Sam and Dr. Marshall Poe, the creator and chief editor of The New Books Network, explore the topic of plagiarism within the academic world amid the current climate of political division. They discuss the actions of political factions aimed at either identifying and removing academics who deliberately steal the work and words of others, or attacking those academics whose political beliefs do not align with their own. Poe argues that perfection is sometimes unattainable and emphasizes the significance of the errors being unintended. Through the lens of Roxanne Gay's situation, Sam and Marshall debate this contentious issue that has polarized the nation, all while considering the context of anti-Semitism and support for Palestinian rights.