On episode 33 of The Storytellers Podcast, Andy Erwin sits down with actor John Michael Finley who plays Bart Millard of MercyMe in I Can Only Imagine 2. Andy and John discuss the original I Can Only Imagine, John's roles on Broadway and on the West End (including his time in Les Miserables and The Book of Mormon) and what returning to the screen with Dennis Quaid in I Can Only Imagine 2 meant to John. You can see John Michael Finley in Kingdom Story Company's upcoming "I Can Only Imagine 2" in theaters February 20, 2026. 

To connect with John Michael Finley, follow him on instagram: https://www.instagram.com/john_michael_finley/?hl=en

To connect with Andrew, follow him on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erwinbroandy/?hl=en

Make sure you never miss an episode by following us on Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube https://www.instagram.com/kingdomstorycompany/?hl=en

Join the conversation as a Kingdom Story Company Insider at www.kingdomstorycompany.com. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit <a href="https://megaphone.fm/adchoices">megaphone.fm/adchoices</a>

On episode 33 of The Storytellers Podcast, Andy Erwin sits down with actor John Michael Finley who plays Bart Millard of MercyMe in I Can Only Imagine 2. Andy and John discuss the original I Can Only Imagine, John's roles on Broadway and on the West End (including his time in Les Miserables and The Book of Mormon) and what returning to the screen with Dennis Quaid in I Can Only Imagine 2 meant to John. You can see John Michael Finley in Kingdom Story Company's upcoming "I Can Only Imagine 2" in theaters February 20, 2026. To connect with John Michael Finley, follow him on instagram: https://www.instagram.com/john_michael_finley/?hl=en To connect with Andrew, follow him on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erwinbroandy/?hl=en Make sure you never miss an episode by following us on Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube https://www.instagram.com/kingdomstorycompany/?hl=en Join the conversation as a Kingdom Story Company Insider at www.kingdomstorycompany.com. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

On episode 33 of The Storytellers Podcast, Andy Erwin sits down with actor John Michael Finley who plays Bart Millard of MercyMe in I Can Only Imagine 2. Andy and John discuss the original I Can Only Imagine, John's roles on Broadway and on the West End (including his time in Les Miserables and The Book of Mormon) and what returning to the screen with Dennis Quaid in I Can Only Imagine 2 meant to John. You can see John Michael Finley in Kingdom Story Company's upcoming "I Can Only Imagine 2" in theaters February 20, 2026. 

To connect with John Michael Finley, follow him on instagram: https://www.instagram.com/john_michael_finley/?hl=en

To connect with Andrew, follow him on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erwinbroandy/?hl=en

Make sure you never miss an episode by following us on Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube https://www.instagram.com/kingdomstorycompany/?hl=en

Join the conversation as a Kingdom Story Company Insider at www.kingdomstorycompany.com. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit <a href="https://megaphone.fm/adchoices" rel="noopener noreferrer">megaphone.fm/adchoices</a>

Episode 31: John Michael Finley - I Can Only Imagine 2

At Kingdom Story Company we truly believe that the right story can change your life. We invite you to experience this transformative power with us through conversations with our friends - where the art of storytelling intersects with faith, hope, and redemption.

Award-winning filmmaker Andrew Erwin has found his calling in crafting stories of the underdogs and rebels, the broken and the redeemed. As the director of films like ”I Can Only Imagine", "American Underdog", and "I Still Believe”, and a producer of “Jesus Revolution”, he knows a thing or two about the impact a story can have.

In each episode, Andrew delves into the heart of storytelling with fellow artists, exploring its transformative power through the lens of faith. From directors to actors, writers to musicians, and thought leaders to cultural icons, "The Storytellers" illuminates the divine spark that ignites creativity and shapes narratives that resonate with the soul. Through these candid discussions, you will gain insight into the challenges, triumphs, and profound moments of struggle and inspiration that guide these storytellers on their creative journeys.

Join Andrew and some of his closest friends as they guide you into the process of discovering the story you have to tell and reveal how they found theirs.

TV & Film

Religion & Spirituality

Christianity

Film Interviews

At Kingdom Story Company we truly believe that the right story can change your life. We invite you to experience this transformative power with us through conversations with our friends - where the art of storytelling intersects with faith, hope, and redemption. Award-winning filmmaker Andrew Erwin has found his calling in crafting stories of the underdogs and rebels, the broken and the redeemed. As the director of films like ”I Can Only Imagine", "American Underdog", and "I Still Believe”, and a producer of “Jesus Revolution”, he knows a thing or two about the impact a story can have. In each episode, Andrew delves into the heart of storytelling with fellow artists, exploring its transformative power through the lens of faith. From directors to actors, writers to musicians, and thought leaders to cultural icons, "The Storytellers" illuminates the divine spark that ignites creativity and shapes narratives that resonate with the soul. Through these candid discussions, you will gain insight into the challenges, triumphs, and profound moments of struggle and inspiration that guide these storytellers on their creative journeys. Join Andrew and some of his closest friends as they guide you into the process of discovering the story you have to tell and reveal how they found theirs.

Share Episode 31: John Michael Finley - I Can Only Imagine 2

Sign up to save your podcasts

Episode 31: John Michael Finley - I Can Only Imagine 2

Episode 31: John Michael Finley - I Can Only Imagine 2

More shows like The Storytellers with Andrew Erwin

The Joe Rogan Experience

The RELEVANT Podcast

Pints With Aquinas

The Fr. Mike Schmitz Catholic Podcast

WHOA That's Good Podcast

SmartLess

The Megyn Kelly Show

'The Radio Coffee House Show'

Morning Wire

The Candace Cameron Bure Podcast

The Tucker Carlson Show

Fail Better with David Duchovny

Candace