Dear Watchers: an omniversal comic book podcast

🎙️ What If We Opened a Portal to New York Comic Con 2025 to Reveal Our Highlights?

NYCC is our annual pilgrimage through fandom—and this year we opened a portal to relive it all! From retro creators and cosplay encounters to surprise Marvel reveals and new comic treasures, we’re sharing the sights, sounds, and stories that made 2025’s con unforgettable.

Ep. 170 What If We Opened a Portal to New York Comic Con 2025 to Reveal Our Highlights?

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

We just got back from New York Comic Con 2025, and instead of our usual multiverse deep-dive, we’re giving you a guided tour of our con experience—through our three classic segments: Origins of the Story, Exploring Multiversity, and Pondering Possibilities. We chat about tradition, community, legendary creators like Bob Wiacek, fan-favorite artists like Russell Dauterman, and what Marvel’s latest shows (Daredevil: Born Again, Wonder Man, Vision Quest) tell us about the MCU’s future.

From sentimental traditions and crowd energy to exclusive merch and unforgettable encounters—this episode is both a recap and a celebration of the con that feels like home.

Email: [email protected]

Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️ Two Publishers, Both Alike in Dignity…

What if DC and Marvel were one shared multiverse? We’re diving into the biggest crossover in years to explore the ultimate fan fiction gone corporate canon.

Ep. 169 Deadpool Batman #1: What If Marvel & DC Were the Same Company?

from Deadpool Batman #1 (Marvel/DC, 2025)

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

They said it couldn’t be done… but they did it anyway! We're diving into Deadpool Batman #1, the first co-published Marvel/DC crossover in decades. From Deadpool in Gotham to Wonder Woman and Cap co-founding a shared past, we explore this jam-packed issue filled with seven stories by top creators like Zeb Wells, Frank Miller, Chip Zdarsky, Kelly Thompson, Kevin Smith, Al Ewing, and Ryan North.

We begin with the long history of intercompany collaborations (and our past coverage on them), then break down each vignette from this new shared Earth—including Rocket Raccoon with a Green Lantern ring, a silent Jeff & Krypto tale, and Old Man Logan vs. Dark Knight Returns. We finish with a massive surprise tease of the original Amalgam Universe returning (Logo! Thanoside! Super Soldier!).

Is this a one-off event? Or the beginning of a new omniversal era? Either way, we’re pondering possibilities from across both comic book cosmoses.

Reading / Watch List:

• Deadpool Batman #1 (Marvel/DC, 2025)
• Captain America Wonder Woman: The Gun and the Sword by Chip Zdarsky & Terry Dodson
• Old Man Logan & Batman: Showdown by Frank Miller
• Logo: Enter Logo by Ryan North & Ryan Stegman
• Deadpool Batman: The Dead of Night by Zeb Wells & Greg Capullo
• Daredevil Green Arrow: The Red and the Green by Kevin Smith & Adam Kubert
• Rocket Raccoon Green Lantern by Al Ewing & Dike Ruan
• Jeff & Krypto: Catch by Kelly Thompson & Gurihiru

Email: [email protected]

Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️ Groovy? Dreamy? Slashy? Let’s get ready to SCREAM!

What happens when three horror icons collide in the multiverse—and who’s left standing when the blood dries?

Ep. 168 What if Jason (Friday the 13th) fought Freddy (Nightmare on Elm Street) and Ash (Evil Dead)?

from Freddy vs. Jason vs. Ash #1-6 (Wildstorm/Dynamite, 2007–2008)

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

We’re diving into the ultimate horror crossover multiverse! We begin with the legendary slasher and supernatural legacies of Jason Voorhees, Freddy Krueger, and Ash Williams—from Friday the 13th, Nightmare on Elm Street, and Evil Dead respectively—before turning to the blood-soaked comics of Freddy vs. Jason vs. Ash and its chaotic sequel The Nightmare Warriors. Along the way we explore the intersection of fan service, horror mythmaking, and multiversal mash-ups, then wrap with speculation on whether this horror trifecta deserves a cinematic rematch—or maybe an even bigger monster multiverse.

