Opening Arguments

Did a Federal Judge Really Just Shutter Alligator Alcatraz?


Listen Later

OA1185 - The rule of law has never been put more to the test in this country, and we do our best to keep up with at least a few of the most important decent developments. We begin with a brief review of the current status of wrongfully-deported Salvadoran asylum seeker Kilmar Abrego Garcia. Why is the Trump administration desperately trying to re-deport this Central American man whom they already fully admit was deported to hell by mistake to… Uganda? Matt explains. Then: Did a federal judge really just shutter Florida’s “Alligator Alcatraz”? We consider the history of this surprisingly significant swampland and why an environmental challenge to its existence was so much easier to win than one based in due process, while also celebrating a major win for native rights.

Another major presidential first this week: for the first time in US history, the President has claimed the authority to fire a member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors. Could this one decision really have global economic consequences? How much does it matter that Trump has done literally the one thing that the Supreme Court has ever told him *not* to do? We review some basics to try to understand the full magnitude of what this all means for our current moment before moving on to today’s footnote: an outstanding decision from a Virginia federal judge which should stand as a model for how the judiciary can stand up to American fascism.

  1. Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s Motion to Dismiss Based on Vindictive and Selective Prosecution

  2. Abrego Garcia habeas docket

  3. SCOTUS shadow docket order in Trump v. Wilcox (5/22/2025)

  4. Judge Williams’s order closing “Alligator Alcatraz” (8/21/2025)

  5. Order granting motion to dismiss in U.S. v. Russell (8/26/2025)

Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Opening ArgumentsBy Opening Arguments Media LLC

  • 4.3
  • 4.3
  • 4.3
  • 4.3
  • 4.3

4.3

3,552 ratings


More shows like Opening Arguments

View all
Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts by Slate Podcasts

Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts

3,531 Listeners

Cognitive Dissonance by Atheist and Skeptical News

Cognitive Dissonance

4,035 Listeners

The Scathing Atheist by Puzzle in a Thunderstorm, LLC

The Scathing Atheist

3,207 Listeners

Skeptics with a K by Skeptic Media Limited

Skeptics with a K

431 Listeners

God Awful Movies by Puzzle in a Thunderstorm, LLC

God Awful Movies

2,599 Listeners

The Skepticrat by Puzzle in a Thunderstorm, LLC

The Skepticrat

1,986 Listeners

The Lawfare Podcast by The Lawfare Institute

The Lawfare Podcast

6,302 Listeners

Knowledge Fight by Knowledge Fight

Knowledge Fight

4,640 Listeners

Citation Needed by Citation Needed Media

Citation Needed

2,661 Listeners

UnJustified by MSW Media

UnJustified

7,645 Listeners

Cleanup on Aisle 45 with AG & Harry Dunn by MSW Media

Cleanup on Aisle 45 with AG & Harry Dunn

1,887 Listeners

Dear Old Dads by Eli Bosnick, Thomas Smith, Tom Curry

Dear Old Dads

525 Listeners

Where There's Woke by Thomas Smith

Where There's Woke

268 Listeners

Law and Chaos by Liz Dye

Law and Chaos

375 Listeners

The Know Rogan Experience by Cross Pond Productions

The Know Rogan Experience

771 Listeners