Send us Fan Mail

In 2013, Melissa dropped her girls off at school and hasn't been seen or heard from since. In this episode, I break down the timeline of Melissa’s disappearance, the last known moments before she vanished, and the unsettling details that have left her family and investigators searching for answers for over a decade.

Someone knows something, and it's time we ask louder questions.

Song of the Week: "Ash and Tears" by Last Good Chad

Send us Fan Mail

A look into the lives of Chris Cornell and Chester Bennington, the "Silent Children" theories that linked their deaths to Anthony Bourdain and Avicii, and the true story of the NXIVM cult that changed the way we look at power and influence.

Song of the Week: "Hunger Strike" by Stephen Wilson Jr.

Send us Fan Mail

Heyya!

   Tuesdays True Crime Tuesday will be on Friday as it's true crime and a conspiracy deep dive! I cant wait for you all to hear it! <3 

Send us Fan Mail

Is God real, or are we just a cosmic accident? 

In this episode, we dive deep into the invisible reality of spiritual warfare, how the enemy uses doubt and deception to keep you from your purpose, and I wrap it all up by sharing the personal testimonial of how God became undeniable in my own life.

Song of the Week: "I'm Not Dead" by Mike Messina 

Dubby is a clean energy drink mix with no sugar, no crash, and none of that jittery ‘I just licked a power outlet’ feeling.

Try clean energy today! Go to  www.dubby.gg and use code STAYWEIRD at checkout for 10% off!

https://nighthawk-radio.com/

https://screamingpodcast.com/

Send us Fan Mail

In this deep-dive episode, we pull back the curtain on the most analyzed presidency in American history. We begin in the freezing waters of the Pacific, where a young John F. Kennedy survived a ship destruction that should have killed him, and follow his meteoric rise to become the youngest man ever elected to the Oval Office.

Song of the week: "I'm Not Dead" by Mike Messina 

Dubby: www.dubby.gg use code STAYWEIRD at checkout for 10% off! 

Send us Fan Mail

I’m This week on True Crime Tuesday, we’re talking about one of the wildest courtroom stories in recent memory. After police raided Afroman’s house in Ohio over kidnapping and drug trafficking allegations and found nothing, he turned the entire thing into music, videos, merch, and one unforgettable song: “Lemon Pound Cake.”

In this episode, I break down the full timeline from the 2022 raid, to the songs and viral videos he released, to the lawsuit filed by the deputies, and the courtroom moments that had the internet obsessed. We’re getting into the facts, the chaos, the funniest moments, and how this whole thing ended in a major free speech win.

Listen now, and while you’re here, grab some energy for your next deep dive with Dubby:

https://www.dubby.gg/discount/KELLIANNERUGH?ref=baeobdws

Use code: STAYWEIRD

Send us Fan Mail

Just a quick little update. True Crime Tuesday will air on Friday and Fridays deep dive will be on Sunday <3 

Send us Fan Mail

This week on Don't Quote Me, It's Probably Nothing, we’re heading to a small place in Kelli's brain ... to talk about a bunch of nothing!

⚡ Sponsored by Dubby Energy

Fuel your chaos the clean way 🧠⚡

No sugar. No crash. Just energy to keep you going, whether you’re deep in a true crime rabbit hole or just trying to survive your day.

👉 Shop here: https://www.dubby.gg/discount/KELLIANNERUGH?ref=baeobdws
👉 Use code: STAYWEIRD at checkout for a discount

And when you support Dubby, you’re also supporting the show 💚

🎧 Song of the Week

“Hindsight” by Goodfella

Go give it a listen, add it to your playlist, and let me know what you think!

Send a text

This week on True Crime Tuesday, we’re heading to a small town in Ohio where something as simple as a letter turned into years of fear, accusations, and unanswered questions.

Starting in the 1970s, residents of Circleville began receiving anonymous letters exposing personal secrets, accusing people of affairs, and threatening to reveal even more.

What started as harassment quickly escalated into something much more serious… including a suspicious death and a booby-trapped sign meant to harm its target.

Someone was watching.

Someone knew the secrets.

And decades later, we still don’t know exactly who it was.

⚡ Sponsored by Dubby Energy

Fuel your chaos the clean way 🧠⚡

No sugar. No crash. Just energy to keep you going, whether you’re deep in a true crime rabbit hole or just trying to survive your day.

👉 Shop here: https://www.dubby.gg/discount/KELLIANNERUGH?ref=baeobdws
👉 Use code: STAYWEIRD at checkout for a discount

And when you support Dubby, you’re also supporting the show 💚

🎧 Song of the Week

“Hindsight” by Goodfella

Go give it a listen, add it to your playlist, and let me know what you think!

Sources & References

• FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin  “The Circleville Letters”
• Pickaway County historical records & local news archives
• The Circleville Writer: The Unsolved Mystery of the Circleville Letters by Paul Freshour
• Associated Press archives on the Circleville case
• Ohio court records related to Paul Freshour’s trial
• Various true crime research compilations and case summaries

Send a text

What if one of the most mysterious places on Earth wasn’t somewhere across the ocean… but right here in the United States?

In this deep dive episode, we’re heading north to one of the strangest regions in the world: The Alaska Triangle.

Stretching between Anchorage, Juneau, and Utqiagvik, this massive wilderness has become famous for unexplained disappearances, missing aircraft, strange lights in the sky, and stories that go back long before modern investigators ever arrived.

More than 20,000 people have vanished in Alaska since the 1970s, and some of the cases are almost impossible to explain. We’ll look at one of the most famous disappearances in American history ... the mysterious 1972 flight carrying House Majority Leader Hale Boggs, a congressman, an aide, and a pilot… a plane that vanished without leaving behind a single piece of wreckage.

But the mystery doesn’t stop there.

We’ll also explore the eerie legends told by Indigenous communities in the region, including stories of the Kushtaka, a shape-shifting being said to lure travelers deeper into the wilderness. 

Is the Alaska Triangle simply one of the harshest environments on Earth?

Or is there something about this region that we still don’t fully understand?

Song of the Week: "Hey Leonardo (She Likes Me for Me)" by Blessid Union of Souls