Decoding IP Blog

Decoding IP Blog

By DecodingIPBusinessBusiness News
Download on the App Store

All Decoding IP Blog episodes

  • Cheerleading Fashions Copyright Clash
    Can you copyright your fashions? In general, clothing designs: i.e., the cut and design of articles of clothing, are not protected by copyright law because the statute expressly excludes protection for “useful articles.” One of the murkiest issues in copyright law is how to determine what transforms a “useful article” otherwise not protected by copyright into something creative that is worthy of copyright protection. The United States Supreme Court will wade into the issue next term in Star Athletica, LLC v. Varsity Brands, Inc.
    Varsity Brands is the world’s largest manufacturer and distributor of cheerleading uniforms. When Star Athletica entered the market with its first catalog of cheerleading uniforms, Varsity sued claiming that Star’s use of chevrons and stripes on its uniforms infringed on Varsity’s copyrights. The district court in Tennessee granted summary judgment in favor of defendant Star, finding that the use of stripes and chevrons on cheerleading uniforms was not conceptually separable from the useful purpose of the uniform. In other words, a cheerleading uniform is not subject to copyright protection because the patterns on the uniform are part of what makes it identifiable as a cheerleading uniform.
    The Sixth Circuit disagreed, finding that the stripes and chevrons could be viewed as separate and copyrightable. Star sought and received a grant of certiorari from the U.S. Supreme Court. The various appellate courts have struggled mightily with determining when something that is otherwise a “useful article” has elements that may be copyrightable, creating a series of tests and standards that are often confusing, inconsistently applied, and somewhat contradictory.
    Join Kandis Koustenis and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the history of copyright in the fashion industry and the issues raised by the case, including the interplay between copyright and design patent protection.
    Photo credit: SD Dirk
    29 min
  • Political Satire Gets ‘Berned’ on IP Laws
    The 2016 Presidential election campaign is in full swing and the world of IP law is not immune from it. But we aren’t talking about policy positions, we’re talking trademark and copyright. Last month, lawyers for the Bernie Sanders campaign sent a cease and desist letter to political satire gear creator Liberty Maniacs claiming that certain t-shirts sold on Liberty Maniacs’ website infringed the trademarks and copyrights of the Sanders campaign.
    Unsurprisingly, the cease and desist letter and the cleverly worded response from Liberty Maniacs went viral and inspired a lot of commentary. So, are political campaign logos protected by copyright and trademark? Was the Sanders campaign right to send the letter that they did? With cease and desist letters and their responses going viral instantly, what can rights holders do to protect their intellectual property without engendering scorn from the public?
    Join Kandis Koustenis and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss trademark and copyright issues relating to political campaigns and the nuances of appropriate trademark and copyright enforcement.
    Photo credit: DonkeyHotey
    36 min
  • Your Batmobile Might Be Infringing on IP Rights
    Your car can be a copyrighted character. Ok, not really. But the Batmobile is. And other cars in films may be as well. DC Comics sued Gotham Garage for copyright infringement alleging that the custom “Batmobile” cars and car modification kits manufactured by Gotham Garage violated DC Comics’ copyrights. Gotham countered that cars are not subject to copyright protection and that the two models manufactured by Gotham had been subject to design patents that expired.
    The district court held that, despite the design patents, the two models of Batmobile were in fact protected by copyright law because the Batmobile was a character in the Batman comics, television shows, and movies. The Ninth Circuit agreed and announced a new test for determining whether something is a character subject to copyright protection. The case sparked headlines not just because of the popularity of Batman, but because of the unique holding that a car, which cannot normally be the subject of copyright protection, can be a copyrightable character.
    Join Kandis Koustenis and Jennifer Atkins as they discuss the implications of the new Ninth Circuit test and the interplay between patent, copyright, and trademark law highlighted by this case and others like it.
    Photo credit: Gideon Wright
    26 min
  • Star Trek Fan Fiction Gets the Ax-nar from Infringement
