This week on Do You Watch What I Watch?, we're reviewing Hallmark Channel's Double Holiday.

The ingredients seemed promising: a Christmas celebration, Hanukkah traditions, workplace competition, and Kristoffer Polaha. But despite some strong performances and a story with plenty of potential, this one never fully came together for us.

Join Josh and Jennifer as they recap the movie, share the moments that worked, unpack the ones that didn't, and decide whether Double Holiday earns Gold or Coal.

As always, we're keeping it kind, keeping it fun, and looking for the good — even when a movie doesn't quite make our nice list.

Welcome to the first-ever Quick Watch!

Quick Watch is a new mini-format from 'Do You Watch What I Watch?': shorter, faster reviews when a Hallmark movie is too good (or too interesting) to wait for a full episode.

This week, Josh shares his thoughts on Hallmark's newest original movie, The Greek Aisle. From the charming setting and family dynamics to the romance at the center of the story, he'll break down what worked, what didn't, and whether this one earns Gold or Coal.

If you've watched The Greek Aisle, we'd love to hear your verdict. Join the conversation and let us know where you landed!

Hallmark Hanukkah Month rolls on with 'Hanukkah on the Rocks' (2024)!

This week, Josh and Jennifer head to a cozy bar, spend some time with Stacey Farber and Daren Kagasoff, and try to decide exactly where this movie lands on the Gold-or-Coal spectrum.

The movie earns points for charm, atmosphere, and one very nostalgic surprise appearance from Double Dare legend Marc Summers. But does it have enough sparkle to become a Hallmark Hanukkah favorite?

Join us as we recap the story, discuss what worked, what didn't quite land, and hand down our official verdict.

And yes... there are more than a few Double Dare references along the way.

Welcome to Hallmark Hanukkah Month!

We're kicking off this special June series with "Round and Round" (2023), a clever Hanukkah time-loop romance that completely won us over.

Join Josh and Jennifer as they recap the movie, discuss what makes it stand out from so many other Hallmark films, celebrate the performances, laugh through some memorable moments, and decide whether this one earns Gold or Coal.

Spoiler alert: We really, really liked this one.

If you've been looking for a Hallmark movie that's funny, charming, romantic, and genuinely unique, Round and Round might be exactly what you're looking for.

New Hanukkah movie reviews every week throughout June!

Christmas is back... in July! LOL

Hallmark has unveiled four brand-new Christmas movies for its annual 'Christmas in July' event, and we're diving headfirst into all the festive goodness.

This week, Josh and Jennifer share their first impressions and 'Gold-or-Coal' predictions for the newest additions to Hallmark's holiday lineup.

Join us for plenty of laughs, festive speculation, and enough Christmas cheer to survive the hottest days of summer.

Grab your sunscreen and your Santa hat. We're talking Christmas in July!

It’s time for the ultimate Hallmark debate…

WHO belongs on the Hallmark Mt. Rushmore?! 👀🏔️

This week, we’re revealing OUR Top 4 Hallmark stars of all time: the legends, the icons, the comfort-watch kings & queens we’ll always show up for.

And yes… there were negotiations. 😂

Did your favorites make the cut? Or did we totally miss the mark?!

👇 Tell us YOUR Hallmark Mt. Rushmore! We're reading EVERY comment!

The Hallmark Dream Book is officially here… and apparently financial responsibility has been canceled. 🎄💸

This week, Jennifer and Josh are flipping through the NEW Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Dream Book and sharing:
✨ Their biggest must-haves!
😅 The ornaments that left them VERY confused!
❤️ Favorite sentimental finds!
🎁 And why this catalog feels like Christmas nostalgia in paper form.

Whether you’re a longtime collector or just love cozy Christmas vibes, this episode is packed with laughs, memories, and a whole lot of “TAKE OUR MONEY” energy. Plus, Josh is sharing a BIG secret!

So grab your Dream Book and come gab with us!

This week, we recap and review Hallmark’s A Godwink Christmas: Miracle of Love ... and this one is WILD. 😂 From nonstop sweetness to plot twists flying in from every direction, we had a blast breaking this one down.

It’s funny, heartfelt, slightly chaotic, and packed with plenty of Gold or Coal moments. Grab a cozy drink and join us for a fun Hallmark chat! 🎄

And, as always, may your days be merry and bright!

Season 1 of Hope Valley: 1874 has officially come to a close, and we’re breaking down EVERYTHING from the finale.

From emotional character moments to lingering questions heading into Season 2, we’re recapping the highs, the lows, and all the Gold or Coal along the way. We also look back on the season as a whole and talk about why this show has started building such a loyal audience among Hearties.

Did the finale stick the landing? We’re diving in.

This week, we head back to Hope Valley for another full recap and review of Hallmark’s newest episodes. FINALE RECAP COMING SOON!

Josh + Jennifer break down the biggest moments, favorite scenes, standout performances, and all the cozy drama along the way — before handing out their official Gold or Coal ratings.

Did this episode win us over? Tune in and find out and subscribe for new episodes -- and a lot more fun -- all year long!