TALKING POLITICS

Europe Blows Up


Listen Later

How does a judgement of the German constitutional court threaten to explode the European project? David talk to Helen Thompson, Adam Tooze and Shahin Vallee about what the court's decision might mean for the Euro, for the response to the pandemic, for Franco-German relations and for the future of central banks. Can the great European fudge continue? And what happens if it can't?


Plus a bonus chat with Ed Miliband and Geoff Lloyd from the ‘Reasons to be Cheerful Podcast’ https://www.cheerfulpodcast.com/



The German Constitutional Court ruled that the ECB’s QE program is illegal. 

  • It says that the German government has failed to control the ECB’s program and its compliance with the German constitution.
  • It ruled that the European Court of Justice made an illegal judgment.
  • And it gives the ECB 3 months to provide a clear analysis and a new decision. If not, the German government can’t continue to participate in QE.


This raises three fundamental political questions: 

  • Does EU law take precedence over national law? 
  • Has the ECB ventured too far outside of monetary policy?
  • Should the ECB’s independence be as absolute? 


Monetary union rested on a sharp distinction between monetary policy, which was going to be a matter for the EU, and the rest of economic policy, where there was going to be no federal authority.

  • The economic premise of monetary union is no longer supported by a great number of people in the monetary union.
  • Of course the advocates of the system believe the fudge.


This is a very political judgment. 

  • The ruling inadvertently opens the question not only about the financial constitution, but, more deeply, if it’s time for the monetary union to have a proper fiscal risk sharing instrument, a proper budget, and political accountability.
  • The judgment forces a conversation about the architecture of the monetary union.


Part of this judgment is about democratic control over otherwise unaccountable institutions.

  • The German Constitutional Court is one of the anchors of the success of German democratic model since 1949.
  • It acts as a driver of modern constitutional jurisprudence. 


Independent central banks were meant to reign in the inflationary tendencies of democratic governments. Now their primary role is to guard against the forces of deflation.

  • They have changed their character while maintaining their form.
  • The ECB’s QE was an absolutely massive bond buying scheme.
  • The court is registering the need to start talking about re-legitimising and redefining the role of central banks.   


Mentioned in this Episode:

  • The last time we talked to Adam
  • Adam on the death of the central bank myth


Further Learning: 

  • More on the German court’s decision
  • More on the Franco-German plan
  • Shahin on Macron


And as ever, recommended reading curated by our friends at the LRB can be found here: lrb.co.uk/talking

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

TALKING POLITICSBy David Runciman and Catherine Carr

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

622 ratings


More shows like TALKING POLITICS

View all
The LRB Podcast by The London Review of Books

The LRB Podcast

294 Listeners

Intelligence Squared by Intelligence Squared

Intelligence Squared

790 Listeners

In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,441 Listeners

LSE: Public lectures and events by London School of Economics and Political Science

LSE: Public lectures and events

272 Listeners

Political Fix by Financial Times

Political Fix

146 Listeners

Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

162 Listeners

The New Statesman: politics and culture by The New Statesman

The New Statesman: politics and culture

146 Listeners

The Briefing Room by BBC Radio 4

The Briefing Room

69 Listeners

Inside Briefing with the Institute for Government by Institute for Government

Inside Briefing with the Institute for Government

17 Listeners

The Bunker – News without the nonsense by Podmasters

The Bunker – News without the nonsense

110 Listeners

Talking Politics: HISTORY OF IDEAS by Talking Politics

Talking Politics: HISTORY OF IDEAS

479 Listeners

Ones and Tooze by Foreign  Policy

Ones and Tooze

351 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: Leading by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: Leading

859 Listeners

Past Present Future by David Runciman

Past Present Future

320 Listeners

How To Win An Election by The Times

How To Win An Election

20 Listeners

Origin Story by Podmasters

Origin Story

117 Listeners