Develop This: Economic and Community Development

Tracye McDaniel and Jennifer Todd-Goynes with TIP Strategies join Dennis for continued discussion on equity and inclusion in this economic environment.  See below for expanded show notes.

TIP Strategies

Connect with Tracye McDaniel

Connect with Jennifer Todd-Goynes

Why are traditional economic development models inadequate?

TRADITIONAL MODEL – Focus on the community’s overall economic recovery to benefit all residents

FUTURE-FOCUSED PRACTICE – Target recovery efforts to uniquely serve and benefit under-resourced populations

• TRADITIONAL MODEL – General relief and recovery tools are open to all residents and businesses

FUTURE-FOCUSED PRACTICE – Actions and policies are designed with under-resourced populations at the center

• TRADIONAL MODEL – Equity and inclusion is for community and workforce development partners

FUTURE-FOCUSED PRACTICE – Equity and inclusion is everyone’s responsibility and has economic benefits

How can economic development organizations and community leaders apply a focus on equity and inclusion?

Two relevant case studies –

Operationalize Equity and Inclusion

BEST PRACTICE:  Resilient Tulsa Action Plan

WHAT IS IT:  An action plan that integrates equity and inclusion across core economic, workforce, and community development functions

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT: 

• Provides specific goals and actions for the City of Tulsa and its partners to implement
• Outlines roles and responsibilities across city departments and organizations (doesn’t treat equity and inclusion as a separate function)

 Expand Broadband Access

BEST PRACTICE:  San Antonio Digital Inclusion Plan

WHAT IS IT:  Cross-sector coalition of 30+ organizations working to close the digital divide for low-income residents

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT:

• Broadband access is increasingly central to economic success and participation in the workforce
• COVID-19 has highlighted the consequences of the digital divide for education and employment outcomes
• The Digital Inclusion Alliance is working to incorporate digital inclusion strategies in the City’s ED Plan

Candi Clouse, Ph.D., assists economic developers by using IMPLAN to measure local and state economies' economic impacts. IMPLAN pairs classic input-output analysis and regional social accounting matrices (SAMs) with software solutions to provide users with the most trusted, accurate, and adaptable model for performing specialized economic impact analyses.

In this episode, Andy and Candi discuss the economic impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic and reveal opportunities for economic development professionals to leverage IMPLAN as a tool to understand the large scale impact of business attraction, retention, and tourism.

Tracye McDaniel and Jaclyn Le with TIP Strategies join Dennis for a thought-provoking discussion on equity and inclusion in this economic environment.  See below for expanded show notes.

TIP Strategies

Connect with Tracye McDaniel

Connect with Jaclyn Le

PART 1.

 CONTEXT

• In today’s rapidly changing demographic, social, and economic environment, the need for equity and inclusion in economic development programs is particularly urgent.
• COVID-19, the current economic crisis, and national uprisings have altered life in every community and called greater attention towards racial and economic justice.
• If the economic development field does not take a more proactive approach to addressing racial inequity, then we run the risk of failing to meet our goals of improving our communities and fostering economic vitality.
• Traditional approaches to economic development have not benefited all populations — and, in many cases, the policies and programs have neglected or even shortchanged people of color, immigrants and low-income communities.

TERMS

• Equity – Providing fair access to resources and opportunity while eliminating systemic barriers that prevent full economic participation.
• Inclusion – Creating an economy in which every individual and group is valued and able to fully contribute to your community’s economic vitality.
• Under-resourced communities – communities that have been historically marginalized and excluded from economic opportunity because of their race or class. Specifically, this includes communities of color and low-income residents. While there is some overlap between these two groups, it is important to recognize that they are not synonymous with each other.

How has COVID-19 exacerbated inequality? 

