Dear Jane

Dear Jane

By Scott Baker & Marcie LittleSociety & CultureNewsNews CommentaryPhilosophy
Download on the App Store

Dear Jane episodes

  • Is the Pro-Life Movement Divided Over Equal Protection?

    The pro-life movement suffered significant setbacks at the ballot box in Virginia, Missouri, and Nevada. But do these defeats mean voters have abandoned the fight to protect preborn lives?

    Not necessarily.

    Monica Snyder, executive director of Secular Pro-Life, joins Dear Jane to examine the factors behind these losses, from overwhelming spending by pro-abortion groups to confusing ballot language and growing divisions within the pro-life movement.

    And one of the most contentious disagreements centers on equal protection under the law.

    Should women who obtain abortions face homicide charges, lesser penalties, or no criminal charges at all? Monica's recent survey reveals a widening divide between pro-life advocates and abortion abolitionists over criminal accountability and enforcement.

    Meanwhile, the growing availability of abortion pills is creating an entirely new set of challenges. With abortions increasingly taking place outside traditional abortion facilities, how can lawmakers effectively enforce protections for preborn children while accounting for coercion, deception, and natural miscarriages?

    As the pro-life movement confronts internal divisions and new threats to preborn lives, one question remains: are we fighting the right battles?

    Mentioned in this episode

    Monica’s full survey results: What does “abortion abolitionist” mean?

    https://secularprolife.org/2026/11/abortion-abolitionist-meaning-survey/

    Monica’s article on enforcing equal protection laws

    https://secularprolife.org/2026/04/6-reasons-equal-protection-enforcement/

    Secular Pro-Life

    https://secularprolife.org

    Stay connected with Dear Jane. Join the email list for new episodes, bonus content, and behind-the-scenes updates.

    Watch this thought-provoking conversation on Dear Jane about the future of pro-life legislation, equal protection under the law, and the growing challenges of protecting preborn lives as abortion pills become increasingly accessible.

    52 min
  • Since Every Life Is Precious, Why Is Rape the Exception?

    Rebecca Kiessling learned at 18 that she was conceived in rape.

    A year later, she met her birth mother and learned the devastating details: she had been abducted at knifepoint by a serial rapist and later attempted twice to obtain an illegal abortion. Rebecca credits Michigan's pro-life laws at the time with saving her life.

    Today, Rebecca is an attorney and founder of Save The 1, an international organization representing people conceived in rape and mothers who became pregnant through rape. Her message is unequivocal: no child should be punished for the circumstances of their conception.

    Yet even within the pro-life movement, rape exceptions remain a contentious issue.

    Scott raises one of the most difficult questions surrounding these exceptions: Isn't requiring a woman to carry a child conceived in rape forcing her to live with a constant reminder of her attacker?

    Rebecca challenges that premise. Why should an innocent child bear responsibility for a rapist's crime? She shares stories of women who have found healing through motherhood and explains how abortion can sometimes conceal ongoing sexual abuse, leaving perpetrators free to continue their crimes.

    Perhaps most troubling are Rebecca's experiences within the pro-life movement itself. She recounts instances in which pro-life leaders opposed her efforts to testify against rape exceptions, including one conversation in which she says she was told supporters were “better off not knowing” those exceptions existed.

    How can the pro-life movement advocate for the protection of every preborn child while supporting legislation that excludes some of them?

    Rebecca also confronts the dehumanizing language directed at people conceived in rape, including being labeled “rapist's children,” “evil seed,” and even “demon seed.” Her response is as simple as it is profound: “Did God not create me?”

    Throughout this powerful conversation, Rebecca challenges the pro-life movement to confront its compromises, listen to voices too often overlooked, and recognize the inherent dignity of every human life, regardless of how that life began.

    Because an innocent child's right to life should never depend on the circumstances of conception.

    Stay connected with Dear Jane. Join the email list for new episodes, bonus content, and behind-the-scenes updates.

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    ----

    2:17 — I Was Conceived in Rape

    2:50 — The Law That Protected Her Life

    3:08 — Two Illegal Abortion Attempts

    4:20 — “She Should Have Aborted Me”

    5:28 — Why Make Rape the Exception?

    6:28 — Are These Children Less Protected?

