We're back with our mid-season fantasy draft check-in! We're revisiting the Season 1 characters we drafted onto our fantasy teams and evaluating how they've performed so far in Season 2. We'll break down each character's impact on the story, fantasy value, biggest moments, entertainment factor, and whether their stock has risen or fallen.

This conversation got so big that we had to split it into two episodes! Part 2 drops later this week, where we'll reveal which host has the strongest team so far—and whose draft picks have been the biggest disappointments.