Decoding IP Blog

Decoding IP Blog

By DecodingIPBusinessBusiness News
Download on the App Store

All Decoding IP Blog episodes

  • The Billion Dollar Copyright
    The use of photographs and other digital images on the web can be a tricky business. Copyright owners are increasingly taking steps to police their images by monitoring web content using automated means like web scrapers. Many online content creators have had to learn the hard way about the pitfalls and best practices in the world of copyrighted online content. We’ve previously discussed these issues in other contexts. But a recent headline-making case has brought attention to yet another twist for online copyrights in the form of a billion dollar copyright suit.

    A Public Gift
    Carol Highsmith is a well-known photographer who has traveled all over America on a mission “to produce a nationwide visual study of the United States in the early 21st Century.” Through her non-profit organization devoted to this mission, Ms. Highsmith has donated her works to the Library of Congress, which has called her donation “one of the greatest acts of generosity in the history of the Library.” The Carol M. Highsmith Archive, which is expected to grow to more than 100,000 photographs covering the entirety of the United States, is accessible royalty-free via the Library’s website. The only condition for public access and use of the images is to attribute them to the Library of Congress’ Highsmith archive.
    Meanwhile, stock photo agency Getty Images and other related companies such as Alamy have been selling thousands of Ms. Highsmith’s images to the public for a fee, without ever identifying Ms. Highsmith as the author or informing their customers that the photographs are actually available for free via the Library of Congress. Remarkably, Getty and its affiliates would have been able to continue flying under the radar had they not sent Ms. Highsmith a threatening letter accusing her of copyright infringement for using one of her own photographs on her website and demanding payment of $120!
    The Digital Millennium Copyright Act
    In response to the letter, Ms. Highsmith sued Getty and its related companies for violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), seeking more than $1 billion in damages based on 18,755 separate violations of the DMCA – one violation for each of Ms. Highsmith’s photos on the Getty website. Section 1202 of the DMCA makes it unlawful to distribute a work with false copyright management information, or to remove copyright management information altogether. “Copyright management information” includes work-identifying information such as the title and author of the work, but it also includes terms and conditions for use of the work.
    The lawsuit accuses Getty and the other defendants of violating the DMCA by falsely holding themselves out as the exclusive copyright owner, and falsely claiming that a user must purchase a copyright license from Getty in order to use the Highsmith images. Thus, the lawsuit states, Getty and the other defendants have “misappropriated Ms. Highsmith’s generous gift to the American people.” So far, none of the defendants have filed a formal answer to the initial complaint. In a public statement, however, Getty acknowledged that the images are in the public domain, but still maintains that it has the right to charge a fee for distributing the material.
    Join Jennifer Atkins
    41 min
  • Trademark Lessons From Crazy Horse Strip Clubs
    Better known for juicy tales of mobsters, adult film stars, and general shenanigans, the now-closed Las Vegas strip club “Crazy Horse Too” plays a role in providing important lessons in trademark law. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently put to rest a dispute over the “Crazy Horse” trademark for strip clubs in the United States. The case involved one registration, three refusals, a cancellation proceeding, two contracts, and one lawsuit, collectively illustrating important lessons for trademark owners.