Reading / Watch List:

• Freddy vs. Jason vs. Ash #1-6 (Wildstorm/Dynamite, 2007)
• Freddy vs. Jason vs. Ash: The Nightmare Warriors #1-6 (Wildstorm/Dynamite, 2009)
• Freddy vs. Jason (New Line Cinema, 2003)
• Friday the 13th (Paramount, 1980) – and sequels
• A Nightmare on Elm Street (New Line Cinema, 1984) – and sequels
• The Evil Dead (Renaissance Pictures, 1981) – and sequels including Army of Darkness, Ash vs Evil Dead, etc.

Email: [email protected]

Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️ Gods of the Omniverse? It’s Our 4-Year Anniversary!

from Dear Watchers Episode 167

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Happy (slightly belated) birthday to us! Dear Watchers just turned 4 years old, and we’re celebrating with you. We look back at our origins (dating back to July 2021), share wild trivia about our journey (170+ episodes, 6,859 minutes of runtime, 25 unique guests, and five straight days of bingeable Watchers content!), and reminisce about our favorite arcs like Age of Apocalypse.

Then, since we’re the “gods of the Omniverse” for this minisode, we invent our own Elseworlds/What Ifs! Rob pitches Spider-Man as a 1950s black-and-white horror monster, Elvira solving murders in Gotham with Batman, and the Joker hosting a late-night talk show. Guido imagines the Muppets as Mutants at Xavier’s School, Elvira traveling to Etheria to meet She-Ra, and the X-Men cast in a soap opera (or Twin Peaks). We debate, laugh, and pick our favorites—like a true anniversary mashup.

Reading / Watch List:

(No homework this week — these universes don’t exist yet!)

• Instead, check out our earlier anniversary specials:
  • Ep. 54 – One-Year Birthday Trivia Party
  • Ep. 100 – Watchers’ Favorite What Ifs
  • Ep. 150 – Another Big Retrospective

Email: [email protected]

Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️ Wonder Woman Meets She-Ra Meets Barbie?!

Grab a box of Cinnamon Mini Buns from 1993, comb your long luxurious hair, and polish your gemstones—because today we’re traveling to the most glittery corner of the multiverse.

Ep. 166 What if Wonder Woman Led the Star Riders?

from Wonder Woman and the Star Riders (Mattel/DC Promotional Minicomics, 1993)

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

What if Wonder Woman was crossed with She-Ra and Barbie to lead the Star Riders, a team of sparkling superheroines? We’re diving into this dazzling “lost” alternate universe born from a 1993 DC/Mattel collaboration. We begin with Tom King & Guillem March’s Wonder Woman #20–21 (2025) before turning to the unreleased Wonder Woman and the Star Riders toys, catalog comics, and animated special. Along the way, we explore the bizarre and mysterious history of this canceled line—from prototypes to SDCC screenings—and wrap by pondering whether this glitter-powered Elseworld should return.

Reading / Watch List:

• Wonder Woman #20–21 (DC Comics, 2025) — Writer: Tom King; Artist: Guillem March
• Wonder Woman and the Star Riders Promotional Comics (Mattel/DC, 1993) — Art: José Luis García-López
• Wonder Woman and the Star Riders vs. Purrsia Minicomic (Mattel/DC, 1993)

Email: [email protected]
Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️ Had a challenging week? Get ready for something fantastic. We’re going Amalgam, baby! This week, Marvel’s First Family meets DC’s death-defying adventurers in one of the boldest mash-ups of the Amalgam Age!

Ep. 165 What if the Fantastic Four returned from their travels without powers—and had to face Galactiac?

from Challengers of the Fantastic #1 (Amalgam Comics, June 1997) & Showcase #6 (DC Comics, February 1957)

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

This week, we dive into the Amalgam Universe—Earth 9602—where Reed Richards, Sue Storm, Ben Grimm, and Johnny Storm collide with the worlds of Ace Morgan, Red Ryan, June Robbins, and Professor Haley to become the Challengers of the Fantastic! We begin our journey with the Silver Age debut of DC Comics’ Challengers of the Unknown in Showcase #6, created (or co-created) by Jack Kirby, and trace the team's wild legacy through the decades—including Nazi-busting villains, zombie plagues, and their bizarre Weirdoverse revival in the 1990s.