    8:32 — Learning the Truth at 18

    9:23 — Pro-Life Before She Knew Why

    11:11 — The Images She Never Forgot

    12:51 — Is the Child a “Horrible Reminder”?

    14:09 — Who Is the Real Reminder of the Rape?

    15:36 — Does Abortion Hide the Abuse?

    17:50 — When the Perpetrator Stays Protected

    20:06 — Can the Child Become Part of Healing?

    21:35 — Why Don’t We Hear These Women?

    23:28 — Why Some Pro-Life Leaders Don’t Want Them Testifying

    26:01 — What Are We Really Saying With Exceptions?

    28:28 — Does Pain Determine Who Gets Protected?

    29:35 — What Support Do Rape Victims Actually Need?

    30:55 — Stop Calling Them “Rapist’s Children”

    32:44 — “Demon Seed”?

    34:14 — “Did God Not Create Me?”

    35:16 — Is the Pro-Life Movement Still Stuck?

    36:13 — When Pastors Recommend Abortion

    38:00 — What Pregnancy Centers Can Do

    40:16 — Why Stories Change the Fight

    42:24 — What Happens When the Movement Won’t Respond?

    45:19 — The “Fringe” Issues That Aren’t Fringe

    46:01 — Where to Find Save the 1

    48:03 — The Loss That Changed Everything

    50 min
  • If Life Begins at Conception, Why Does Legal Protection Start Later?

    Ginna Cross, an RN and pregnancy-center leader with Alliance Family Services, says her organization has been banned from pregnancy-center coalitions in Wisconsin and Tennessee because of one conviction: preborn children should receive the same legal protection as everyone else.

    That position has put her at odds with parts of the movement she serves.

    Ginna joins Scott and Marcie to argue that rescuing individual lives is not enough if the law still leaves those lives unprotected. For her, equal protection is not a political side issue. It's a question of whether the pro-life movement is willing to follow its own convictions.

    Scott presses her on the consequences. Would pregnancy centers become reporting agencies? Would women still trust them enough to walk through the door? And what happens when abortion pills can be ordered online and taken privately at home?

    Ginna argues that the law does more than establish consequences. It also shapes how society views abortion. She believes extending equal protection to preborn children would deter abortions, even as Scott and Marcie raise questions about enforcement, interstate travel, and the growing availability of abortion pills.

    But the conversation ultimately returns to a more fundamental question: If life begins at conception, why settle for a six-week ban? Why make exceptions that seem to contradict the belief that every preborn child is fully human? And if pro-life laws continue to accommodate public opinion, can those laws ever help change it?

    Ginna believes those compromises are creating confusion within the pro-life movement, weakening its message, and making it harder to mobilize Christians to pursue equal protection.

    Since life begins at conception, why doesn't the law protect it from that moment?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    Don't miss what's next. Join the Dear Jane email list for new episodes, bonus content, and behind-the-scenes updates.

    37 min
  • Who Decides When a Life Is No Longer Worth Living?

    When the cameras were off, Lori Kehoe asked an assisted-suicide advocate a disturbing question, "Could society ever have an interest in the death of someone who doesn't want to die?"

    According to Lori, his answer was immediate: of course.

    It's a chilling exchange that raises a much larger question: when does the right to die become the duty to die?

    In this episode of Dear Jane, Lori Kehoe of New York State Right to Life joins Dear Jane to examine New York's newly enacted assisted-suicide law and the troubling questions surrounding autonomy, coercion, and the value of human life.

    The law includes a five-day waiting period, recorded patient requests, mental health evaluations, and restrictions on who can serve as a witness. But Lori questions whether these safeguards can adequately protect vulnerable patients and whether they will remain in place.

    What happens when someone already feels like a burden? When the cost of care enters the conversation? Or when a patient's life is judged by someone else's definition of suffering?

    Lori shares troubling accounts involving elderly and disabled patients, the financial pressures surrounding end-of-life care, and a dying woman whose husband reportedly told her she was draining the life out of him. The conversation also turns personal as Lori recalls her father's final days and Marcie introduces the idea of "toxic empathy,"when the desire to relieve suffering risks overshadowing the value of the person who suffers.

    New York's assisted-suicide law took years to pass, and Lori explains why she believes people in other states should pay attention now, before similar legislation reaches their communities.

