advised due to graphic historical content.

    Primary Sources

    • Court Records of Commonwealth vs. Scott Jackson & Alonzo Walling (1896–1897)

    • Hamilton County Coroner’s Reports (Cincinnati, Ohio)

    • Kentucky State Archives – Fort Thomas Investigation Papers

    • Contemporary newspaper coverage from:

      • Cincinnati Enquirer

      • Louisville Courier-Journal

      • Indianapolis News

      • New York World

    • Witness testimony from the Newport Jail interrogations

    • Letters between Pearl Bryan and Scott Jackson (entered into trial evidence)

    Secondary Sources / Research

    • Hensley, Mary. The Pearl Bryan Murder Case.

    • Kentucky Historical Society – “The Headless Mystery of Pearl Bryan”

    • Talbott, Tim. Kentucky Gruesome Crimes & Trials.

    • Morehead State University Special Collections

    • Ohio River Valley Folklore Archives – Pearl Bryan legends & oral histories

    • Newport History Museum – Execution Records of Jackson & Walling

    21 min
  • Brutal Murder of Brenda Sue Schaefer - Dead City

    Brenda Sue Schaefer was 36, kind, devout, and ready to end her relationship with Mel Ignatow — a controlling, 51-year-old real estate broker from Louisville. On September 23, 1988, she vanished.

    For years, Ignatow taunted investigators, manipulating the media while police searched for proof. When her body was finally found, the case still fell apart in court — and Ignatow walked free.

    Then, six months later, a man remodeling Ignatow’s home opened a floor vent… and found five undeveloped rolls of film. The photographs showed everything — the torture, the murder, and Ignatow’s face.

    But it was too late. He couldn’t be retried.

    This is the story of one of America’s most haunting miscarriages of justice — where truth surfaced, but justice never did.

    🔊 Follow & Support:

    Follow Deadly Truths on Spotify, YouTube, and Apple Podcasts.
    Rate, review, and share to help keep these forgotten stories alive.

    ⚠️ Disclaimer:

    This episode contains descriptions of violence and sexual assault. Listener discretion is advised.

    📚 Sources:

    • The Courier-Journal (Louisville), 1988–2008

    • FBI Evidence Archives — Case File “Schaefer, Brenda Sue”

    • People v. Ignatow (Jefferson County Circuit Court, 1991)

    • ABC Primetime Live — “Justice Too Late” (1993)

    • Lee Strobel, Reckless Faith

    • The New York Times — “Man Admits Killing Woman He Was Cleared of Slaying” (1992)

    16 min
  • Two Trunks, One Ticket: The Butcher of Lexington (1901) - Dead City

    In December 1901, two young women vanished from a Lexington boarding house. Days later, two wooden trunks arrived in Cincinnati — leaking blood.
    Inside were the dismembered remains of Lillian Rodin and Minnie Everly… and the calling card of a man named Claude O’Brien.

    He was charming, well-dressed, and deadly — a salesman who turned seduction into slaughter.
    His arrest and public hanging shocked Kentucky, giving birth to forensic science in the Bluegrass and inspiring one of America’s earliest urban legends: O’Brien’s boxes.

    This episode of Deadly Truths: Kentucky Bloodlines dives into the real story behind the “Cutting-Box Murders,” the public spectacle of O’Brien’s trial, and how Victorian morality turned two murdered women into footnotes while turning their killer into folklore.

    Kentucky true crime, Lexington murders, 1901 trunk murders, Claude O’Brien, Lillian Rodin, Minnie Everly, Kentucky history, historical crime podcast, Deadly Truths, American serial killers, female victims, cutting box murders, public execution history, forensic origins, haunted Kentucky, Bluegrass crimes, Becca Clark podcast

    This episode contains historical accounts of extreme violence, including murder, dismemberment, and execution. Listener discretion is advised. All events are presented using verified archival sources and historical documentation.

    • The Lexington Herald (Dec 12–20, 1901)

    • The Cincinnati Enquirer (Dec 13, 1901 – Apr 11, 1902)

    • Fayette County Court Records: Commonwealth v. O’Brien (1902)

    • University of Kentucky Special Collections, “Lexington Murder Files, 1900–1905”

    • Kentucky Historical Society: Hanged in the Bluegrass: Executions 1865–1930

    If you found this story compelling, follow Deadly Truths on Spotify, YouTube, and Apple Podcasts.
    Rate ★★★★★, share the episode, and help keep these forgotten histories alive.

