The Mindful Aspiring CRNA Podcast

Ep. 29: Mentoring vs. Coaching: What's the Difference — and Why It Matters in Your CRNA Journey


Listen Later

Welcome back to The Mindful Aspiring CRNA Podcast.

In this episode, I'm diving into a conversation that's long overdue in healthcare: mentoring vs. coaching — what they are, what they aren't, and why the distinction actually matters more than we think.

If you've ever wondered:

  • "Why would I pay for coaching when I can get advice for free?"

  • "Is coaching even legit?"

  • "Isn't this just mindset fluff?"

  • "Shouldn't healthcare professionals be able to handle things on their own?"

This episode is for you.

I share my own very real, very skeptical beginning with coaching back in 2020 — when I was a brand new mom, working 24-hour shifts during the height of the pandemic, juggling personal challenges, and silently white-knuckling my way through it all. Hiring a coach didn't just help me "feel better." It changed how I led at work, how I showed up in my marriage, how I built my business, and how I took care of my own nervous system.

And that's the part we don't talk about enough in healthcare.

We are trained to manage everyone else's physiology — but not our own.

In this episode, I unpack:

  • Why mentorship is powerful — but often incomplete

  • How coaching goes deeper than strategy and into identity

  • The nervous system science behind procrastination, perfectionism, and imposter syndrome

  • Why high-achievers often stall despite "knowing what to do"

  • The 4 P's that quietly dominate the CRNA journey: Perfectionism, Productivity, Performance, and People-Pleasing

  • Why burnout is normalized — but personal development is not

  • The truth about paying for coaching and the psychology behind commitment

  • 6 reasons you absolutely should not get a coach

This isn't about hype. It's not about "just think positive." It's not about someone telling you what to do.

It's about learning how to lead yourself.

Because you can know everything… and still not execute. You can look successful… and still feel shaky inside. You can hustle toward your goals… without building the character required to sustain them.

If you're an aspiring CRNA who feels stuck in cycles of overthinking, overworking, self-doubt, or emotional reactivity — this conversation will challenge you in the best way.

Healthcare doesn't need tougher people. It needs developed leaders.

So listen with an open mind and then decide for yourself if coaching is for you or not.

I'll see you inside the episode.

LINKS MENTIONED:

  • Want a 15min FREE Consult? Email me your availabiity at [email protected]
  • Follow me on IG @amandakcrna or my YouTube Channel
  • Roadmap Coaching for RNs
  • Coaching for NAR/RRNAs
  • Website: www.amandakaycrna.com

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Mindful Aspiring CRNA PodcastBy Amanda Kay MSN, CRNA

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

18 ratings


More shows like The Mindful Aspiring CRNA Podcast

View all
Crime Junkie by Audiochuck

Crime Junkie

369,886 Listeners

Beyond The Mask: Innovation & Opportunities For CRNAs by Beyond The Mask Podcast

Beyond The Mask: Innovation & Opportunities For CRNAs

199 Listeners

Critical Care Scenarios by Brandon Oto, PA-C, FCCM and Bryan Boling, DNP, ACNP, FCCM

Critical Care Scenarios

256 Listeners

Core Anesthesia by Tanner and Cole

Core Anesthesia

299 Listeners

CRNA School Prep Academy Podcast by Jenny Finnell

CRNA School Prep Academy Podcast

113 Listeners

Atomic Anesthesia by Rhea Temmermand, PhD, CRNA & Sachi Lord, MSN, CRNA

Atomic Anesthesia

132 Listeners