    When compassion becomes permission to end a life, who decides whose life is worth protecting?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    39 min
  • Are Pro-Life Voters Tuning Out at the Worst Time?

    Pro-life voters are frustrated. And with another election approaching, that frustration could have consequences.

    Add gas prices, wars, and the cost of living, and it’s easy to see why some are tired. Scott and Marcie feel that frustration too. But the other side may be counting on it.

    This November, abortion-related measures are on the ballot in Idaho, Missouri, Nevada, and Virginia, with campaign contributions heavily favoring the pro-abortion side in three of the four states. In Nevada and Virginia, the funding disparity is particularly pronounced, while Missouri has also seen significantly more money directed against the pro-life measure. Idaho stands apart, with contributions more evenly divided.

    Then there’s the ballot itself. In Missouri, the pro-life vote is yes, while yard signs urge, “Protect women and families, vote no.” If Marcie, who has worked on multiple ballot initiatives, can still second-guess herself in the booth, how can voters be expected to navigate confusing ballot language without preparation?

    Missouri offers another warning. In 2024, some national pro-life voices wrote off its abortion amendment because the polls looked lopsided. It passed by about three percentage points.

    And the stakes don’t end with amendments. Attorneys general and judges can shape which laws are defended in court long after Election Day.

    Know what’s on your ballot before November 3. Understand what yes and no actually mean. Bring a cheat sheet if you need one.

    The point is simple: Don’t let frustration make the decision for you.

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    30 min
  • If Abortion Is Already Legal in Virginia, Why Change the Constitution?

    What happens when a major constitutional amendment is approaching a vote, but even some of the people most engaged with the issue don't know it's happening?

    Thomas Hill, co-founder of Virginia for Preborn Justice, joins Scott and Marcie to discuss Virginia's proposed abortion amendment and the challenges facing those organizing against it.

    Thomas says he's encountered sidewalk counselors, pregnancy center volunteers, and college students who knew little or nothing about the amendment. Meanwhile, supporters of the measure have spent years developing their messaging and organizing efforts.

    But what happens when voters begin asking questions? At Virginia Tech, Thomas recalls a 25-minute conversation with a pro-choice student who walked away reconsidering how she would vote. He explains why he believes focusing on the preborn child changes the conversation, including among people who disagree about abortion.

    The discussion also explores disagreements over messaging within the pro-life movement, efforts to build coalitions across political and religious lines, and the importance of understanding what the proposed amendment would change.

    And for those wondering how to get involved, Thomas offers a practical starting point: look for opportunities to serve people in your own community, even if you can only spare an hour a month.

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    --

    0:06 — Is Virginia Ready for This Fight?

    1:22 — Why Are People Just Hearing About It?

    2:16 — Did Pro-Lifers Wait Too Long?

    3:26 — How the Amendment Is Being Sold

    4:57 — Abortion Is Already Legal. So What Changes?

    6:05 — Do Virginians Know the Current Law?

    7:03 — Why Should Pro-Life Voters Show Up?

    9:44 — Do College Students Know This Is Happening?

    11:52 — The 25-Minute Conversation That Changed the Tone

    12:34 — What Changes When You Center the Victim?

    13:49 — Can Graphic Images Still Break Through?

    16:47 — The Woman or the Baby?

    19:08 — What Can Unite Pro-Lifers?

    22:14 — You Don’t Need the Same Message

    23:26 — A Coalition Across Beliefs

    24:27 — How Thomas Hill Became Pro-Life

    25:19 — The Face He Couldn’t Forget

    26:25 — When Abortion Stopped Being Abstract

    28:30 — Start Small

    30:20 — One Hour a Month

    31:26 — It’s Not About Our Comfort

    32:13 — Where to Learn More

    35 min
  • Why Are Pro-Life Democrats Being Pushed Out?

    Change your position on abortion if you want to win. That’s the pressure Kristen Day says pro-life candidates face inside the Democratic Party.

    The Democrats for Life leader joins Scott and Marcie to discuss candidates advised to publicly support abortion, the difficulty of finding campaign support, and a local party chair removed from her position after others learned she was pro-life.

    What happens to a party’s promise of inclusion when defending unborn children gets you pushed out?

