Felicity's birthday is not what she imagined. While Ben plans a surprise party for her, Felicity is trying to keep a secret of her own: waking up in bed next to Randy. She tries to track Randy down to figure out what happened between them during her drunken night at the frat house. Sean has a sore nut, and Noel's computer repair customer has a crush on him. We talk about testicular cancer's big moment in 2000 and if honesty is always the best policy. Let's rewatch S3E5 "Surprise" together!