    15 min
  • The Harpe Brothers: America’s First Serial Killers - The Frontier is Dead

    Before the words serial killer ever existed, the frontier already knew their kind.

    In the late 1790s, Micajah “Big Harpe” and Wiley “Little Harpe” roamed the Kentucky-Tennessee wilderness with three captive “wives” and a trail of mutilated bodies behind them. They didn’t kill for money or revenge — they killed because it made them feel alive.

    This season premiere of Deadly Truths takes you into the birth of American sadism — a land without law, mercy, or conscience.
    From the Revolutionary War’s ruins to the first roadside manhunt, this is where America learned what evil really looked like.

    Follow Becca as she unearths the true story of the Harpe brothers — the ghostly legends who turned Kentucky’s frontier into a graveyard.

    🔗 Follow, rate, and share on Spotify, YouTube, and Apple Podcasts — it keeps these forgotten histories alive.

    📚 Sources: Kentucky Historical Society Archives; Tennessee State Library & Archives Frontier Justice Collection; Bruce McLeod, Bad Men of the Frontier South; Paul I. Wellman, Spawn of Evil (1947).

    ⚖️ Disclaimer: This episode contains descriptions of graphic violence, including child homicide and historical mutilation, intended for mature audiences only.

    19 min
  • The Forgotten Names of the Public Enemy Era - The Mob is Dead

    They weren’t the legends — they were the wreckage left behind.
    In this Morally Bankrupt season finale, we go beyond Dillinger, Nelson, and Bonnie & Clyde to uncover the men who died forgotten: John Paul Chase, Homer Van Meter, Adam Richetti, Doc Barker, Red Hamilton, Eddie Green, and others erased by J. Edgar Hoover’s myth-making machine.

    They bled out in cornfields, cheap hotels, and back alleys while the FBI built its empire and Hollywood wrote its heroes.
    This episode strips away the headlines to show what really happened when the spotlight moved on — the loyalty, betrayal, and quiet deaths of America’s last bandits.

    You’ll hear:
    • The Kansas City Massacre’s forgotten fallout
    • The bloody trail from Little Bohemia to Chicago
    • The death of Doc Barker and the prison system that broke him
    • How Hoover turned corpses into propaganda

    🎧 Listen now — and remember the ones history buried.

    This podcast is for educational and historical analysis. It contains descriptions of real violence and archival material from the 1930s gangster era. Listener discretion is advised.

    FBI case files (1933–1935)
    National Archives – Public Enemies Collection
    The Dillinger Days by John Toland (1963)
    St. Paul Police Historical Society – Public Enemy Era Records
    Newspaper archives: Chicago Tribune, Kansas City Star, St. Paul Pioneer Press

    If you found this story compelling — follow, rate, and share Deadly Truths on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.
    Your support keeps these forgotten histories alive.

    24 min
  • Creepy Karpis: The Last Public Enemy | The Mob is Dead

    He was the last man standing — calm, brilliant, and impossible to catch.
    Alvin “Creepy” Karpis wasn’t the romantic outlaw Hoover’s FBI wanted you to believe in.
    He was the strategist — the man who made the Bureau look foolish, survived Alcatraz, and taught a young Charles Manson how to play guitar.

    This episode of Deadly Truths: Morally Bankrupt exposes the truth behind Hoover’s staged arrest, the propaganda that buried Karpis’s legacy, and the irony of America’s final Public Enemy — a man who never killed for pleasure, but who understood power better than anyone chasing him.

    “Everyone wants control,” Karpis wrote. “The difference between a gangster and a government is who gets to call it justice.”

    If you found this story compelling, follow, rate, and share Deadly Truths on Spotify, YouTube, and Apple Podcasts — it helps keep these forgotten histories alive.
    Watch extended visuals and short episodes on YouTube and TikTok under Deadly Truths with Becca.

    This episode contains historical descriptions of organized crime, violence, and federal law enforcement corruption.
    Listener discretion is advised.
    All research and narration © 2025 Deadly Truths Media.