    From the Champs Elysees to the Vegas Strip
    People have used “Crazy Horse” for strip club names in multiple locations across the United States after the original venue famously opened on the Avenue des Champs Elysees in Paris in the 1960s. Yet, somewhat surprisingly, it was not until 2006 that a North Carolina operator registered the trademark in the United States. When club owners in Nevada and Ohio also tried to register the mark, they were denied.
    A cancellation proceeding ensued and was settled with a co-existence agreement between the Las Vegas, Nevada club operator and the North Carolina mark holder, leaving the trademark intact. Later, the North Carolina owner of the mark assigned the mark to the Ohio applicant, who set about licensing the brand throughout the United States. However, the Las Vegas club owner refused to pay license fees and the dispute ended up in court pitting the co-existence agreement against the trademark assignment. The district court held that the co-existence agreement was valid against the assigned trademark and that the Las Vegas owner did not owe any licensing fees. The Ninth Circuit affirmed.
    Join Kandis Koustenis and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the interesting but complex history of the case and the important lessons that can be learned for trademark holders about licensing and co-existence agreements.
    Photo credit: THX0477
    24 min
  • What Does Brexit Mean for European and UK Patents? (Part 2)
    The European Union (EU) is an economic and political partnership involving 28 European countries. It began after World War II, in large part because many Europeans felt that countries which trade and work closely with each other are less likely to go to war and attempt to invade their partner states. Now, the EU is about to lose an important member of this single market, which has allowed products and people to flow freely across national borders for many years. This is because last month, the United Kingdom (UK) held a voter referendum, and the majority of voters (52% to 48%) decided that the UK should leave the EU partnership.
    There has been a lot of discussion regarding the expected fallout from the UK’s historic vote to leave the EU. One area of uncertainly relates to the effect its exit will have on the current European patent system and processes available to protect technology in the UK. In this blog post and podcast episode, Cloudigy Law’s Jennifer Atkins and Antigone Peyton go over presently available European and UK patent protection options and the highly anticipated Unitary Patent System, as well as what effect Brexit might have upon them.

    The European Patent System
    Currently, companies seeking UK patent protection can use the European Patent Convention (EPC) option. This patent process allows a company to file a single European Patent Application with the European Patent Office (EPO). The EPO will examine the application, and if the technology is found to be patentable, then a European Patent will be granted.
    The EPO patent must then be validated in any country (such as the UK) that is a signatory to the EPC for the patent to be enforceable in that country. Validation involves a variety of requirements which differ from country to country. For some, a translation to one of the approved languages (such as French, Spanish, etc.) and payment of a national stage acceptance fee is required, among other things. Then there are the maintenance fees for keeping a patent alive in each country once it has been granted. Parts of this process are very expensive and cumbersome for patent owners, which is why the new Unitary Patent option described below is seen as an attractive alternative.
    The European Patent is independent of the EU. The UK is a member of the European Patent Convention and Brexit does not affect its membership in this convention. As such, Brexit will not change the current European Patent system or the ability to use the EPO as the central filing and examination clearing center for a patent that is ultimately secured in the UK (after the national stage fee is paid).
    United Kingdom Patent Applications
    An applicant can also file a patent application directly with the UK’s Intellectual Property Office (IPO). The IPO will examine a UK patent application, and if they agree that its subject matter is patentable, then a UK patent will be issued. This is the option that companies usually pursue when they wish to file for patent protection in only one or a few EU countries. Generally, the UK examination process is faster than the EPO examination process, which is then followed by a national stage filing in the UK. Again, as is the case with the current European Patent system and EPO, Brexit will not affect patents that were obtained directly through the UK’s IPO.
    Moreover, the UK is also a signatory to the independent Paris Convention Treaty (PCT), which provides important intellectual property rights and protections to all member countries. For instance, a patent application filed in one member country is entitled to the filing date benefits of a corresponding patent application previously filed in another member country, as long as the two applications are not filed more than 12 months apart. Currently, the Paris Convention Treaty has 176 member countries, including the United States. Patent applications filed with the UK’s IPO receive the PCT filing date ben...
    26 min
  • Converse Case Proves Secondary Meaning Requirements Are Getting Tougher
    A couple of months ago we spoke about copyright protection for clothing designs. Now it’s time to talk about shoes and trademarks. Converse, the maker of the ubiquitous Chuck Taylor All Star sneakers, filed lawsuits against thirty shoe manufacturers, importers, and retailers over the last two years alleging trademark infringement of its shoe design. Converse sought a general exclusion order from the International Trade Commission preventing the importation of any shoe with its design elements. These are protected by three separate trademarks, two of which relate to patterns on the sole of the shoe and one concerning the toecap and mid-sole design.