• Inequality and exclusion existed in our communities before covid-19, but the emergence of this virus and the subsequent economic crisis have exacerbated existing disparities, especially among under-resourced populations.
  • The impacts of coronavirus create a negative feedback loop that makes inequality even worse.
    • Lower incomes è chronic health conditions è increased vulnerability to COVID-19
    • More often impacted by loss of income and healthcare due to quarantines and business closures
    • More likely to be employed in essential worker jobs which increase potential exposure to the virus
    • Contribute to the widening socio-economic divide.
  • TIP has developed an occupational risk tool that measures job-related risk during the COVID-19 crisis on 2 dimensions: risk to personal health and risk to personal earnings
    • 40% of workers in the US are in jobs with a high risk to earnings and a high risk to personal health
    • Across all the major metro regions, Black, Latinx, and younger workers face a disproportionate level of risk
    • Furthermore, 83% of workers facing the greatest risk earn less than $20/hr
    • What this shows us is how fragile and tenuous are economy was pre-covid for Black and Latinx communities – Covid didn’t create this inequality. It has always been there, but now it’s exposed more now than ever.
    • A version of the tool is available on our website—so you can go online and explore the data for the large metro regions in the US

 How have national uprisings and racial justice movement affected economic development?

• National uprisings in the wake of the deaths of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and others has broadened awareness about racial injustice across numerous social and economic issues
• There’s a tendency for economic development to see the uprisings and racial justice movement as a social issue that may not be related to our work.
• That’s fundamentally not true. Systemic racism is also an economic issue. It directly relates to economic development.
• We need to explicitly address racial equity in our work. For too long, Black and Latinx residents have been locked out of opportunity – everything from education to jobs and more.
• Prior to Covid, we were in a period of extensive growth and prosperity. Economic developers played a part in that growth, but the rising tide didn’t lift all boats. Communities of color, in particular, did not experience the benefits that others did.
• There’s a tendency to want to “stay in our lane,” but if we don’t address racial inequity, then many people in our communities will not be able to benefit from the economic opportunities we are working to create. This will also reduce our communities’ competitiveness, especially as public expectations shift, and the private sector is also held accountable.

Eric Canada is back on the podcast today with great, timely information for the economic development community.

What have we learned during this pandemic?

In this episode, Eric shares 7 insights from doing more with less to the continued need for community development.  He also shares a word of caution for siloed organizations.

Blane Candada Ltd.

Connect with Eric Canada

Yes - today's show has a long title, but the listen will be worth your time.  The role of the economic development professional is changing, and adaptation is really the only option.

In this episode, Mary Ann Moon, CEcD, FM, HLM, joins Dennis for a great discussion on all things related to the industry and your professional development.

Connect with Mary Ann Moon

Prosper Economic Development Corporation

In this episode, Dennis is joined by Tracye McDaniel and Jon Roberts with TIP Strategies to discuss emerging economic development trends as a result of the pandemic such as:

-Supply Chain Restructuring -Online Retail Sales -Flexible Workspace -Health & Medicine -Workforce Composition -Social Inequity

In addition, they suggest ways in which EDOs can respond to these trends from assessing vulnerabilities to elimination of redundancies.

TIP Strategies

Connect with Tracye McDaniel

Connect with Jon Roberts

Big economic development projects have many moving parts.  How can you keep the deal together and how can you keep yourself together?

In this episode, Dennis and Jason share strategies for keeping projects on track and making sure you don't wear yourself out.

Jay Moon is a veteran of the economic development industry with roles that span a variety of key positions- including a volunteer position as the former chair of the IEDC board of directors.

In this episode, Jay provides insight on disaster recovery, incentives, supply chains, and future skills needed in the economic development profession.

Connect with Jay Moon

Acclaimed site selector Jay Garner, CEcD, CCE, and President of Garner Economics returns to the podcast to discuss his latest book launch:

Economic Development Is Not for Amateurs!: A must-read for community leaders on how to achieve economic development success

Co-authored with Ross Patten, this read is the perfect length and focuses on the one common denominator between successful economic development strategies: leadership.

Connect with Jay Garner

Garner Economics

Pick up the book now

For those organizations highly dependent on event revenue, this COVID crisis is proving especially difficult.

In this episode, Jason asks for your feedback.  How is your organization placing event revenue?  Are you cutting back, spending reserves, or replacing it with something new?  For those of you doing virtual events, what kind of revenue loss are you incurring?

We want your feedback, please email details to [email protected]