    Kristen also challenges lawmakers to see the work of pregnancy centers firsthand. She recounts roughly 18 rounds of emails with Congressman Josh Gottheimer’s staff, asking him to take “those ten steps inside” a center he had stood outside opposing.

    She says he has refused so far.

    Meanwhile, Democrats for Life is putting support for mothers and babies into action: delivering 60,000 diapers and wipes around Chicago during the Democratic Convention and another 40,000 diapers in Virginia.

    As Kristen asks: If the party supports “choice,” why isn’t it doing more to help women choose life?

    The conversation explores Planned Parenthood’s influence within the party, opportunities to support mothers and families through legislation, and state lawmakers continuing to defend unborn children despite opposition from their own party.

    It also confronts the difficult question Scott raises at the ballot box: How do you vote when the candidate who shares your other priorities supports abortion?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    28 min
  • If We Can Treat Babies in the Womb, When Do Their Rights Begin?

    When Dr. William Lile has a pregnant patient, he says he doesn’t have one patient; he has two: the mother and her baby. And modern medicine is increasingly treating them that way.

    Doctors can perform open-heart surgery before birth. Repair spina bifida. Correct dangerous heart rhythms. Perform blood transfusions. Even operate on babies inside the womb and allow them to continue developing until birth.

    So Dr. Lile asks a much harder question: if we can diagnose, anesthetize, operate on, and heal a baby before birth, when do that baby’s rights begin?

    That question drives a wide-ranging conversation about fetal medicine, abortion, and the changing meaning of viability. Dr. Lile explains how medical advances have pushed the boundaries of what doctors can do before birth and why he sees a profound contradiction between treating a baby as a patient in one room and ending that baby’s life in another.

    He also discusses what physicians learn in complex family planning fellowships, including late-term abortion and selective reduction; the growing use of the abortion pill; cases in which women have been given abortion drugs without their knowledge; and his work with abortion pill reversal.

    And for Dr. Lile, the conversation ultimately goes beyond medicine. He explains why he believes the church must be equipped to speak about abortion while also offering healing and forgiveness to women and men carrying abortion in their past.

    If medicine already recognizes the baby as a patient, what should follow from that?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    —

    0:20 — Why He Fights for Life

    1:19 — When One Patient Becomes Two

    3:11 — Botox in the Womb

    6:09 — Open Heart Surgery Before Birth

    7:19 — When Twins Compete for a Placenta

    10:30 — Correcting a Baby’s Heart Rhythm

    12:35 — Stopping a Baby’s Heart to Save It

    13:00 — Repairing Spina Bifida Before Birth

    15:00 — Why Are We Still Debating Late-Term Abortion?

    16:36 — Medical Assistance in Dying

    20:05 — What Scripture Calls the Preborn

    22:47 — Is Your Worldview Set by 13?

    24:06 — Showing Ultrasounds to Third Graders

    25:40 — Is Abortion a Sin?

    26:30 — Three Pastors Out of 120

    27:56 — What Happens When an OB-GYN Speaks Out?

    29:14 — What Complex Family Planning Teaches

    31:28 — Does Viability Mean Anything Anymore?

    33:31 — 87 Days Between Identical Twins

    35:16 — Abortion Pills: All They’ve Ever Known

    36:28 — The Father Who Gave Her the Abortion Pill

    37:38 — Nearly 1,000 Clinicians Trained in Reversal

    39:59 — The $109 Reversal Prescription

    42:35 — Judges 3 and the Cost of Sacrifice

    43:59 — 64 Million Since 1973

    44:34 — Who Is Sitting in the Pews

    47 min
  • What Happens When Abortion Grief Stays Buried for Decades?

    What if abortion grief does not surface until years later?

    Matt Freeman of Rachel’s Vineyard joins Scott and Marcie to talk about abortion healing and the buried, unresolved emotions that can remain long after abortion.

    Most people do not come to a retreat for four or five years. Some wait decades. The longest gap Matt has seen?

    51 years.

    What can stay hidden for that long? And what finally forces it into the open?

    The conversation turns to raw grief, anger, self-medication, and long-carried pain that people may live with for years without ever connecting the dots.

    Then there are the men.

    The father who felt powerless. The partner who went along with it. The one who pressured her toward it.

