In possibly our most entertaining and explosive episode yet, three previous cohosts return for an all out movie battle royal. While we do spend sometime taking a look at one of the lowest rated Best Picture winners, don’t be scared away if you’ve never seen “The Broadway Melody”. In this episode we have a well balanced debate revisiting some of the anti-Goodfellas/Gangs of New York comments made in the BPC pilot episode, as all sides are heard from. Also, in the spirit of “The Broadway Melody” holding the distinction of the lowest rated BP winner on Rotten Tomatoes, each co-host contributes three of their favorite movies ranked under 50% on RT. Finally, this weeks cohosts give their standing rankings of the films covered so far by BPC. A time stamp format is included below so you can navigate through the madness.

Next week Joey R returns to discuss GOING MY WAY.

Time Stamp Format

Grant Z’s 3 sub 50% Movies: 4:49

The Broadway Melody: 13:12

Artie B’s 3 sub 50% Movies: 40:35

Goodfellas: 52:29

Chris G’s 3 sub 50% Movies: 1:23:08

Gangs of NY: 1:35:20

KB’s sub 50% Movies: 2:05:36

Cohost’s Standing Rankings: 2:31:00