    • Public Enemy Number One by Alvin Karpis

    • On the Rock by Alvin Karpis & Robert Livesey

    • FBI and U.S. Department of Justice declassified case archives

    • Newspaper archives: St. Paul Pioneer Press, Chicago Tribune, New Orleans Times-Picayune

    25 min
  • “Machine Gun” Kelly Public Enemy - The Mob is Dead

    He never fired the gun that made him famous.
    He never wanted to be an outlaw.
    But his wife — and the FBI — turned him into one.

    In 1933, George “Machine Gun” Kelly shouted “Don’t shoot, G-men!” as federal agents surrounded a Memphis farmhouse.
    It was the line that built the legend — and the lie — that made J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI a national empire.

    In this 40-minute episode of Deadly Truths: Morally Bankrupt, Becca unravels the story of fear, ambition, and manipulation behind the myth:
    how Kathryn Kelly manufactured her husband’s persona,
    how the Urschel kidnapping changed federal law,
    and how a terrified man became the symbol of a new kind of American justice —
    one built on image, not truth.

    If this story made you question what’s myth and what’s history —
    share it, like it, and follow wherever you listen to Deadly Truths.
    Every follow keeps these forgotten histories alive.

    This episode contains historical descriptions of kidnapping, imprisonment, and violence.
    Listener discretion is advised.
    All material is based on verified historical records, FBI case files, and reputable academic and journalistic sources.
    Some dialogue and internal reflections are dramatized for pacing and atmosphere but remain true to documented events.

    • FBI Case File: The Urschel Kidnapping (1933)

    • U.S. District Court Transcripts, Western District of Oklahoma (1933)

    • Public Enemies by Bryan Burrough (2004)

    • Oklahoma Historical Society Archives: Kathryn Kelly Interviews

    • Alcatraz Inmate Records and Correspondence, 1934–1954

    • Federal Bureau of Investigation Press Releases, 1933–1935

    • The Life and Death of Pretty Boy Floyd by Jeffery King (1998) [contextual cross-reference]

    • American Justice: The Rise of the FBI – Smithsonian Oral History Collection

    “The past isn’t dead."
    — Deadly Truths: Morally Bankrupt

    31 min
  • The Blast Inside the Walls — The Leavenworth Explosion (Halloween Finale)

    On April 7th, 1919, a violent explosion ripped through the U.S. Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth — a blast so powerful it shattered windows a mile away and left dozens of soldiers dead.
    The government called it an accident.
    The prisoners called it revenge.
    And more than a century later, guards still whisper that something beneath those walls remembers.

    In this Halloween finale, Becca unearths the haunting true story of The Blast Inside the Walls — a mix of fact, fire, and the ghosts of justice gone wrong.

    This episode of Deadly Truths contains historical accounts of death, military justice, and violence. Listener discretion is advised.
    All sources are cited and verified through official records and archival materials.
    While the haunting elements are dramatized for storytelling, the historical foundation remains factual.📚 Resources & References:

    • The Leavenworth Times (1919–1921 incident reports)

    • Army Signal Corps Archives

    • U.S. Disciplinary Barracks Fire Investigation Records (1919)

    • Fort Leavenworth Military Historical Society

    🔗 Connect & Support:

    Follow, rate, and share Deadly Truths on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube — it helps keep these forgotten histories alive.
    🎥 Watch the video versions and short visual stories on TikTok and YouTube under Only Deadly Truths with Becca.
    🩶 New bonus season out now: Morally Bankrupt — the true stories of America’s 1930s bank robbers, from Dillinger to Bonnie & Clyde.

    12 min
  • Pretty Boy Floyd: The Outlaw America Needed - The Mob is Dead

    He robbed banks when the banks were robbing everyone else.
    He burned mortgage records so families could keep their homes.
    And when the FBI called him Public Enemy Number One, Oklahoma called him a hero.

    In this episode of Deadly Truths, we uncover the rise and fall of Pretty Boy Floyd — from barefoot farm boy to Depression-era legend — and how the government’s war on crime turned a desperate man into an American myth.

    Was he a cold-blooded killer… or the outlaw America needed most?

    Some will rob you with a six-gun, and some with a fountain pen.
    — Woody Guthrie

    Share, Follow, and Like!

    49 min

About Deadly Truths

From the publisher's feed

Deadly Truths exposes the crimes, cover-ups, and institutional failures buried in American history. From forgotten murders and cold cases to Hollywood myths, mob violence, and frontier bloodshed—this…