Then we venture to Challengers of the Fantastic #1 by Karl Kesel and Tom Grummett, part of 1997’s second wave of Amalgam Comics, where the Fantastic Four return from cosmic exploration without powers and confront Galactiac—an epic fusion of Galactus and Brainiac. Alongside returning guest Ethan (aka @MakeMineAmalgam), we explore what makes this world work, how Kesel balances reverence with absurdity, and why this short-lived title deserves more love.

Plus: obscure villains like Multi-Man and Mr. Tic-Tac-Toe, the evolution of Jack Kirby’s themes across Marvel and DC, and a round of actor amalgamation speculation. Is this the first spark of a new Amalgam universe revival? And just what makes the Amalgam Universe such a rich multiversal playground?

Reading / Watch List:

• Showcase #6 (DC Comics, 1957) – “The Secret of the Sorcerer's Box!”
• Spider-Boy #1 (Amalgam / Marvel & DC Comics, 1996)
• Challengers of the Fantastic #1 (Amalgam Comics, 1997)

Email: [email protected]
Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎙️They don't want to destroy the universe—they want to annoy it into submission!

It's comics' most chaotic crossover as the pink-hatted pest and the green chaos goblin take center stage!

Ep. 164 What If Superman and Silver Surfer Tangled with Impossible Man and Mr. Mxyzptlk?

from Silver Surfer / Superman #1 (Marvel & DC, 1997)

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

We’re diving into the most mischievous multiversal mayhem! We begin with the golden age debut of DC’s Mr. Mxyzptlk and Marvel’s Impossible Man’s first Fantastic appearance, then head into the wild 1997 crossover where the two Imps trade universes—and trouble—for Superman and Silver Surfer. Along the way we explore the legacy of comic pranksters, George Pérez’s Marvel/DC legacy, and the lineage of transdimensional trickery. We wrap with speculation about 2025’s upcoming Marvel/DC crossover and ask: are Imps the ultimate fourth-wall breakers?

Reading / Watch List:

• Superman (Vol. 1) #30 (DC Comics, 1944) – “The Mysterious Mr. Mxyztplk!” by Jerry Siegel & Ira Yarbrough
• Fantastic Four #11 (Marvel Comics, 1963) – “The Impossible Man!” by Stan Lee & Jack Kirby
• Silver Surfer / Superman #1 (Marvel & DC Comics, 1997) – by George Pérez, Ron Lim, Terry Austin

Email: [email protected]
Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

We are traveling to Earth-383, a so-called Negative Earth first featured in Adventure Comics #383 (1969), where Supergirl seemingly perishes in an explosion and attends her own funeral—joined by the spirits of Abraham Lincoln, Joan of Arc, and other ghostly figures! This Bronze Age tale was recently revisited in Back Issue #159 as part of a 40th anniversary retrospective on Crisis on Infinite Earths.

Episode #163: What if Supergirl was dead and able to be amongst other dead people like Joan of Arc and Abraham Lincoln?
from DC Comics Adventure Comics #383

Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

We’re diving into the ethereal and existential! We begin with Supergirl’s strange funeral in the Silver Age story Please Stop My Funeral! before rewinding to the surprising proto-Supergirl tales from the ‘40s and ‘50s. Then we haunt the haunted halls of Kara Zor-El’s multiversal history and her celestial cinematic debut in the 1984 Supergirl movie. Along the way, we explore ghost stories, alternate deaths, and historical cameos in the DC Universe—then wrap with a look at how these odd tales ponder Supergirl's mythic potential.

