Melissa digs into the missing person case of Kimberly Sue Jones, out of Parkersburg, West Virginia.

Melissa discusses the 1974 New Jersey murders of Suzanne Garden and Cynthia Leslie, and interviews a witness who escaped from their killers.

Melissa discusses the Judy Petty case, out of Parkersburg, West Virginia.

Melissa discusses her unusual connection to the case of a missing person, Gretchen Fleming, from Parkersburg, WV.

In the Season 1 finale, Melissa reviews this season's findings while looking at the murder board. Afterward, she sits down for an interview with James Baysinger to discuss the first season of the podcast.

Melissa continues to interview those with information during her trip to Marysville and finally gets to meet Paula and Steve in-person.

Melissa sits down to answer questions from the Dog Pound.

Melissa continues her interview with Eric and she asks him who he believes is responsible for Bernie's murder. She also hears from some Marysville residents, who tell her about their interactions with Nicol.

Melissa learns that Eric is being held at the Tri-County Regional Jail, so she returns to Marysville to have a sit-down with him.