One of the most hotly contested passages in the book of Romans is Romans 7:14-25. The specific problem passage is verse 14, which reads, “I am of the flesh, sold under sin.” The issue raised is how Paul can be writing of himself when he said in chapter 6 that Christians are not slaves to the flesh but rather slaves to God and righteousness in the previous chapter. How can Paul write of himself when he describes a person who has no victory over sin in the flesh?
Romans 7:13-20 (ESV)
Theologians have debated the following 2 sections of Romans for centuries as to their exact meaning. The debate centers on whether Paul is referring to a believer or non-believer in these verses. This discussion guide will lay out the arguments for both general positions and will be using Douglas Moo’s summary of the positions in his commentary on Romans.
Unbelieving Person
The word “I” is strongly connected with “the flesh” (vs14, 18, 25) suggesting that Paul is elaborating on the unbeliever’s condition mentioned in 7:5: being “in the flesh”
“I” throughout the passage struggles “on his/her own” (v25 I myself) without the aid of the Holy Spirit.
“I” is referred to as, “under the power of sin” (v14), a state from which every believer is released (6:2, 6, 11, 18-22).
As the unsuccessful struggle of vs15-20 shows, “I” is a “prisoner of the law of sin” (v23). Yet, Rom 8:2 proclaims that believers have been set free from this same “law of sin (and death)”
While Paul makes clear that believers will continue to struggle with sin (6:12-13; 13:12-14; Gal 5:17), what is depicted in this section in 7:13-25 is not a just a struggle with sin but a defeat by sin. This is a more negative view of the Christian life than can be accommodated within Paul’s theology.
The “I” in these verses struggles with the need to obey the Mosaic law; yet Paul has already proclaimed the release of the believer from the dictates of the law (6:14; 7:4-6).
Believing Person
“I” must refer to Paul himself, and the shift from the past tense in vs7-13 to the present tense in vs14-25 can be explained only if Paul is describing in these latter verses his present experience as a Christian.
Only the regenerate can truly “delight in God’s law” (v22), seek to obey it (vs15-20), and “serve” it (v25); the unregenerate do not “seek after God” (3:11) and cannot submit to the law of God (8:7).
Whereas Paul universally presents the “mind” of people outside of Christ as opposed to God and His will (Rom 1:28; Eph 4:17; Col 2:18; 1 Tim 6:5; 2 Tim 3:8; Titus 2:15), the mind of “I” in this text is a positive medium, by which “I” “serves the law of God” (v22, 25).
“I” must be a Christian because only a Christian possesses the “inner person”; Paul’s only other 2 uses of the phrase are in 2 Cor 4:16 and Eph 3:16.
The passage concludes after Paul mentions the deliverance won by God in Christ, with a reiteration of the divided state of the “I” (vs24-25). This shows that the division and struggle of the “I” that Paul depicts in these verses is that of a person already saved by God in Christ.
There are several “sub” views within each position with some believing Paul is speaking about his experience as an unbelieving Jew under the law, and others believe Paul is referring to a new, immature Christian who is struggling to live the Christian life under his/her own power. Keep in mind this is not a core doctrine of the Bible. There can be disagreement here, but we still find unity in the gospel.
Taking either position has implications for living the Christian life. I would recommend spending time considering what some of those implications could be and discussing them in your GCC.