Academy of Ideas

#EducationForum: Exploring Head, Hand, Heart by David Goodhart


Listen Later

Smart people have become too powerful. That’s the claim made by social commentator David Goodhart in his latest book Head, Hand, Heart: The Struggle for Dignity and Status in the 21st Century. 

The talent to pass exams and handle information efficiently, he argues, has become the gold standard of human esteem. Those with a generous helping of such aptitude have formed a new class – a ‘mass elite’ – which now shapes society in its own interests. For those employed in manual work or the caring professions it’s another matter.

“It is becoming harder to feel satisfaction and self-respect living an ordinary, decent life, especially in the bottom part of the income spectrum”, writes Goodhart.

Brexit and Trump have frequently been criticised because of the low intelligence or poor education of their working-class voters. Yet the recent wave of Covid-related school closures and exam cancellations suggests that academic values aren’t all-conquering either.

The pandemic has seen a re-evaluation of the importance of blue-collar workers and the caring professions, such as in the weekly ‘Clap for Carers’ during the height of the crisis. However, it has also seen those protesting against masks and lockdowns labelled as low-information ‘Covidiots’.

So to what extent is Goodhart’s distinction between Head, Hand and Heart helpful in understanding the contemporary tensions in education? Is he correct to claim that we have reached an era of ‘peak Head’ in which a meritocracy based on educational achievement is counter-productive? Or can one believe in high intellectual standards and the importance of exams without excluding those who have little aptitude for them?

Is a school system which embraces both the academic and non-academic possible – or are these distinctions meaningless anyway?

To consider these and other questions, this Academy of Ideas Education Forum event took the form of a book group on Head, Hand, Heart. Gareth Sturdy gives a short introduction to the book before opening up the meeting to round-table discussion.

How does one argue effectively for a schooling system which accords dignity and status to the non-academic, while upholding academic standards?

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Academy of IdeasBy academyofideas

  • 3.9
  • 3.9
  • 3.9
  • 3.9
  • 3.9

3.9

7 ratings


More shows like Academy of Ideas

View all
Making Sense with Sam Harris by Sam Harris

Making Sense with Sam Harris

26,327 Listeners

The spiked podcast by The spiked podcast

The spiked podcast

206 Listeners

Americano by The Spectator

Americano

262 Listeners

The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast by Dr. Jordan B. Peterson

The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast

33,958 Listeners

Academy of Ideas by Academy of Ideas

Academy of Ideas

564 Listeners

TRIGGERnometry by TRIGGERnometry

TRIGGERnometry

1,839 Listeners

The Brendan O'Neill Show by The Brendan O'Neill Show

The Brendan O'Neill Show

365 Listeners

Last Orders - a spiked podcast by Last Orders - a spiked podcast

Last Orders - a spiked podcast

50 Listeners

Quillette Podcast by Quillette

Quillette Podcast

789 Listeners

Planet Normal by The Telegraph

Planet Normal

201 Listeners

heretics. by Andrew Gold

heretics.

573 Listeners

The Rest Is History by Goalhanger

The Rest Is History

12,964 Listeners

The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters by lotuseaters.com

The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters

537 Listeners

The Current Thing by Nick Dixon

The Current Thing

27 Listeners

Beyond Gender by Stella O'Malley, Mia Hughes, Bret Alderman

Beyond Gender

36 Listeners