This week, we go deep underground where the mole people live when Felicity and Julie get stuck in a subway car together. Noel and Ruby go on their first date, and Ben meets a rude caterer with a cookie crisis at Dean & Deluca. We pore over all the symbolism and mysticism in the episode as we finally find out: were Felicity and Julie ever really friends? We also throw it back to Boy Meets World, Don't Look Under the Bed, Before Sunrise, and so many more nostalgic favorites and lament that we never got to hear Julie's song. Let's dig deep on S2E4, "The Depths."