Episode 389 of RevolutionZ has as guest Francine Mestrum, a longtime social justice researcher and organizer whose work spans globalization, poverty, inequality, social protection, public services, gender, and the “social commons” approach to economic and social rights. She has marched, organized, and built a campaigns and  organizations and yet felt like the world barely moved. And she has thought about why. Her experience in networks tied to the World Social Forum has given her a wide and deep view of what movements do well and what keeps failing. What obstacles impede winning.

She highlights two painful patterns. We show up, we do great work for a moment, but soon everything stops. And, when we show up we are not all together. We are atomized. Some are for this, some are for that, and we do not help each other with this and with that. So next time, we start as if from scratch. We struggle to have, and often even struggle against having unity.

Francine argues that without continuity between actions and real convergence across movements, we will stay trapped in atomized issue and time-bound silos. So we talk about why groups protect their identity, why alliances with trade unions are so often contested, and why cross border organizing still feels out of reach even as crises go global.

Then we go a layer deeper. We ask why the left often acts like winning is impossible and how that defeatism fuels sectarian fights, vague slogans, and refusal to define key terms. Francine calls it a crisis of imagination: thousands of small solutions exist, but we have no shared narrative for a better world able to inspire and orient. Pursuing answers we dig into working class politics and dignity, and why the right can offer belonging and a sense of efficacy even while failing materially and yet advance. We ask, what would it take for the left to reconnect through material demands, inspiring solidarity, and organized power?

Support the show