    Recent ITC Ruling
    This past July, the International Trade Commission surprisingly ruled that one of Converse’s trademark registrations was invalid. According to the ITC, the covered elements, a toecap and stripes on the mid-sole, did not meet the requisite secondary meaning under trademark law. While the ITC held that Converse does have valid trademarks in the designs on the sole of the shoes, that ruling likely gives little solace to Converse.
    The Converse case – which no doubt will be appealed to the Federal Circuit – highlights yet again the difficulties fashion designers and manufacturers face in seeking to protect their intellectual property.
    Join Kandis Koustenis and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the Converse case, the requirements of secondary meaning, and the various tools available for protecting fashion designs.
    Photo credit: Paleontour
    18 min
  • The Defend Trade Secrets Act: New Federal Law, New Litigation Options
    On May 11, 2016, President Obama enacted a new federal trade secret protection law known as the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (DTSA). The DTSA makes federal protection against the misappropriation of trade secrets available to private parties. Before the DTSA, private parties who sought to protect their trade secrets from misappropriation were limited to bringing claims under state law. With the enactment of the DTSA, trade secret protections are no longer limited to individual state jurisdictions as U.S. federal law reaches across all states.

    Previous Cloudigy blog posts and podcast episodes focused on the DTSA’s practical business implications—including important changes to contracts, policies, and procedures dealing with trade secrets and other confidential information. The DTSA also provides important new litigation tools to trade secret owners. Antigone Peyton outlines these litigation options in detail in part two of her blog post series on the new Act. Join Antigone Peyton and Kandis Koustenis in today’s podcast as they continue to explore these new litigation options.
    In addition to providing the ability to bring forth claims directly to federal courts, the new federal protections offered under the DTSA provides trade secret owners with important new litigation options, including:
    Broad Protection for Trade Secrets
    The new federal law seemingly expands the definition of trade secrets in comparison to the various states’ trade secret laws. Most state laws describe a limited list of specific categories or types of information that can qualify as a trade secret. However, under the DTSA, nearly any type of information (including “all forms and types of financial, business, scientific, technical, economic, or engineering information”) may qualify as a trade secret under the DTSA, provided it is kept secret and the owner has taken reasonable steps to maintain its secrecy.
    New “Secret” Trade Secret Seizure Orders
    The DTSA also includes a powerful remedy for violation of another party’s trade secret rights that is currently unavailable under any state trade secret laws. Under the DTSA, a company that has experienced trade secret theft can now file a request with the courts to seize the trade secret without having to notify the party being accused of theft. Nonetheless, it is important to note that this type of ex parte seizure procedure is to be used only under extraordinary circumstances.
    Trade secret owners seeking to take advantage of this seizure remedy must meet strict evidentiary requirements. The party requesting seizure must show, for example: (i) that the alleged trade secret thief “would destroy, move, hide, or otherwise make such matter inaccessible to the court” if the trade secret owner were to provide notice to the alleged thief; (ii) a detailed description of the particular property to be seized; and (iii) that other less drastic remedies, such as a preliminary injunction, are inadequate. Thus, companies seeking to utilize the seizure process will need to undertake detailed factual investigations and be prepared to furnish evidence that satisfies the abovementioned requirements before filing a seizure request.
    Join Antigone Peyton and
    34 min
  • Music & Politics Don’t Mix – Or Do They?
    It’s political convention time once again and that means more intellectual property drama! This political season has already given us trademark disputes involving cease and desist letters and living person name registrations. Now we have copyright issues – specifically, music copyright issues. Politicians and political parties often choose popular music as the background for their conventions. Convention organizers and ad makers use music to convey a certain tone or underscore a particular message.