    Can you copyright a language? Or a species? Or a yellow shirt? CBS and Paramount who own copyrights to the Star Trek television series and movies sued Axnar Productions, Inc. and Alec Peters alleging copyright infringement based on their short film “Prelude to Axnar” and their crowd-funding campaign to produce a feature length film titled “Axnar”. The films purport to tell the story of a battle referenced in the first and third episodes of the original Star Trek series.
    Fan fiction – fans’ creations of side stories inspired by fictional works the love – is nothing new, and often copyright holders look the other way as fan fiction often aids the development of the market for the copyrighted works. But the “Axnar” work is not your everyday fan fiction: with more than a million dollars in funding, its creators intend for it to be a high quality film. Join Jennifer Atkins and Kandis Koustenis as they discuss the lawsuit and its implications for rights holders and fans.
    Photo credit: warvan
    30 min
  • National Parks & Trademark Disputes Continue
    As of March 1, visitors to Yosemite National Park could no longer stay at the Ahwahnee Hotel or the Wawona Hotel or visit Curry Village or Badger Pass. That’s because the National Park Service changed the names due to a trademark dispute with DNC Parks & Resorts at Yosemite, Inc., the former concessionaire from the […]
    22 min
  • Should Litigation Losers Pay Attorney Fee Awards?
    Let’s Talk Attorney Fees Section 505 of the Copyright Act allows courts to award attorney’s fees and costs to successful litigants in copyright litigation. But when are fee awards appropriate? Courts in different parts of the country have different answers, so the United States Supreme Court is taking up the issue this term in Kirtsaeng […]
    39 min
  • Apple vs FBI, Part 2
    The dispute between Apple and the FBI continued this week, with opposition filings in California, a court order in New York, and congressional hearings. Can the government force a company to write code to bypass security features? Is there a First Amendment problem here? Join Jennifer Atkins and Clyde Findley in this podcast, where they […]
    24 min
  • Apple vs FBI
    A district court in California has ordered Apple to create software that will disable security features on the iPhone of one of the San Bernadino shooters. The order garnered significant public attention and vows to appeal from Apple. Can the government require a tech company to create backdoors into technology products? What does this mean for data security? What does this mean for companies who promise security to their customers?
    Join Antigone Peyton, Clyde Findley, and Jennifer Atkins in this podcast, where they discuss the implications of the district court’s order and what we might see as the case continues.
    28 min
  • Internet of Things: Little ‘Bots Are Watching You!
    The Internet of Things (IoT) is one of the newest technologies on the scene today. It refers to “things” that are able to communicate on the Internet – things like Fitbits, Smartphones, biosensors, coffee makers, thermostats, and even automobiles. These things collect data and they make determinations about what people are doing, when they are doing it, and where they are doing it. That data can be saved on the devices themselves, or transmitted over the Internet to cloud-based servers where the data can reside indefinitely. These things, and particularly all this data, can be valuable evidence! Very interesting questions are starting to surface about the extent to which this evidence can be introduced in a court of law, how that evidence can be interpreted, and especially how it can be challenged. It’s a brave new world out there, where not only “big brother,” but “little robots” are watching you all the time!
    Join Antigone Peyton and Clyde Findley in this podcast, as they explore the Internet of Things and discuss how new devices are creating evidence that can be used in litigations.


    28 min
  • Tattoos, Copyrights and Video Games
    Are tattoos copyrightable, and if so, what are the implications? Tattoo artists have sued the makers of the NBA2K16 video game, claiming copyright infringement because the game includes images of tattoos on several NBA players, including LeBron James and Kobe Bryant. Courts have never squarely addressed the issue, and this case raises a host of questions about the consequences of copyright protection for tattoos.
    Join Antigone Peyton and Jennifer Atkins in this podcast, where they discuss the implications of copyrights on body art, rights of publicity, and potential lines of reasoning we might see from the court as this case progresses.
    23 min