Curious Cousins OK Podcast

Ep 100 Hatchet & Hex Houses


Listen Later

EPISODE 100!!!!! 🎉


FIRST AND FOREMOST, THANK YOU! Thank you to all our listeners and fans! You all are simply the best! We wouldn’t be here without you! You have truly allowed us to grow and share what we love…the kooky and spooky of our home state! 


With that being said, join you favorite cousins as Jess gets into this week’s spooky tales…one in OKC and one in Tulsa; The Hatchet and Hex Houses. 


Within the historic Gatewood neighborhood of Oklahoma City lies Carey Place, a street lined with 1930s Mediterranean and Spanish-style homes. The street is known for the urban legends and ghost stories surrounding its homes, particularly the "Hatchet House" where a young girl named Carey was allegedly brutally murdered years ago. The house's distinctive hatchet-carved shutters and the red-painted porch and driveway said to conceal bloodstains from the crime add to the eerie lore. While the details of the legend vary, the neighborhood embraces its haunted reputation, with residents going all-out for Halloween celebrations that draw hundreds of trick-or-treaters each year. Other homes on the street, like one with an irreparable bullet hole in the window, also have their own mysterious stories that contribute to Carey Place's reputation as Oklahoma City's "most haunted neighborhood."


The Tulsa Hex House was a real-life haunted house in Tulsa, Oklahoma with a dark history. In the 1940s, Carolann Smith, a woman with a history of suspicious deaths and insurance fraud, held two women captive in the house's basement for 8 years. Smith had convinced the women, Willetta Horner and Virginia Evans, that she was a healer who could save them from damnation, and subjected them to cruelty, torture, and mind control. Police eventually discovered the women and charged Smith, but she received little punishment. The house was later demolished, but the property remains haunted, with reports of strange occurrences like cars moving on their own in the parking lot that now stands on the site. The Hex House has become a notorious part of Tulsa's history, a chilling tale of religious enslavement, fraud, and the paranormal.


Thanks again for all your love and support! We truly are so appreciative of you! 


Sources:

  • The Hex House

  • Weird Oklahoma by Wesley Treat

  • Haunted Oklahoma City by Jeff Provine and Tanya McCoy

  • Tulsa's Haunted Memories by Teri French

  • Eerie Oklahoma by Heather Woodward

  • Only In Your State - Hex House

  • The Echo - Haunted OKC

  • The Oklahoman - Carey Place

  • The Oklahoman - Scarey Carey



  • ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Curious Cousins OK PodcastBy Curious Cousins OK

    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9
    • 4.9

    4.9

    26 ratings


    More shows like Curious Cousins OK Podcast

    View all
    The Vanished Podcast by Wondery

    The Vanished Podcast

    15,319 Listeners

    20/20 by ABC News

    20/20

    11,846 Listeners

    48 Hours by CBS News

    48 Hours

    10,801 Listeners

    Gone Cold - Texas True Crime by TTC Productions

    Gone Cold - Texas True Crime

    1,892 Listeners

    Crime Junkie by audiochuck

    Crime Junkie

    368,647 Listeners

    Hell and Gone by iHeartPodcasts

    Hell and Gone

    7,469 Listeners

    Going West: True Crime by Dark West Productions

    Going West: True Crime

    10,800 Listeners

    Dateline NBC by NBC News

    Dateline NBC

    47,754 Listeners

    Coffee and Cases Podcast by Cloud10

    Coffee and Cases Podcast

    617 Listeners

    Park Predators by audiochuck

    Park Predators

    17,830 Listeners

    Anatomy of Murder by audiochuck

    Anatomy of Murder

    20,053 Listeners

    Mind of a Monster: The Killer Nurse by ID

    Mind of a Monster: The Killer Nurse

    1,753 Listeners

    Betrayal: Weekly by iHeartPodcasts and Glass Podcasts

    Betrayal: Weekly

    7,900 Listeners

    Slaycation: True Crimes, Murders, and Twisted Vacations by Kim Davis, Adam "Tex" Davis, Jerry Kolber; True Crime Podcast

    Slaycation: True Crimes, Murders, and Twisted Vacations

    517 Listeners

    Dateline Originals by NBC News

    Dateline Originals

    1,521 Listeners