    Artist Complaints
    And with their use of that music comes complaints from artists who are concerned about the unauthorized use or implied association of the artist with a political message. This campaign cycle is no different than any other, with artists complaining about the use of their music. More often than not, those complaints are simply based on the fact that the artist does not want to be associated with a given politician or political party through the use of their music. But sometimes, those complaints are generated because the politician or political party in question did not obtain the appropriate license to use the music in the first place.
    Licenses?
    Music – in both written and recorded form – is subject to copyright protection. To use music in a public performance or in an advertisement, one must obtain a license to do so. In addition to complaints from artists, this campaign cycle already gave rise to at least one copyright infringement lawsuit – a case against the Ted Cruz campaign for using music in a political ad where the terms of the license expressly excluded its use in political advertisements. But even in instances where licenses have been properly obtained, politicians may decide against the use of a particular song in the face of mounting artist complaints, especially when those complaints are set to music created on a popular late night comedy show.
    Join Antigone Peyton and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the music copyright issues raised by the 2016 campaign and the ways politicians can avoid the public controversies and artists can exert more control over the use of their music.
    Photo credit: Nan Palermo
    28 min
  • Brexit Intellectual Property Issues (Part 1)
    On June 23, 2016, in a referendum dubbed “Brexit” voters in the United Kingdom (UK) opted to leave the European Union (EU), sending economic and political shockwaves around the globe. Obviously, the actual Brexit process will not be taking place immediately. The UK must first formally notify the EU of its intention to leave the Union in order to begin a two-year negotiation period for ratifying the terms of the UK’s withdrawal.
    After the vote, a number of enterprising souls sought to trademark the term “Brexit” for a variety of goods and services. But where should they seek trademark registration? The very thing they seek to trademark may have significant impacts on intellectual property rights in both the EU and the UK, including patents, industrial designs, and trademarks. Although the precise details of the impact of Brexit on intellectual property rights won’t fully be known until exit negotiations are complete, trademark owners should consider and prepare for the potential effects.

    Effect of Brexit on EU and UK Trademarks
    One of the benefits of the EU system is a member-wide trademark registration known as an EU trademark (until recently, known as a community trademark or CTM) providing rights in all member states. Before the EU trademark system, trademark rights were protected only on an individual country basis with so-called “national” registrations. The EU trademark system exists as a complement to the national registration regime; it did not replace the national registrations. Unsurprisingly, however, brand owners across the globe have taken advantage of this ability to protect the entire EU with just a single trademark application.
    Once the UK is officially no longer a member of the EU, any existing EU registrations will no longer extend protection to the UK, unless the parties agree otherwise. As such, brand owners could be left without trademark protection in the UK if they do not own corresponding UK national registrations. While it is likely that the UK will seek to implement procedures to convert existing EU trademarks to UK national registrations without loss of priority, trademark owners should be prepared for the potential loss of protection in the UK. Conversely, if a EU registration is solely based upon the use of the mark in the UK, that registration will be subject to cancellation.

    Effect of Brexit on Intellectual Property Agreements
    Due to the effect on trademarks, any agreements involving trademark rights in the EU and UK are potentially impacted. Any existing or new license agreements that include the EU or UK should be reviewed for possible Brexit implications. For example, does the agreement define the EU as it existed at a certain point in time, or as constituted occasionally? Amendments may be necessary to ensure UK coverage.
    Join Jennifer Atkins and Kandis Koustenis as they discuss steps businesses can take now to prepare for the UK’s eventual exit, including trademark audits and systematic contract reviews.
    Photo credit: Jeff Djevdet
     
     
    21 min
  • Does Your Business Comply with the New Federal Trade Secret Law?
    Understanding the New Federal Trade Secret Law
    On May 11, 2016, President Obama enacted a new federal trade secret protection law as part of an update to the Economic Espionage Act of 1996 (EEA). The new trade secret law, known as the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (DTSA), makes federal protection against the misappropriation of trade secrets available to private parties. (Previously, the EEA considered trade secret theft solely as a federal crime.)
    Before the DTSA, private parties who sought to protect their trade secrets from misappropriation were limited to bringing forth a claim under state law. And, although most states have trade secret protection laws, those state laws vary. Added to the sometimes difficult question of which state’s law to apply, this often caused a lack of uniformity and predictability to trade secret protection. The new DTSA does not preempt state trade secret laws, but adds additional protection for trade secrets under federal law. Plaintiffs seeking to remedy trade secret theft will now have the option to proceed under state law, federal law, or both.

