Citations Needed

Episode 181: US Media's 5 Most Popular Revisionist Tropes About the Iraq and Vietnam Wars


Listen Later

"Charting a different course in the Vietnam War to fewer deaths and a better end," muses a book review in the Washington Post. "The Vietnam War was begun in good faith, by decent people," a Ken Burns PBS documentary tells us. "The Iraq War Reconsidered," reads a headline from The Atlantic.

Often, especially when an anniversary of a U.S. invasion or withdrawal rolls around, we're told that the devastation wrought by the US war machine was complicated, flawed, but ultimately necessary if not beneficial. Sure, the United States has killed millions, destabilized power structures, wrecked communities and economies, lied about the reasons for doing it all, and drawn the ire of people throughout the world. But, in hindsight, many in U.S. media insists, a horrible act of war from a world superpower wasn't an unequivocal, deliberate, and needless crime against humanity, but somewhere between a misunderstood righteous cause and a bumbling, good faith mistake motivated by humanitarian concerns.

An ideological system of reassurance therefore emerges. Once wars are broadly viewed as either wrong or a "failure" in the popular imagination — as in the case of Vietnam and Iraq — a cottage industry of punditry and pseudo-history emerges in the subsequent years designed to soothe the egos of elites and muddy the waters of both memory and reality for casual media consumers.

Put another way: we all see a dead body on the floor, no one can doubt this. No one can reasonably argue the destruction of Vietnam and Iraq didn't happen. So, this cottage industry springs into action, on behalf of those that caused the death, working to get the guilty party a charge of third degree manslaughter rather than murder. It was an accident, they were mistaken, they had bad intelligence, they were driven by concerns for freedom and human rights.

After all, those who destroyed Vietnam remained in power well into the 2000s. And those who destroyed Iraq currently run our major publications, universities, nonprofits, and think tanks. They still even run the country itself. So the incentive to make sure they all plead guilty to third degree manslaughter rather than first degree murder is tremendous, otherwise, we’re just a country led by war criminals — and this simply cannot be. We need absolution. We must remain, when all is said and done, innocent.

On this week's episode, we’ll explore the war revisionism industry, breaking down five ways in which media seek to sanitize and justify even the most notoriously unpopular and horrific U.S.-led and backed wars — namely Vietnam and Iraq — as unpleasant, imperfect, mistaken, but ultimately incidental byproducts of a noble and righteous empire that, above all, meant well.

Our guest is The Intercept's Jon Schwarz.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Citations NeededBy Nima Shirazi and Adam Johnson

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

3,834 ratings


More shows like Citations Needed

View all
Jacobin Radio by Jacobin

Jacobin Radio

1,402 Listeners

The Dig by Daniel Denvir

The Dig

1,487 Listeners

Chapo Trap House by Chapo Trap House

Chapo Trap House

8,792 Listeners

Rev Left Radio by Revolutionary Left Radio

Rev Left Radio

3,228 Listeners

Trillbilly Worker's Party by Trillbilly Worker's Party

Trillbilly Worker's Party

1,867 Listeners

Minion Death Cult by Alexander Edward

Minion Death Cult

632 Listeners

The Antifada by Sean KB and AP Andy

The Antifada

920 Listeners

Death Panel by Death Panel

Death Panel

521 Listeners

Know Your Enemy by Matthew Sitman

Know Your Enemy

1,900 Listeners

TrueAnon by TrueAnon

TrueAnon

3,130 Listeners

Blowback by Blowback

Blowback

2,913 Listeners

This Machine Kills by This Machine Kills

This Machine Kills

207 Listeners

Guerrilla History by Guerrilla History

Guerrilla History

553 Listeners

American Prestige by Daniel Bessner & Derek Davison

American Prestige

702 Listeners

Guys: With Bryan Quinby by Bryan

Guys: With Bryan Quinby

798 Listeners