The Safety of Work

Ep. 124 Is safety a key value driver for business?


Listen Later

We challenge the notion that high injury rates are punished by market forces, as we dig into this article that posits the opposite: that safety should be a performance driver. Our analysis dives deep into the credibility and methodologies of the article, emphasizing the critical role of peer review and the broader body of knowledge.

We'll also scrutinize the use of data as rhetoric versus evidence, focusing on the transparency and rigor of research methods when interviewing executives about safety practices. Is safety merely seen as a compliance issue or a strategic investment? We dissect the methodologies, including participant selection and question framing, to uncover potential biases. Finally, we critique a proposed five-step process aimed at transforming safety into a competitive advantage. From aligning on the meaning of safety to incentivizing employees, we expose significant gaps in academic rigor and alignment with established safety literature. 

This conversation serves as a powerful critique of superficial analyses by those outside the safety science domain, offering listeners critical insights into the complexity of safety management and its potential alignment with organizational goals. 
 


Discussion Points:

  • Re-examining the role of safety as a value driver for business
  • Comparing contrasting research findings and cautioning about evaluating research
  • Data as rhetoric in safety
  • Transparency and methodology are crucial in research, especially when interviewing executives about workplace safety
  • Executives' perspectives on safety are questioned, research methods are critiqued
  • Clarifying claims and performance in business 
  • The five-step process for competitive advantage 
  • A study on the effectiveness of safety training methods 
  • Safety management is complex and requires evidence-based strategies, not superficial analysis or reliance on compliance training
  • Strategic value of workplace safety
  • Safety's impact on business success is uncertain, but exploring its alignment with organizational goals is important
  • Takeaways 
  • The answer to our episode’s question: “the short answer is we still don't know!” 
  • Like and follow, send us your comments and suggestions!

 

Quotes:

“The trouble is, then we don't know whether what they're referring to is published research that might be somewhere else that we can look for for the details, or work that they did specifically for this article, or other work that they've done that was just never published.” - Drew

“We've got to be really careful…this is using data as rhetoric, not using data as data.” - Drew

“I wouldn't be surprised that most people see safety as both a cost and as an outcome.”- Drew

“So you've got two-thirds of these companies that don't even have any safety metric, like not even an injury metric or anything that they monitor.” - David

“So we kind of assume business performance means financial performance, but that in itself is never clarified.” - David


Resources:

The Article: Safety Should Be a Performance Driver

Episode 121: Is Safety Good for Business?

The Safety of Work Podcast

The Safety of Work on LinkedIn

Feedback@safetyofwork

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Safety of WorkBy David Provan

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

21 ratings


More shows like The Safety of Work

View all
PreAccident Investigation Podcast by Todd Conklin

PreAccident Investigation Podcast

169 Listeners

Conversations by ABC listen

Conversations

893 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC listen

All In The Mind

754 Listeners

This Working Life by ABC listen

This Working Life

22 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC listen

The Economy, Stupid

25 Listeners

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today by ABC listen

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today

72 Listeners

Ladies, We Need To Talk by ABC listen

Ladies, We Need To Talk

335 Listeners

If You're Listening by ABC listen

If You're Listening

325 Listeners

A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard by A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

A Podcast of One's Own with Julia Gillard

101 Listeners

The HOP Nerd by Safety FM

The HOP Nerd

18 Listeners

HOP Into Action Podcast Series by Brent Sutton

HOP Into Action Podcast Series

2 Listeners

Quick Smart by ABC listen

Quick Smart

7 Listeners

LEADING SAFELY with Georgina Poole by Georgina Poole

LEADING SAFELY with Georgina Poole

5 Listeners

Punk Rock Safety by Ben Goodheart, David Provan, Ron Gantt

Punk Rock Safety

10 Listeners

Safe As Podcast by Ben Hutchinson

Safe As Podcast

3 Listeners