Matthew Winkler was a respected minister, a devoted father, and the face of a seemingly perfect life—until his wife, Mary Winkler, shot him while he slept. What followed shocked their small Tennessee community and sparked a national debate about abuse, faith, and what really happens behind closed doors. In this episode, we unravel the events leading up to Matthew Winkler’s death, the secrets of their marriage, and the controversial trial that divided a nation.