At the Water's Edge

Earned, Not Given: A PhD in the Human Condition with MG (ret) Matt Smith


Listen Later

Retired Major General Matt Smith joins Scott to unpack why veteran transition isn’t just a “feel-good” topic—it’s a long-term national security issue tied directly to readiness and recruiting. They discuss Emory University Goizueta Business School’s Master of Business for Veterans (MBV) Program, the importance of community during transition, and how veterans can translate military leadership into the “language of business.” This is a tactical conversation for leaders leaving uniform—and for employers who want to actually harness veteran talent.


Key Takeaways

  • Why how we treat the GWOT generation directly impacts future recruiting and readiness.

  • What the MBV is (and isn’t): “half an MBA,” built to give senior leaders the core business foundation.

  • The underrated value of grad school for vets: time, perspective, and exposure to “what’s possible.”

  • Why in-person cohort/community can be a force multiplier during the 1–2 year transition window.

  • How veterans should think about GI Bill ROI (and why everyone wants your benefits dollars).

  • The veteran “secret sauce” businesses miss: disciplined initiative + relentless after-action review mindset.

  • Why the chain of command often gives well-intentioned but wrong transition advice—and how to recalibrate.

  • “A PhD in the human condition”: the leadership dataset vets carry into any organization.


    Quotes

    • “Transition is a process, not an event… it takes about two years.”

    • “Graduate business education exposes you to what’s in the realm of possible—and what you don’t want to do.”

    • “If you’re spending other people’s money, they won’t give it to you unless you know how to run a business.”

    • “Veterans bring disciplined initiative—the secret sauce of the American military.”

    • “You have a PhD in the human condition.”


      Chapters

      • 00:00 Why veteran transition is a national security issue

      • 03:16 MG Matt Smith’s background + what the MBV is

      • 06:58 Classroom dynamics: experience, discipline, and veteran accountability

      • 13:12 2001 vs now: how academia’s view of veterans has changed

      • 15:43 The “three buckets” of MBA value (skills, translation, time) + what’s missing

      • 19:52 Timing grad school with retirement + the power of an in-person support system

      • 24:28 “It’s okay not to know”—transition goals and changing plans

      • 29:41 GI Bill ROI, reality checks, and why location/industry matters

      • 31:03 “Business as a language course” + the PMP as translation

      • 34:13 Doing anything you want (and failing fast) after service

      • 39:49 “PhD in the human condition” and why vets don’t see their own value

      • 44:15 Advice to employers: how to actually utilize veteran talent

      • 47:14 MG Smith’s personal transition at the one-year mark

      • 49:29 What Emory could do next + why society needs vets at places like Emory

      • 54:22 Closing thoughts: GWOT ended quietly; transition didn’t—plus gratitude to Vietnam vets

        ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store

        At the Water's EdgeBy WRKdefined Podcast Network

        • 4.9
        • 4.9
        • 4.9
        • 4.9
        • 4.9

        4.9

        13 ratings


        More shows like At the Water's Edge

        View all
        Jocko Podcast by Jocko DEFCOR Network

        Jocko Podcast

        30,871 Listeners