    What are they carrying when they finally walk into a retreat?

    Matt also explains why some people may come too soon, how men grieving alongside women can change the room, and why the physical aftermath of the abortion pill can become part of the trauma itself.

    And then comes one of the most intimate and profound parts of the weekend.

    Each person is invited to give their child a name. For many, it is also the first time they have ever told their abortion story out loud.

    Why name the baby? And what happens when years of silence finally break?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    --

    2:52 — Who Comes to Rachel's Vineyard?

    3:49 — 51 Years Later

    4:14 — When the Pain Finally Connects

    5:58 — The Trauma Beneath the Abortion

    7:46 — What About the Men?

    10:56 — When Couples Don't Stay Together

    12:08 — Did This Happen to Me, or Did I Do This?

    13:28 — The Three Kinds of Men Who Come

    15:06 — What Happens at a Retreat?

    15:18 — The Stone

    17:27 — Understanding the Context

    19:17 — What Can We Handle Right Now?

    20:18 — Is the Abortion Pill Trauma Different?

    22:13 — When the Bleeding Becomes Part of the Memory

    23:02 — What Does Bottoming Out Look Like?

    25:06 — When You Never Connected the Dots

    26:34 — How Do You Suggest Healing Without Pushing?

    27:39 — When Help Feels Like Judgment

    28:50 — Why They Name Their Children

    31:50 — The Bond a Name Can Create

    32:19 — Rachel's Vineyard Around the World

    33:00 — How Rachel's Vineyard Began

    34:49 — Why Some People Travel Far From Home

    35:21 — Is This Retreat for Me?

    37:35 — The First Time They Tell the Story

    38:20 — Heard, Loved, and Not Judged

    40 min
  • Is Social Media Teaching Us to Empathize With the Wrong Person?

    What happens when empathy starts protecting the person who caused the harm?

    Marcie and Scott confront two stories where sympathy for the adult threatens to overshadow the child at the center.

    While following the Lindsay Clancy case, Marcie realized something unsettling: she knew Clancy’s name. She could not name her three children. That absence matters.

    The conversation explores toxic empathy, legal responsibility, and the idea of the “second victim.” At what point does understanding someone’s suffering begin to obscure accountability?

    Then there is Baby Gabriel. Born through surrogacy with a serious heart condition, Gabriel survived after his surrogate resisted the biological parents’ reported request to end the pregnancy. He has since been returned to their custody by court order, raising difficult questions about surrogacy, disability, parental rights, and what happens when the child adults planned for is not the child they receive.

    In both stories, attention gravitates toward the adults, their pain, their intentions, their rights, while the children live with the consequences.

    How far can empathy bend before it starts excusing the inexcusable?

    Watch the full conversation on Dear Jane.

    --

    0:19 — 25 Years Since 9/11, 1 Since Charlie Kirk

    2:12 — The Lindsay Clancy Case

    3:02 — Why Are Women Rallying Around Her?

    3:33 — Toxic Empathy

    4:01 — Justice Wears a Blindfold

    6:12 — Who Has to Say This Is Wrong?

    6:58 — The Law Was Violated. Then What?

    7:58 — “This Sets Us Back as Women”

    8:56 — “This Could Be Me”

    9:40 — The Second Victim Narrative

    10:24 — What Precedent Does This Set?

    11:11 — The Copycat Case

    12:06 — When Empathy Lands on the Wrong Person

    12:40 — Baby Gabriel

    13:44 — Better for This Child to Be Dead?

    14:35 — Nobody Is Talking About the Baby

    15:09 — What the Survival Numbers Show

    16:23 — Post-Birth Abortion

    17:17 — When the Designer Baby Doesn’t Match

    18:03 — Why So Few People Hear About This

    18:45 — How Far Does the Slippery Slope Go?

    20:08 — Voting With Your Eyes Open

    22:35 — When Pro-Life Friends Struggle With This

    23:00 — You Might Be the Only Pushback

    23:42 — Carpet Cleaning and Riding Mowers

    27 min

About Dear Jane

From the publisher's feed

This podcast brings together pro-life leaders and individuals of all stripes to have meaningful conversations about the issue of life. How do we tackle the massive injustice of abortion while…