    The DTSA not only provides the right to sue directly in federal court, but also, expands the definition of trade secrets, adds new remedies, and includes express “whistleblower” protections. All companies dealing with sensitive competitive information will be affected by this new law. But it is the whistleblower protections that present the most immediate and practical impact for companies.
    This blog post and accompanying podcast (the first of a two-part series) focuses on the practical steps companies should start taking in order to benefit from the full protections of this new law.
    New Protection for Whistleblowers
    The DTSA gives immunity to employees, independent contractors and consultants who disclose trade secrets, in confidence, to government officials for the purpose of reporting violations of the law. And employers are now required to give notice of this immunity in any contract or agreement that governs the use of a trade secret or other confidential information.
    If an employer fails to include this immunity notice, it may not recover exemplary (punitive) damages or attorneys’ fees in any lawsuit it might bring against an employee for improper disclosure of trade secrets.
    To meet this notice requirement, employers can provide the notice in the contract or agreement, or provide a cross-reference to a policy document. It is therefore important for employers to review any of their contracts and policies that deal with the use or disclosure of trade secrets – such as non-disclosure agreements, employment contracts, employee handbooks, consulting contracts, independent contractor agreements, and collaboration and joint venture agreements – to make sure they contain the required whistleblower notice.
    Join Antigone Peyton and Kandis Koustenis as they discuss these and other practical steps business owners should start taking in order to comply with and enjoy the full protections of this new federal trade secret law
    Photo credit: Steven Depolo
    31 min
  • Making the Trump Name Drumpf Again?
    The 2016 presidential contest once again pushed trademark law into the news. A few weeks ago, it was the Democrats. Now it’s the Republicans. Well, sort of.



    John Oliver’s late-night show aired a segment critical of Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump. In the segment, Oliver pointed out that the Trump family name was originally “Drumpf” and launched a campaign to “make Donald Drumpf again.” A few days before the segment aired, Drumpf Industries, LLC – a company created by Oliver – applied for a trademark on “Drumpf”.
    The Trademark Office recently issued an office action rejecting the “Drumpf” application based on the section of the Trademark Act that prohibits the registration as a trademark of a name of a living person without their consent. But does that section of the Act apply here where the name in question is not a name actually being used by the living person? Drumpf Industries can still respond to the office action to support the application. What will they say?
    Join Antigone Peyton and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss contours of the case and the broader implications of the application of the “living person” prohibition.
    Photo credit: Alex Hanson
    28 min
  • Oracle’s APIs are Copyrighted, But Jury Decides Google’s Android Software Use is “Fair”
    Many software companies, developers, and legal eagles have been watching Oracle’s and Google’s face-off over the question of whether Google’s Android software infringes a copyright Oracle acquired through its purchase of Sun Microsystems. After 6 years of legal wrangling, a jury recently found that Google’s Android system does not infringe Oracle’s copyright in Java code because its use of certain portions of that code is “fair use.” This means that the jury did not have to consider Oracle’s claim that Google owed it $9 billion in damages for copying portions of Java that are application programming interfaces (APIs), without taking a license.



    As this case wound through the courts, we’ve kept you up to date on some significant legal and practical issues the parties raised. For instance, the question of whether application programming interfaces (APIs) should be copyrightable at all has been a hotly debated topic throughout this case. In the first trial in this case, the district court judge–who taught himself how to program using Java code in order to better understand the technology–ruled that Google had copied portions of Java but that these copied portions were simply APIs and not protected by copyright law. The Federal Circuit, an appeals court, disagreed, and concluded that the “structure, sequence, and organization” of an API is in fact protectable by copyright. The Federal Circuit then returned the case to the trial court to determine whether Google’s copying of Oracle’s Java code was, in fact, an infringement of Oracle’s copyright.
    Another important question the courts and then the jury considered, is: if APIs are copyrightable, can another party use those APIs without a license in the name of “fair use.” In the second trial, which was held last month in San Francisco, a jury found that Google’s use of the API code was protected as “fair use.” Fair use is a determination that the material in question is properly protected by copyright but that an otherwise unauthorized use is nonetheless allowed as a matter of policy to serve the public interest. Oracle has already announced that it will appeal the jury’s decision to the Federal Circuit, in hopes of obtaining another victory in its copyright infringement claim.
    Join Antigone Peyton and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the history of the Oracle v. Google case and the important issues raised by the case, including the interplay between strong copyright protections and the practical impact of this decision on developers and tech companies that use portions of software code.
    Photo credit: Rob Buhlman
    20 min