Reading / Watch List:

• Action Comics #252 (DC Comics, 1959) – Debut of Supergirl by Otto Binder & Al Plastino
• Adventure Comics #383 (DC Comics, 1969) – “Please Stop My Funeral!” by Robert Kanigher & Win Mortimer
• Supergirl: The Official Movie Adaptation (DC Comics, 1985) – Based on the 1984 film
• Supergirl (film) (Tri-Star Pictures, 1984) – Directed by Jeannot Szwarc, starring Helen Slater

Email: [email protected]
Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

★ Support this podcast ★

🎶 Boop-Oop-a-Doop! 🎶
This week we’re tapping our toes, flipping our curls, and leaping out of the inkpot as we explore one of animation’s original divas—Betty Boop!

We’re asking:
What if Betty Boop traveled from the cartoon world to our world?

For the first time, Dear Watchers is hopping from the silver screen to the comic page to the Broadway stage as we visit Earth-Boop-Oop-a-Doop and explore:

📽 Betty Boop Cartoon Shorts (1930–1939)
The surreal, saucy, and sometimes censored origins of Betty Boop, born from the minds of Max Fleischer and Grim Natwick, where jazz met animation in a flapper’s frame.

🎭 Boop! The Musical (Broadway, 2025)
Betty breaks out of her monochrome world in a brand-new Broadway musical, with a book by Bob Martin (The Drowsy Chaperone) and music by Grammy legend David Foster. Can a cartoon star find love—and herself—in modern-day Manhattan?

📘 Betty Boop #1–4 (Dynamite Comics, 2016)
In this charming and spooky revival by Roger Langridge and Gisèle Lagacé, Betty sings at the Oop-A-Doop Club, battles ghosts, and protects her soul from devilish villains—all while staying true to her plucky, positive spirit.

💬 Along the way, we ask:

• Can Betty Boop’s vintage vaudeville energy still resonate in today’s world?
• What does it mean for a character to cross from animated past to physical present?
• And who knew interdimensional travel could be so jazzy?

🌀 From flapper cartoons to musical showstoppers to comic book capers, this episode is your backstage pass to the multiversal spotlight of one of pop culture’s most enduring icons.

Reading / Watch List:
🎬 Betty Boop Theatrical Shorts (1930–1939, Fleischer Studios)
🎭 Boop! The Musical (Broadway, 2025)
📚 Betty Boop #1–4 (Dynamite Comics, 2016)

Email: [email protected]
Find us & support us at: https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)

🌎 Earth! 🔥 Fire! 💧 Water! 🌪 Wind! 🪵 Heart! With our powers combined, we're calling forth the return of the ultimate eco-hero: Captain Planet! For the first time in Dear Watchers history, we’re diving into a beloved ‘90s animated icon who’s been absent from the comic page for three decades.

This week, we're going full Planeteer as we explore:

• 💬 "Captain Planet and the Planeteers" #1–12 (Marvel Comics, 1991–1992): A deep look at the surprisingly sophisticated early ‘90s comics based on the cartoon series, filled with villains like Duke Nukem, Hoggish Greedly, and a lot of eco-anxiety.
• 📘 "Captain Planet and the Planeteers" #1 (Dynamite Comics, April 2025): A first look at the brand-newrevival by David Pepose, Eman Casallos, and the creative team tasked with modernizing a green-haired icon for a new generation.

Ep. 161 What if our powers combined to create the mega mac-daddy of ecology, Captain Planet, and we try to resurrect him for the first time in 30 years?

from Captain Planet and the Planeteers #1 (Marvel Comics, 1991)
Find us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

💚 Along the way, we ask:

• Can a character born of Earth Day idealism thrive in today's climate crisis world?
• How do the Marvel comics compare to the TV show?
• What makes Captain Planet more than just a meme—and maybe a hero worth rebooting?

🌀 From Planeteer powers to Plunder Villains, this episode is your all-access pass to one of pop culture’s most earnest eco-warriors—just in time for his return.

Reading / Watch List:

• Captain Planet and the Planeteers (DIC / Hanna Barbera, 1990 - 1996)
• Captain Planet and the Planeteers #1-12 (Marvel Comics, 1991 - 1992)
• Captain Planet and the Planeteers #1 (Dynamite, 2025)

Email [email protected]
Find us & support us at https://linktr.ee/dearwatchers

Theme music is Space Heroes by MaxKoMusic (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0)